.png){kind=icon}
返回
Five fallacies to avoid for future spatial development practice
.png){kind=icon}
OA
AI
DOI：10.1080/09654313.2025.2535463.png)
.png){kind=icon}
原文求助.png){kind=icon}
分享.png){kind=icon}
收藏
摘要
En 中文
In this brief essay, we introduce several fallacies that are seldom confronted in spatial planning studies and practice. The presentation is set within the context of the now-emergent ‘polycrisis’ and its aftermath as evolutionary change works its way through large-scale processes that have been confronting humanity in unpredictable ways and unexpected locations. We offer reflections on five fallacies that challenge interventionist thinking, which is nowadays clearly inadequate to the scale of prevailing conditions. The first of these is the ‘fallacy of intentionality’, which highlights the common contemporary policy failure of confusing the announcement of an intention to do something with actual investment in a workable output or, more importantly, outcome. The second is the ‘fallacy of inadequacy’, which, in effect, announces a measure that is neither adequately costed nor properly planned, taking it for granted that the policy’s failure will ultimately be borne by those affected (the Valencian floods serve as a case in point). Third is the ‘fallacy of learning’, which posits that solutions can be copied from apparently successful efforts that fall into the ‘one size fits all’ category and are largely irrelevant to the specific change trajectory of interest. The fourth policy input is the ‘fallacy of composition’, a common critique of ‘sample of one’ thinking. This assumes that a description of a place and its problems are universally applicable and that generic measures will work equally universally. Finally, the ‘fallacy of agentic evolution’ is shown to have minimal application in the real world, where issues can only be addressed through institutional interaction on a grand scale, cascading differences down to the granular policy level to protect populations confronted with disruptive market and climatic processes and events.
Keyword:
Intentionality
inadequacy
learning
composition
agency
期刊
IF:
3.2
论文数:
294
被引数:
5.8K
机构
引用论文
Banks, D. 2021. “The Attention Economy of Authentic Cities: How Cities Behave Like Influencers.” European Planning Studies 30: 195–209. https://doi.org/10.1080/09654313.2021.1882947. (Open in a new window)Web of Science ®(Open in a new window)Google ScholarBanks, D. 2021. “真实城市的注意力经济：城市如何像影响者一样行为。”欧洲规划研究 30: 195–209. https://doi.org/10.1080/09654313.2021.1882947. (在新窗口中打开)Web of Science ®(在新窗口中打开)Google Scholar.png)
IF0
PREAI
分享收藏Cooke, P. 2022. “Beyond the Smart or Resilient City: In Search of Sustainability in the Sojan Thirdspace.” Sustainability 14: p. 145. https://doi.org/10.20944/preprints202209.0469.v1. (Open in a new window)Google ScholarCooke, P. 2022. “超越智慧城市或韧性城市：在索ajan第三空间中寻求可持续性。”《可持续发展》14: 第145页。https://doi.org/10.20944/preprints202209.0469.v1. (在新窗口中打开)Google Scholar
IF0
PREAI
分享收藏Cooke, P. 2020. “Gigafactory Logistics in Space and Time: Tesla’s Fourth Gigafactory and its Rivals.” Sustainability 12: p. 2044. https://doi.org/10.3390/su12052044. (Open in a new window)Web of Science ®(Open in a new window)Google ScholarCooke, P. 2020. “Gigafactory Logistics in Space and Time: Tesla’s Fourth Gigafactory and its Rivals.” Sustainability 12: p. 2044. https://doi.org/10.3390/su12052044. (在新窗口中打开) Web of Science ®(在新窗口中打开) Google Scholar
IF0
PREAI
分享收藏Yeung, H. 2022. “Explaining Geographic Shifts of Chip Making towards East Asia and Market Dynamics in Semiconductor Global Production Networks.” Economic Geography 98 (3): 272–298. https://doi.org/10.1080/00130095.2021.2019010 (Open in a new window)Web of Science ®(Open in a new window)Google Scholar杨 (Yeung, H. 2022)。 “解释芯片制造地理格局向东亚转移及半导体全球生产网络中的市场动态。” 经济地理学 98 (3): 272–298。 https://doi.org/10.1080/00130095.2021.2019010 (在新窗口打开) Web of Science ®(在新窗口打开) Google Scholar
IF0
PREAI
分享收藏Cooke, P. 2025. “Translating Specialist versus Diversified Business Models into Spatial Planning? Dark Limitations and Lighter Inspirations.” In The Oxford Handbook of Spatial Diversity and Business Economics, edited by Wixe et al., 92–109. Oxford: Oxford University Press. (Open in a new window)Google ScholarCooke, P. 2025. “将专业化与多元化商业模式转化为空间规划？暗藏的局限与积极的启示。”载于《空间多样性与商业经济学牛津手册》（Wixe等编），第92-109页。牛津：牛津大学出版社。（在新窗口中打开）Google Scholar
IF0
PREAI
分享收藏Lindsay, G., and M. Sawyer. 2021. “A Constellation of Stars: What a Local Newspaper Talks About When it Talks About Star Architecture.” European Planning Studies 30: 66–84. https://doi.org/10.1080/09654313.2021.1892031. (Open in a new window)Web of Science ®(Open in a new window)Google ScholarLindsay, G., and M. Sawyer. 2021. “A Constellation of Stars: What a Local Newspaper Talks About When it Talks About Star Architecture.” European Planning Studies 30: 66–84. https://doi.org/10.1080/09654313.2021.1892031. (在新窗口中打开)Web of Science ®(在新窗口中打开)Google Scholar
IF0
PREAI
分享收藏Marx, A., B. Rihoux, and C. Ragin. 2013. “The Origins, Development, and Application of Qualitative Comparative Analysis: The First 25 Years.” European Political Science Review 6 (1): 115–142. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1755773912000318. (Open in a new window)Google Scholar马克思（Marx），A.，B. 里霍克斯（Rihoux），和 C. 拉金（Ragin）。2013年。“定性比较分析的起源、发展与运用：最初的25年。”《欧洲政治科学评论》6（1）：115–142。https://doi.org/10.1017/S1755773912000318. (在新窗口中打开)Google Scholar
IF0
PREAI
分享收藏Ahn, B. 2024. “What Changes Over Time? Planning History and Institutional Change from a Policy Design Perspective.” European Planning Studies 32 (12): 2535–2554. https://doi.org/10.1080/09654313.2024.2377796. (Open in a new window)Web of Science ®(Open in a new window)Google ScholarAhn, B. 2024. “随着时间推移发生什么变化？从政策设计视角看规划史与制度变迁。”欧洲规划研究 32 (12): 2535–2554. https://doi.org/10.1080/09654313.2024.2377796. (在新窗口中打开)Web of Science ®(在新窗口中打开)Google Scholar
IF0
PREAI
分享收藏Boschma, R. A., & Frenken, K. (2006). Why is economic geography not an evolutionary science? Towards an evolutionary economic geography. Journal of Economic Geography, 6(3), 273–302. https://doi.org/10.1093/jeg/lbi022 (Open in a new window)Web of Science ®(Open in a new window)Google ScholarBoschma, R. A., & Frenken, K. (2006). 经济地理学为何不是一门演化科学？——迈向演化经济地理学。经济地理学杂志, 6(3), 273–302. https://doi.org/10.1093/jeg/lbi022 (在新窗口中打开)Web of Science ®(在新窗口中打开)Google Scholar
IF0
PREAI
分享收藏
查看更多内容