How Java APIs break - An empirical study

Kamil Ježek

doi:10.1016/j.infsof.2015.02.014

How Java APIs break - An empirical study

2015-09-01

41

PRE

AI

DOI：10.1016/j.infsof.2015.02.014

原文链接

摘要

En 中文

Context: It has become common practice to build programs by using libraries. While the benefits of reuse are well known, an often overlooked risk are system runtime failures due to API changes in libraries that evolve independently. Traditionally, the consistency between a program and the libraries it uses is checked at build time when the entire system is compiled and tested. However, the trend towards partially upgrading systems by redeploying only evolved library versions results in situations where these crucial verification steps are skipped. For Java programs, partial upgrades create additional interesting problems as the compiler and the virtual machine use different rule sets to enforce contracts between the providers and the consumers of APIs. Objective: We have studied the extent of the problem in real world programs. We were interested in two aspects: the compatibility of API changes as libraries evolve, and the impact this has on programs using these libraries. Method: This study is based on the qualitas corpus version 20120401. A data set consisting of 109 Java open-source programs and 564 program versions was used from this corpus. We have investigated two types of library dependencies: explicit dependencies to embedded libraries, and dependencies defined by symbolic references in Maven build files that are resolved at build time. We have used JaCC for API analysis, this tool is based on the popular ASM byte code analysis library. Results: We found that for most of the programs we investigated, APIs are unstable as incompatible changes are common. Surprisingly, there are more compatibility problems in projects that use automated dependency resolution. However, we found only a few cases where this has an actual impact on other programs using such an API. Conclusion: It is concluded that API instability is common and causes problems for programs using these APIs. Therefore, better tools and methods are needed to safeguard library evolution. (C) 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Keyword:

Binary compatibility

API evolution

Backward compatibility

Byte-code

Java

How Java APIs break - An empirical study

摘要

AI总结

期刊

机构

引用论文