arrow
返回

Flexibility versus generalizability in model selection

delete2003-03-01
delete51
delete
OA
AI
M
Mark A. Pitt *
W
Woojae Kim
I
In Jae Myung
DOI:10.3758/BF03196467delete
delete原文链接
delete分享
delete收藏
查看原文
摘要

摘要

En 中文
Which quantitative method should be used to choose among competing mathematical models of cognition? Massaro, Cohen, Campbell, and Rodriguez (2001) favor root mean squared deviation (RMSD), choosing the model that provides the best fit to the data. Their simulation results appear to legitimize its use for comparing two models of information integration because it performed just as well as Bayesian model selection (BMS), which had previously been shown by Myung and Pitt (1997) to be a superior alternative selection method because it considers a model's complexity in addition to its fit. In the present study, after contrasting the theoretical approaches to model selection espoused by Massaro et al. and Myung and Pitt, we discuss the cause of the inconsistencies by expanding on the simulations of Massaro et al. Findings demonstrate that the results from model recovery simulations can be misleading if they are not interpreted relative to the data on which they were evaluated, and that BMS is a more robust selection method.
Keyword:
MINIMUM DESCRIPTION LENGTH
COGNITION
AI总结

AI总结

对已上传原文的论文进行重点信息的提取,主要内容包括:简要概述、研究摘要、背景介绍、关键亮点、图文解析、展望与总结。

期刊

P
Psychonomic Bulletin and Review
IF:
3
论文数:
4.5K
被引数:
1.5W

机构

暂无机构信息
引用论文

引用论文

Increasing the dynamic range for the analysis of boron in PGAA
err2013-09-15
err0
errOAAI
errStefan Söllradl; Hanna Lührs; Zsolt Révay; Petra Kudejova; Lea Canella; Andreas Türler
err分享
err收藏
Patient-Reported Outcomes After Chemoradiation in Patients With Anal Cancer: A Qualitative Analysis
err2022-07-01
err0
errOAAI
errKelsey L. Corrigan; Brian De; Michael K. Rooney; Ethan B. Ludmir; Prajnan Das; Grace L. Smith; Cullen M. Taniguchi; Bruce D. Minsky; Eugene J. Koay; Albert C. Koong; Emma B. Holliday
err分享
err收藏
Transitions between superstatistical regimes: Validity, breakdown and applications
err2018-03-01
err0
errOAAI
errPetr Jizba; Jan Korbel; Hynek Lavička; Martin Prokš; Václav Svoboda; Christian Beck
err分享
err收藏
Methods for comparing the diversity of samples of the T cell receptor repertoire
err2007-04-01
err0
PREAI
errVanessa Venturi; Katherine Kedzierska; Stephen J. Turner; Peter C. Doherty; Miles P. Davenport
err分享
err收藏
Bayes factor of model selection validates FLMP
err2001-03-01
err29
errOAAI
errMassaro, DW; Cohen, MM; Campbell, CS; Rodriguez, T
err分享
err收藏
Intraparenchymal meningioma in a 14-month-old infant: Case report
err1985-01-01
err0
PREAI
errEric Legius; Johan S Vles; Paul Casaer; Christiaan Plets; René Dom
err分享
err收藏
学者 查看更多内容