Comments on “Single paper meta-analysis is unavoidable”

doi:10.1002/jcpy.70002

2025-08-26

PRE

DOI：10.1002/jcpy.70002

原文链接

原文求助

摘要

En 中文

布莱克利·麦克沙恩和乌尔夫·博肯霍尔特在《消费者心理学杂志》（2025年）发表的对话式文章对行为学者分析及呈现其研究成果的方式提出了有力的批判。最初的文章文稿发送给了四位资深学者，他们同意为作者提供公开的合作指导。在修订后的文稿被接受后，合作作者及其他人员提供了以下最终反馈。克里斯蒂安·惠勒总结了麦克沙恩和博肯霍尔特的建议，并阐释了这些建议对当前研究实践的影响。他认为，单篇元分析通过使研究者更好地理解经验关系中的固有变异，从而促进了社会科学中的理论发展。

Keyword:

casual reasoning

experimental psychology

philosophy of science

期刊

Journal of Consumer Psychology

IF:

6.1

论文数:

1.3K

被引数:

8.5K

机构

Duke University

学者数:

6.3W

论文数: 5.7W

被引数: 6.5W

Stanford University

学者数:

9.6W

论文数: 8.2W

被引数: 17.0W

The Ohio State University

学者数:

4.2K

论文数: 1.7K

被引数: 7.4W

查看更多机构

引用论文

Correcting the record on financial education: Smaller effects after adjusting for publication bias 纠正金融教育记录：在调整发表偏倚后效果更小

IF0

PREAI

Exposing omitted moderators: Explaining why effect sizes differ in the social sciences 暴露遗漏的主持人: 解释为什么社会科学中的效应大小不同

PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

IF9.1

2024-03-11

OAAI

Krefeld-Schwalb, Antonia; Sugerman, Eli Rosen; Johnson, Eric J.

Single-Paper Meta-Analysis: Benefits for Study Summary, Theory Testing, and Replicability 单篇论文荟萃分析: 研究总结、理论测试和可复制性的好处

