arrow
Return

A Real-Data-Driven Framework for Evaluating Differential Transcript Usage Methods Across Long-Read Bulk, Single-Cell, and Spatial Transcriptomics

delete2026-09-18
delete0
delete
OA
AI
C
Chenxing Zhang
J
Jun Liu
Q
Qi Zhao
H
Huilong Yin
A
Angang Yang
M
Minhua Zheng *
R
Rui Zhang *
DOI:10.1002/advs.77756delete
deleteOriginal
deleteShare
deleteSave
View PDF
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
Differential transcript usage (DTU) analysis reveals transcript-level regulation in alternative splicing. With the rapid adoption of long-read sequencing in bulk, single-cell, and spatial transcriptomics, reliable evaluation of DTU methods under real biological conditions becomes essential. Current evaluation frameworks mainly rely on simulated data, which can introduce bias and may not reflect true regulatory mechanisms. A real-data-driven framework is constructed to evaluate DTU methods across long-read bulk, single-cell, and spatial transcriptomics. The framework includes two key components. First, a biologically grounded reference transcript set is defined using RNA-binding protein (RBP) knockout or knockdown RNA-seq data together with experimentally validated RBP-transcript interactions. Second, a DTU-specific evaluation metric, the transcript set enrichment score, is introduced to quantify how effectively a method prioritizes reference transcripts in ranked results. The framework is systematically validated for reliability, unbiasedness, stability, effectiveness, and robustness using multiple real RNA-seq datasets. Supported by this validation, ten representative DTU methods are evaluated across long-read and short-read data, revealing performance differences across data types. Beyond evaluating DTU methods, the framework is further extended to predict transcript-level RBP activity, recovering perturbed RBPs more consistently than gene-level differential expression strategies. Together, this study establishes a biologically interpretable and data-driven standard for DTU method evaluation.
Keywords:
differential transcript usage (DTU)
evaluation framework
evaluation metric
long-read transcriptomics
multi-omics data resources
AI Summary

AI Summary

Key information extracted from the uploaded paper, including a brief overview, abstract, background, key highlights, visual analysis, and future outlook.

Journal

Advanced Science cover
Advanced Science
IF:
14.1
Papers:
1.8W
Citations:
11.5W

Organization

F
fourth military medical university
Scholars:
1.4K
Papers: 258
Citations: 1
Cited Papers

Cited Papers

A large-scale binding and functional map of human RNA-binding proteins
err2020-07-29
err0
errOAAI
errEric L. Van Nostrand; Peter Freese; Gabriel A. Pratt; Xiaofeng Wang; Xintao Wei; Rui Xiao; Steven M. Blue; Jia-Yu Chen; Neal A. L. Cody; Daniel Dominguez; Sara Olson; Balaji Sundararaman; Lijun Zhan; Cassandra Bazile; Louis Philip Benoit Bouvrette; Julie Bergalet; Michael O. Duff; Keri E. Garcia; Chelsea Gelboin-Burkhart; Myles Hochman; Nicole J. Lambert; Hairi Li; Michael P. McGurk; Thai B. Nguyen; Tsultrim Palden; Ines Rabano; Shashank Sathe; Rebecca Stanton; Amanda Su; Ruth Wang; Brian A. Yee; Bing Zhou; Ashley L. Louie; Stefan Aigner; Xiang-Dong Fu; Eric Lécuyer; Christopher B. Burge; Brenton R. Graveley; Gene W. Yeo
errShare
errSave
Detecting differential transcript usage in complex diseases with SPIT
err2024-03-01
err0
errOAAI
errErdogdu, Beril; Varabyou, Ales; Hicks, Stephanie C.; Salzberg, Steven L.; Pertea, Mihaela
errShare
errSave
POSTAR3: an updated platform for exploring post-transcriptional regulation coordinated by RNA-binding proteins
err2021-08-17
err74
errOAAI
errZhao, Weihao; Zhang, Shang; Zhu, Yumin; Xi, Xiaochen; Bao, Pengfei; Ma, Ziyuan; Kapral, Thomas H.; Chen, Shuyuan; Zagrovic, Bojan; Yang, Yucheng T.; Lu, Zhi John
errShare
errSave
Relative Abundance of Transcripts (RATs): Identifying differential isoform abundance from RNA-seq
err2019-02-24
err0
errOAAI
errKimon Froussios; Kira Mourão; Gordon Simpson; Geoff Barton; Nicholas Schurch
errShare
errSave
Impact of Alternative Splicing on the Human Proteome
err2017-08-01
err143
errOAAI
errLiu, Yansheng; Gonzalez-Porta, Mar; Santos, Sergio; Brazma, Alvis; Marioni, John C.; Aebersold, Ruedi; Venkitaraman, Ashok R.; Wickramasinghe, Vihandha O.
errShare
errSave
Incomplete paralog compensation generates selective dependency on TRA2A in cancer
err2025-05-14
err0
errOAAI
errLee, Amanda R.; Tangiyan, Anna; Singh, Isha; Choi, Peter S.
errShare
errSave
The RNA-binding protein PCBP1 modulates transcription by recruiting the G-quadruplex-specific helicase DHX9
err2024-11-01
err2
errOAAI
errKaram, Joseph A. Q.; Frereux, Cecile; Mohanty, Bidyut K.; Dalton, Annamarie C.; Dincman, Toros A.; Palanisamy, Viswanathan; V. Howley, Breege; Howe, Philip H.
errShare
errSave
RADAR: annotation and prioritization of variants in the post-transcriptional regulome of RNA-binding proteins
err2020-07-30
err8
errOAAI
errZhang, Jing; Liu, Jason; Lee, Donghoon; Feng, Jo-Jo; Lochovsky, Lucas; Lou, Shaoke; Rutenberg-Schoenberg, Michael; Gerstein, Mark
errShare
errSave
An integrative ENCODE resource for cancer genomics
err2020-07-29
err91
errOAAI
errZhang, Jing; Lee, Donghoon; Dhiman, Vineet; Jiang, Peng; Xu, Jie; McGillivray, Patrick; Yang, Hongbo; Liu, Jason; Meyerson, William; Clarke, Declan; Gu, Mengting; Li, Shantao; Lou, Shaoke; Xu, Jinrui; Lochovsky, Lucas; Ung, Matthew; Ma, Lijia; Yu, Shan; Cao, Qin; Harmanci, Arif; Yan, Koon-Kiu; Sethi, Anurag; Gursoy, Gamze; Schoenberg, Michael Rutenberg; Rozowsky, Joel; Warrell, Jonathan; Emani, Prashant; Yang, Yucheng T.; Galeev, Timur; Kong, Xiangmeng; Liu, Shuang; Li, Xiaotong; Krishnan, Jayanth; Feng, Yanlin; Rivera-Mulia, Juan Carlos; Adrian, Jessica; Broach, James R.; Bolt, Michael; Moran, Jennifer; Fitzgerald, Dominic; Dileep, Vishnu; Liu, Tingting; Mei, Shenglin; Sasaki, Takayo; Trevilla-Garcia, Claudia; Wang, Su; Wang, Yanli; Zang, Chongzhi; Wang, Daifeng; Klein, Robert J.; Snyder, Michael; Gilbert, David M.; Yip, Kevin; Cheng, Chao; Yue, Feng; Liu, X. Shirley; White, Kevin P.; Gerstein, Mark
errShare
errSave
researcher View more