arrow
返回

Evaluating space-based methane detection through a one-year blind test

delete2026-10-14
delete0
PRE
AI
F
Frances Reuland
T
Taylor Adams
E
Evan David Sherwin
S
Sahar H. El Abbadi
E
Eric A. Kort
A
Adam R. Brandt *
DOI:10.1038/s41586-026-11115-0delete
delete原文链接
delete原文求助
delete分享
delete收藏
摘要

摘要

En 中文
基于空间遥感可实现全球大型、集中甲烷源的检测与监测。然而,仪器和算法的独立评估有限,且新卫星和人工智能技术尚未在受控、单盲条件下进行测试。本研究开展了一项为期一年的单盲测试,涉及746个事件:481次甲烷释放(释放量9.5–1,183.7 kg h−1)和265次空白对照。在美国亚利桑那州释放定量的甲烷,并配合12颗政府、商业和非营利卫星的过境时间。来自9个国家的15个分析团队生成了超过2,250个估算值,据我们所知,这是迄今为止规模最大的受控测试,也是对EMIT、Tanager-1(Carbon Mapper)和GHOSt仪器首批评估之一。性能存在异质性:专为甲烷目标设计的“专用”仪器表现出优异的检测性能(真阳性率92–100%,假阳性率0–11%)和量化精度(斜率0.83–1.00,平均绝对百分比误差44%)。用于甲烷传感的改用仪器性能更不稳定(检测率62–88%,平均绝对百分比误差46%),但多数仍表现出显著能力。广域扫描仪在测试释放率下检测能力较弱,但具有一致的全局覆盖和历史档案,这为后续工作提供了动力。基于人工智能的方法显示出潜力,但需谨慎;79%的假阳性由此类方法产生。地面测量的云量>20%会降低各系统的性能,引发在某些地区使用的担忧。研究发现,当源位置大致已知时,卫星测量可实现甲烷点源的高精度检测与量化。一项为期一年的单盲研究显示,多颗卫星能够准确检测和量化甲烷点源排放。

期刊

Nature 封面图
Nature
IF:
48.5
论文数:
1.8W
被引数:
96.5W

机构

U
University of Iowa
学者数:
462
论文数: 179
被引数: 0
S
Stanford University
学者数:
1.2K
论文数: 481
被引数: 0
U
university of michigan
学者数:
1.3K
论文数: 580
被引数: 0
U
university of california berkeley
学者数:
196
论文数: 105
被引数: 0
学者 查看更多机构
引用论文

引用论文

Space‐based remote imaging spectroscopy of the Aliso Canyon CH4 superemitter
err2016-06-20
err0
errOAAI
errD. R. Thompson; A. K. Thorpe; C. Frankenberg; R. O. Green; R. Duren; L. Guanter; A. Hollstein; E. Middleton; L. Ong; S. Ungar
err分享
err收藏
err分享
err收藏
err分享
err收藏
Single-blind test of nine methane-sensing satellite systems from three continents
err2024-01-31
err14
errOAAI
errSherwin, Evan D.; El Abbadi, Sahar H.; Burdeau, Philippine M.; Zhang, Zhan; Chen, Zhenlin; Rutherford, Jeffrey S.; Chen, Yuanlei; Brandt, Adam R.
err分享
err收藏
Technological Maturity of Aircraft-Based Methane Sensing for Greenhouse Gas Mitigation
err2024-05-17
err5
errOAAI
errEl Abbadi, Sahar H.; Chen, Zhenlin; Burdeau, Philippine M.; Rutherford, Jeffrey S.; Chen, Yuanlei; Zhang, Zhan; Sherwin, Evan D.; Brandt, Adam R.
err分享
err收藏
High-Resolution Methane Mapping With the EnMAP Satellite Imaging Spectroscopy Mission
err2024-01-01
err13
errOAAI
errRoger, Javier; Irakulis-Loitxate, Itziar; Valverde, Adriana; Gorrono, Javier; Chabrillat, Sabine; Brell, Maximilian; Guanter, Luis
err分享
err收藏
Satellite-based survey of extreme methane emissions in the Permian basin
err2021-07-02
err101
errOAAI
errIrakulis-Loitxate, Itziar; Guanter, Luis; Liu, Yin-Nian; Varon, Daniel J.; Maasakkers, Joannes D.; Zhang, Yuzhong; Chulakadabba, Apisada; Wofsy, Steven C.; Thorpe, Andrew K.; Duren, Riley M.; Frankenberg, Christian; Lyon, David R.; Hmiel, Benjamin; Cusworth, Daniel H.; Zhang, Yongguang; Segl, Karl; Gorrono, Javier; Sanchez-Garcia, Elena; Sulprizio, Melissa P.; Cao, Kaiqin; Zhu, Haijian; Liang, Jian; Li, Xun; Aben, Ilse; Jacob, Daniel J.
err分享
err收藏
Global Identification of Solid Waste Methane Super Emitters Using Hyperspectral Satellites利用高光谱卫星全球识别固体废物甲烷超级排放源
err
err0
errOAAI
errXin Zhang; Joannes D. Maasakkers; Javier Roger; Luis Guanter; Shubham Sharma; Srijana Lama; Paul Tol; Daniel J. Varon; Daniel H. Cusworth; Katherine Howell; Andrew K. Thorpe; Philip G. Brodrick; Ilse Aben
err分享
err收藏
The Carbon Mapper emissions monitoring systemDuren, R.; Cusworth, D.; Ayasse, A.; Howell, K.; Diamond, A.; Scarpelli, T.; Kim, J.; O’neill, K.; Lai-Norling, J.; Thorpe, A.; et al. 碳 Mapper 排放监测系统。arXiv 2025. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
err2025-11-24
err1
PREAI
errDuren, Riley; Cusworth, Daniel; Ayasse, Alana; Howell, Katherine; Diamond, Alex; Scarpelli, Tia; Kim, Jinsol; O'neill, Kelly; Lai-Norling, Judy; Thorpe, Andrew; Zandbergen, Sander R.; Shaw, Lucas; Keremedjiev, Mark; Guido, Jeff; Giuliano, Paul; Goldstein, Malkam; Nallapu, Ravi; Barentsen, Geert; Thompson, David R.; Roth, Keely; Jensen, Daniel; Eastwood, Michael; Reuland, Frances; Adams, Taylor; Brandt, Adam; Kort, Eric A.; Mason, James; Green, Robert O.
err分享
err收藏
The GHGSat-D imaging spectrometer
err2021-03-18
err104
errOAAI
errJervis, Dylan; McKeever, Jason; Durak, Berke O. A.; Sloan, James J.; Gains, David; Varon, Daniel J.; Ramier, Antoine; Strupler, Mathias; Tarrant, Ewan
err分享
err收藏
学者 查看更多内容