Single paper meta-analysis is unavoidable

doi:10.1002/jcpy.1462

2025-09-10

Blakeley B. McShane *

Ulf Böckenholt

DOI：10.1002/jcpy.1462

原文链接

查看原文

摘要

En 中文

我们主张，典型行为研究论文中针对同一现象的多个研究应进行联合分析，以提供对这些研究的整体统计总结。确实，我们认为此类单篇元分析在典型行为研究论文中是不可避免的，因为：(i) 这类论文包含对同一现象的多个研究；(ii) 这类论文包含对这些研究的总结；(iii) 研究的统计总结（即元分析）优于非统计总结。然而，当前的主流做法是，这类论文对每个研究的单独数据进行统计分析，但包含的是多个研究的非统计总结而非统计总结。我们认为这是令人遗憾的，因此旨在纠正这一状况。因此，我们回顾了关于元分析和更广泛的统计分析的一些考虑因素；将单篇元分析与传统元分析进行比较，并通过案例研究说明其优势；讨论并驳斥对单篇元分析的担忧；并讨论单篇元分析与评审流程。

Keyword:

meta-analysis

methods

AI总结

对已上传原文的论文进行重点信息的提取，主要内容包括：简要概述、研究摘要、背景介绍、关键亮点、图文解析、展望与总结。

期刊

Journal of Consumer Psychology

IF:

6.1

论文数:

1.3K

被引数:

8.5K

机构

Northwestern University

学者数:

6.2W

论文数: 5.3W

被引数: 3.9K

引用论文

Blinding Us to the Obvious? The Effect of Statistical Training on the Evaluation of Evidence

Management Science

IF0

2016-06-01

PREAI

Blakeley B. McShane; David Gal

Enriching Meta-Analytic Models of Summary Data: A Thought Experiment and Case Study 丰富汇总数据的元分析模型: 思维实验和案例研究

ADVANCES IN METHODS AND PRACTICES IN PSYCHOLOGICAL SCIENCE

IF13.4

2019-11-26

OAAI

McShane, Blakeley B.; Bockenholt, Ulf

Pre-registration is a Game Changer. But, Like Random Assignment, it is Neither Necessary Nor Sufficient for Credible Science

JOURNAL OF CONSUMER PSYCHOLOGY

IF6.1

2021-02-15

PREAI

Simmons, Joseph P.; Nelson, Leif D.; Simonsohn, Uri

On the Poor Statistical Properties of the P-Curve Meta-Analytic Procedure 关于P曲线元分析程序的不良统计特性

Journal of the American Statistical Association

IF3

2025-10-20

OAAI

Richard D. Morey; Clintin P. Davis-Stober

Single-Paper Meta-Analysis: Benefits for Study Summary, Theory Testing, and Replicability 单篇论文荟萃分析: 研究总结、理论测试和可复制性的好处

JOURNAL OF CONSUMER RESEARCH

IF6.4

2017-01-23

371

PREAI

McShane, Blakeley B.; Bockenholt, Ulf

Theoretical Statistics

IF0

1974-01-01

PREAI

D. R. Cox; D. V. Hinkley

Meta-analysis of individual patient data from randomized trials: a review of methods used in practice

Clinical Trials

IF0

2005-06-01

PREAI

Mark C Simmonds; Julian P T Higginsa; Lesley A Stewartb; Jayne F Tierneyb; Mike J Clarke; Simon G Thompson

Adjusting for Publication Bias in Meta-Analysis: An Evaluation of Selection Methods and Some Cautionary Notes

PERSPECTIVES ON PSYCHOLOGICAL SCIENCE

IF8.4

2016-09-29

270

OAAI

McShane, Blakeley B.; Bockenholt, Ulf; Hansen, Karsten T.

Registered Replication Report on Fischer, Castel, Dodd, and Pratt (2003)关于Fischer、Castel、Dodd和Pratt的注册复制报告 (2003)

ADVANCES IN METHODS AND PRACTICES IN PSYCHOLOGICAL SCIENCE

IF13.4

2020-06-12

OAAI

Colling, Lincoln J.; Szucs, Denes; De Marco, Damiano; Cipora, Krzysztof; Ulrich, Rolf; Nuerk, Hans-Christoph; Soltanlou, Mojtaba; Bryce, Donna; Chen, Sau-Chin; Schroeder, Philipp Alexander; Henare, Dion T.; Chrystall, Christine K.; Corballis, Paul M.; Ansari, Daniel; Goffin, Celia; Sokolowski, H. Moriah; Hancock, Peter J. B.; Millen, Ailsa E.; Langton, Stephen R. H.; Holmes, Kevin J.; Saviano, Mark S.; Tummino, Tia A.; Lindemann, Oliver; Zwaan, Rolf A.; Lukavsky, Jiri; Beckova, Adela; Vranka, Marek A.; Cutini, Simone; Mammarella, Irene Cristina; Mulatti, Claudio; Bell, Raoul; Buchner, Axel; Mieth, Laura; Roeer, Jan Philipp; Klein, Elise; Huber, Stefan; Moeller, Korbinian; Ocampo, Brenda; Lupianez, Juan; Ortiz-Tudela, Javier; de la Fuente, Juanma; Santiago, Julio; Ouellet, Marc; Hubbard, Edward M.; Toomarian, Elizabeth Y.; Job, Remo; Treccani, Barbara; McShane, Blakeley B.

Spending and Happiness: The Role of Perceived Financial Constraints

JOURNAL OF CONSUMER RESEARCH

IF6.4

2021-12-24

OAAI

Dias, Rodrigo S.; Sharma, Eesha; Fitzsimons, Gavan J.

查看更多内容