Ethical principles shaping values-based cybersecurity decision-making

Joseph Fenech

doi:10.1016/j.cose.2024.103795

2024-05-01

Joseph Fenech

Deborah Richards *

Paul Formosa

DOI：10.1016/j.cose.2024.103795

原文链接

查看原文

摘要

En 中文

The human factor in information systems is a large vulnerability when implementing cybersecurity, and many approaches, including technical and policy driven solutions, seek to mitigate this vulnerability. Decisions to apply technical or policy solutions must consider how an individual's values and moral stance influence their responses to these implementations. Our research aims to evaluate how individuals prioritise different ethical principles when making cybersecurity sensitive decisions and how much perceived choice they have when doing so. Further, we sought to use participants' responses to cybersecurity scenarios to create profiles that describe their values and individual factors including personality. Participants (n = 193) in our study responded to five different ethically sensitive cybersecurity scenarios in random order, selecting their action in that scenario and rating and ranking of the ethical principles (i.e., Beneficence, Non-Maleficence, Justice, Autonomy, Explicability) behind that action. Using participants' demographics, personality, values, and cyber hygiene practices, we created profiles using machine learning to predict participants' choices and the principle of most importance to them across scenarios. Further, we found that, generalising, for our participants Autonomy was the most important ethical principle in our scenarios, followed by Justice. Our study also suggests that participants felt they had some agency in their decision making and they were able to weigh up different ethical principles.

Keyword:

Cybersecurity sensitive decision -making

Ethical principles

Ethics training

Profiling

Human agency