JOURNAL OF CONSUMER RESEARCH

IF6.4

2017-01-23

371

PREAI

McShane, Blakeley B.; Bockenholt, Ulf

CAPTURING AND CREATING PUBLIC-OPINION IN SURVEY-RESEARCH

JOURNAL OF CONSUMER RESEARCH

IF6.4

1993-09-01

PREAI

SIMMONS, CJ; BICKART, BA; LYNCH, JG

Identification of and Correction for Publication Bias

AMERICAN ECONOMIC REVIEW

IF11.6

2019-08-01

188

OAAI

Andrews, Isaiah; Kasy, Maximilian

Estimating the reproducibility of psychological science 估计心理科学的可重复性

SCIENCE

IF45.8

2015-08-28

4.2K

OAAI

Aarts, Alexander A.; Anderson, Joanna E.; Anderson, Christopher J.; Attridge, Peter R.; Attwood, Angela; Axt, Jordan; Babel, Molly; Bahnik, Stepan; Baranski, Erica; Barnett-Cowan, Michael; Bartmess, Elizabeth; Beer, Jennifer; Bell, Raoul; Bentley, Heather; Beyan, Leah; Binion, Grace; Borsboom, Denny; Bosch, Annick; Bosco, Frank A.; Bowman, Sara D.; Brandt, Mark J.; Braswell, Erin; Brohmer, Hilmar; Brown, Benjamin T.; Brown, Kristina; Bruening, Jovita; Calhoun-Sauls, Ann; Callahan, Shannon P.; Chagnon, Elizabeth; Chandler, Jesse; Chartier, Christopher R.; Cheung, Felix; Christopherson, Cody D.; Cillessen, Linda; Clay, Russ; Cleary, Hayley; Cloud, Mark D.; Cohn, Michael; Cohoon, Johanna; Columbus, Simon; Cordes, Andreas; Costantini, Giulio; Alvarez, Leslie D. Cramblet; Cremata, Ed; Crusius, Jan; DeCoster, Jamie; DeGaetano, Michelle A.; Della Penna, Nicolas; den Bezemer, Bobby; Deserno, Marie K.; Devitt, Olivia; Dewitte, Laura; Dobolyi, David G.; Dodson, Geneva T.; Donnellan, M. Brent; Donohue, Ryan; Dore, Rebecca A.; Dorrough, Angela; Dreber, Anna; Dugas, Michelle; Dunn, Elizabeth W.; Easey, Kayleigh; Eboigbe, Sylvia; Eggleston, Casey; Embley, Jo; Epskamp, Sacha; Errington, Timothy M.; Estel, Vivien; Farach, Frank J.; Feather, Jenelle; Fedor, Anna; Fernandez-Castilla, Belen; Fiedler, Susann; Field, James G.; Fitneva, Stanka A.; Flagan, Taru; Forest, Amanda L.; Forsell, Eskil; Foster, Joshua D.; Frank, Michael C.; Frazier, Rebecca S.; Fuchs, Heather; Gable, Philip; Galak, Jeff; Galliani, Elisa Maria; Gampa, Anup; Garcia, Sara; Gazarian, Douglas; Gilbert, Elizabeth; Giner-Sorolla, Roger; Gloeckner, Andreas; Goellner, Lars; Goh, Jin X.; Goldberg, Rebecca; Goodbourn, Patrick T.; Gordon-McKeon, Shauna; Gorges, Bryan; Gorges, Jessie; Goss, Justin; Graham, Jesse; Grange, James A.; Gray, Jeremy; Hartgerink, Chris; Hartshorne, Joshua; Hasselman, Fred; Hayes, Timothy; Heikensten, Emma; Henninger, Felix; Hodsoll, John; Holubar, Taylor; Hoogendoorn, Gea; Humphries, Denise J.; Hung, Cathy O. -Y.; Immelman, Nathali; Irsik, Vanessa C.; Jahn, Georg; Jaekel, Frank; Jekel, Marc; Johannesson, Magnus; Johnson, Larissa G.; Johnson, David J.; Johnson, Kate M.; Johnston, William J.; Jonas, Kai; Joy-Gaba, Jennifer A.; Kappes, Heather Barry; Kelso, Kim; Kidwell, Mallory C.; Kim, Seung Kyung; Kirkhart, Matthew; Kleinberg, Bennett; Knezevic, Goran; Kolorz, Franziska Maria; Kossakowski, Jolanda J.; Krause, Robert Wilhelm; Krijnen, Job; Kuhlmann, Tim; Kunkels, Yoram K.; Kyc, Megan M.; Lai, Calvin K.; Laique, Aamir; Lakens, Daniel; Lane, Kristin A.; Lassetter, Bethany; Lazarevic, Ljiljana B.; LeBel, Etienne P.; Lee, Key Jung; Lee, Minha; Lemm, Kristi; Levitan, Carmel A.; Lewis, Melissa; Lin, Lin; Lin, Stephanie; Lippold, Matthias; Loureiro, Darren; Luteijn, Ilse; Mackinnon, Sean; Mainard, Heather N.; Marigold, Denise C.; Martin, Daniel P.; Martinez, Tylar; Masicampo, E. J.; Matacotta, Josh; Mathur, Maya; May, Michael; Mechin, Nicole; Mehta, Pranjal; Meixner, Johannes; Melinger, Alissa; Miller, Jeremy K.; Miller, Mallorie; Moore, Katherine; Moeschl, Marcus; Motyl, Matt; Mueller, Stephanie M.; Munafo, Marcus; Neijenhuijs, Koen I.; Nervi, Taylor; Nicolas, Gandalf; Nilsonne, Gustav; Nosek, Brian A.; Nuijten, Michele B.; Olsson, Catherine; Osborne, Colleen; Ostkamp, Lutz; Pavel, Misha; Penton-Voak, Ian S.; Perna, Olivia; Pernet, Cyril; Perugini, Marco; Pipitone, R. Nathan; Pitts, Michael; Plessow, Franziska; Prenoveau, Jason M.; Rahal, Rima-Maria; Ratliff, Kate A.; Reinhard, David; Renkewitz, Frank; Ricker, Ashley A.; Rigney, Anastasia; Rivers, Andrew M.; Roebke, Mark; Rutchick, Abraham M.; Ryan, Robert S.; Sahin, Onur; Saide, Anondah; Sandstrom, Gillian M.; Santos, David; Saxe, Rebecca; Schlegelmilch, Rene; Schmidt, Kathleen; Scholz, Sabine; Seibel, Larissa; Selterman, Dylan Faulkner; Shaki, Samuel; Simpson, William B.; Sinclair, H. Colleen; Skorinko, Jeanine L. M.; Slowik, Agnieszka; Snyder, Joel S.; Soderberg, Courtney; Sonnleitner, Carina; Spencer, Nick; Spies, Jeffrey R.; Steegen, Sara; Stieger, Stefan; Strohminger, Nina; Sullivan, Gavin B.; Talhelm, Thomas; Tapia, Megan; te Dorsthorst, Anniek; Thomae, Manuela; Thomas, Sarah L.; Tio, Pia; Traets, Frits; Tsang, Steve; Tuerlinckx, Francis; Turchan, Paul; Valasek, Milan; van 't Veer, Anna E.; Van Aert, Robbie; van Assen, Marcel; van Bork, Riet; van de Ven, Mathijs; van den Bergh, Don; van der Hulst, Marije; van Dooren, Roel; van Doorn, Johnny; van Renswoude, Daan R.; van Rijn, Hedderik; Vanpaemel, Wolf; Echeverria, Alejandro Vasquez; Vazquez, Melissa; Velez, Natalia; Vermue, Marieke; Verschoor, Mark; Vianello, Michelangelo; Voracek, Martin; Vuu, Gina; Wagenmakers, Eric-Jan; Weerdmeester, Joanneke; Welsh, Ashlee; Westgate, Erin C.; Wissink, Joeri; Wood, Michael; Woods, Andy; Wright, Emily; Wu, Sining; Zeelenberg, Marcel; Zuni, Kellylynn

Addressing Disturbing and Disturbed Consumer Behavior: Is it Necessary to Change the Way We Conduct Behavioral Science?

Journal of Marketing Research

IF0

1996-02-01

PREAI

Richard E. Petty; John T. Cacioppo

Effect sizes for experimenting psychologists.

Canadian Journal of Experimental Psychology / Revue canadienne de psychologie expérimentale

IF0

2003-09-01

PREAI

Ralph L. Rosnow; Robert Rosenthal