arrow
返回

Knowledge before belief

delete2020-09-08
delete45
PRE
AI
J
Jonathan Phillips *
W
Wesley Buckwalter
F
Fiery Cushman
O
Ori Friedman
A
Alia Martin
J
John Turri
L
Laurie R. Santos
J
Joshua Knobe
DOI:10.1017/S0140525X20000618delete
delete原文链接
delete分享
delete收藏
摘要

摘要

En 中文
Research on the capacity to understand others' minds has tended to focus on representations of beliefs, which are widely taken to be among the most central and basic theory of mind representations. Representations of knowledge, by contrast, have received comparatively little attention and have often been understood as depending on prior representations of belief. After all, how could one represent someone as knowing something if one does not even represent them as believing it? Drawing on a wide range of methods across cognitive science, we ask whether belief or knowledge is the more basic kind of representation. The evidence indicates that nonhuman primates attribute knowledge but not belief, that knowledge representations arise earlier in human development than belief representations, that the capacity to represent knowledge may remain intact in patient populations even when belief representation is disrupted, that knowledge (but not belief) attributions are likely automatic, and that explicit knowledge attributions are made more quickly than equivalent belief attributions. Critically, the theory of mind representations uncovered by these various methods exhibits a set of signature features clearly indicative of knowledge: they are not modality-specific, they are factive, they are not just true belief, and they allow for representations of egocentric ignorance. We argue that these signature features elucidate the primary function of knowledge representation: facilitating learning from others about the external world. This suggests a new way of understanding theory of mind - one that is focused on understanding others' minds in relation to the actual world, rather than independent from it.
Keyword:
belief
factivity
false belief
knowledge
knowledge-first
theory of mind
AI总结

AI总结

对已上传原文的论文进行重点信息的提取,主要内容包括:简要概述、研究摘要、背景介绍、关键亮点、图文解析、展望与总结。

期刊

Behavioral and Brain Sciences 封面图
Behavioral and Brain Sciences
IF:
13.7
论文数:
1.6W
被引数:
1.5W

机构

V
victoria university wellington
学者数:
50
论文数: 26
被引数: 4.0K
D
Dartmouth College
学者数:
565
论文数: 285
被引数: 8.9K
G
George Mason University
学者数:
415
论文数: 238
被引数: 5.4K
Y
Yale University
学者数:
4.0K
论文数: 1.4K
被引数: 5.0W
U
University of Waterloo
学者数:
1.2K
论文数: 567
被引数: 1.8W
H
Harvard University
学者数:
7.2K
论文数: 2.5K
被引数: 20.7W
学者 查看更多机构
引用论文

引用论文

Enhancing the Farm Bill's Conservation Potential Through Land Prioritization
err2010-12-13
err0
PREAI
errDONALD J. BROWN; DANA M. SPONTAK; MARY N. TIBBETS; AMY R. CONNOLLY; JOHN T. BACCUS
err分享
err收藏
Design of a remote operation system for trans‐Pacific microscopy via international advanced networks
err2002-03-27
err0
PREAI
errKiyokazu Yoshida; Hirotaro Mori; Shinji Shimojo; Youki Kadobayashi; Toyokazu Akiyama; Mark H. Ellisman
err分享
err收藏
MULTINATIONAL PATTERNS OF SECOND-LINE ANTI-HYPERGLYCEMIC DRUG INITIATION IN ESTABLISHED CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE: A FEDERATED PHARMACOEPIDEMIOLOGIC EVALUATION IN LEGEND-T2DM
err2023-03-01
err0
errOAAI
errRohan Khera; Lovedeep Dhingra; Kelly Li; Arya Aminorroaya; Jin Zhou; Faaizah Arshad; Fan Bu; David Dorr; Thomas Falconer; Tina French; Wallis Lau; Yuan Lu; Kenneth Man; Michael Edwin Matheny; Evan Minty; Akihiko Nishimura; Anna Ostropolets; Sarah Seager; Wan Eric Y.F.; Jianxiao Yang; Can Yin; George Hripcsak; Harlan M. Krumholz
err分享
err收藏
Invertebrate Community Response to a Shifting Mosaic of Habitat
err2008-01-01
err0
errOAAI
errDavid M. Engle; Samuel D. Fuhlendorf; Aaron Roper; David M. Leslie
err分享
err收藏
Direct determination of monolayer MoS2and WSe2exciton binding energies on insulating and metallic substrates直接测定绝缘和金属基底上的单层MoS2 和WSe2 激子结合能
err2018-01-11
err0
errOAAI
errSoohyung Park; Niklas Mutz; Thorsten Schultz; Sylke Blumstengel; Ali Han; Areej Aljarb; Lain-Jong Li; Emil J W List-Kratochvil; Patrick Amsalem; Norbert Koch
err分享
err收藏
err分享
err收藏
学者 查看更多内容