When transformative experience is a trap

doi:10.1080/0020174X.2025.2576143

2025-10-01

PRE

Mercedes Valmisa *

Tim Connolly

DOI：10.1080/0020174X.2025.2576143

原文链接

原文求助

摘要

En 中文

This article examines how certain transformative experiences - such as becoming a mother, joining the military, or attending college - can function as traps when framed through a rhetoric of individual agency and self-realization that obscures sociomaterial conditions and oppressive structural forces. We analyze three features of contemporary philosophical discourse on transformative experience that contribute to this entrapment: the emphasis on subjective value, the view of transformation as a rupture between old and new selves, and the appeal to higher-order values like authenticity and self-authorship. Our case study on motherhood shows how these conceptual framings can render structural constraints invisible, sever individuals from the resources that might help them navigate the rigid roles into which they are cast, and ultimately isolate them in the aftermath of difficult or harmful outcomes, leaving them solely responsible to bear the burden.

Keyword:

Transformative experience

transformation

sociomaterial conditions

self

trap

motherhood