arrow
返回

Defusing Bertrand's Paradox

delete2015-06-01
delete9
delete
OA
AI
Z
Zalán Gyenis *
M
Miklós Rédei
DOI:10.1093/bjps/axt036delete
delete原文链接
delete原文求助
delete分享
delete收藏
摘要

摘要

En 中文
The classical interpretation of probability together with the principle of indifference is formulated in terms of probability measure spaces in which the probability is given by the Haar measure. A notion called labelling invariance is defined in the category of Haar probability spaces; it is shown that labelling invariance is violated, and Bertrand's paradox is interpreted as the proof of violation of labelling invariance. It is shown that Bangu's ([2010]) attempt to block the emergence of Bertrand's paradox by requiring the re-labelling of random events to preserve randomness cannot succeed non-trivially. A non-trivial strategy to preserve labelling invariance is identified, and it is argued that, under the interpretation of Bertrand's paradox suggested in the paper, the paradox does not undermine either the principle of indifference or the classical interpretation and is in complete harmony with how mathematical probability theory is used in the sciences to model phenomena. It is shown in particular that violation of labelling invariance does not entail that labelling of random events affects the probabilities of random events. It also is argued, however, that the content of the principle of indifference cannot be specified in such a way that it can establish the classical interpretation of probability as descriptively accurate or predictively successful.
Keyword:
COMPACT-GROUPS

期刊

British Journal of Political Science 封面图
British Journal of Political Science
IF:
4.7
论文数:
2.2K
被引数:
6.7K

机构

C
Central European University
学者数:
381
论文数: 471
被引数: 476
U
university of london
学者数:
21.5W
论文数: 19.7W
被引数: 305
引用论文

引用论文

Manganese, Mn-dependent peroxidases, and the biodegradation of lignin
err1988-12-01
err0
PREAI
errIan T. Forrester; Anthony C. Grabski; Richard R. Burgess; Gary F. Leatham
err分享
err收藏
Introduction to agricultural IoT
err2020-01-01
err0
errOAAI
errLucio Colizzi; Danilo Caivano; Carmelo Ardito; Giuseppe Desolda; Annamaria Castrignanò; Maristella Matera; Raj Khosla; Dimitrios Moshou; Kun-Mean Hou; François Pinet; Jean-Pierre Chanet; Gao Hui; Hongling Shi
err分享
err收藏
Adaptive optics performance of a simulated coronagraph instrument on a large, segmented space telescope in steady state
err2022-09-23
err0
errOAAI
errAxel Potier; Garreth Ruane; Chris Stark; Pin Chen; Ankur Chopra; Larry Dewell; Roser Juanola-Parramon; Alison Nordt; Laurent Pueyo; David Redding; A J Eldorado Riggs; Dan Sirbu
err分享
err收藏
Modeling of DNA hybridization detection using methylene blue as an electroactive label
err2012-08-04
err0
PREAI
errB. Sehatnia; F. Golabi; M. H. Pournaghi-Azar; R. E. Sabzi; M. S. Hejazi
err分享
err收藏
err分享
err收藏
err分享
err收藏
学者 查看更多内容