arrow
Return

About nothing

delete2013-08-19
delete25
PRE
AI
A
Andrew V. Z. Brower *
M
Mário C. C. de Pinna
DOI:10.1111/cla.12050delete
deleteOriginal
deleteOriginal request for help
deleteShare
deleteSave
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
In light of recent terminological controversy, this article reviews cladistic conceptions of character states coded as absences, symplesiomorphies, and secondary losses. The first section addresses absence as a question of ontology vs. epistemology. The second and third sections address the evidentiary status of symplesiomorphy in cladistics, the fourth contrasts primitive absence with secondary loss, and the fifth clarifies the meaning of grouping. While secondary losses (reversals) are often synapomorphies, symplesiomorphies (absent or otherwise) have no evidentiary import to cladistic hypotheses of relationship. Thus, we argue that identifying symplesiomorphic character states as homologous is conceptually vacuous, because they are either synapomorphies (homologues) of more inclusive taxa, or complementary absences that unite no group.
Keywords:
TAXIC HOMOLOGY
PHYLOGENY
EVOLUTION

Journal

Cladistics cover
Cladistics
IF:
6.2
Papers:
994
Citations:
3.9K

Organization

M
Middle Tennessee State University
Scholars:
977
Papers: 839
Citations: 711
U
universidade de sao paulo
Scholars:
10.6W
Papers: 6.7W
Citations: 93
Cited Papers

Cited Papers

Range contraction and conservation of the endangered Yellow Cardinal
err2019-08-01
err0
PREAI
errFabricio Reales; Juan Andrés Sarquis; Sebastián Dardanelli; Martjan Lammertink
errShare
errSave
More on homology
err2012-01-04
err18
PREAI
errNixon, Kevin C.; Carpenter, James M.
errShare
errSave
Pattern cladistics really means paraphyly
err2013-06-19
err4
errOAAI
errFarris, James S.
errShare
errSave
Homology and historiography
err2012-07-27
err6
errOAAI
errFarris, James S.
errShare
errSave
Effect of age of red cells for transfusion on patient outcomes: a systematic review and meta-analysis
err2018-04-01
err0
PREAI
errZoe K. McQuilten; Craig J. French; Alistair Nichol; Alisa Higgins; David J. Cooper
errShare
errSave
Counterfeit cladistics
err2012-01-03
err16
PREAI
errFarris, James S.
errShare
errSave
Characterization of complete dentures using patient’s intraoral photograph: A dental technique
err2022-01-01
err0
errOAAI
errDr. Anuraj Vijayan; Dr. Shubham Kumar Gupta; Dr. Dhwanit Widhani; Dr. Sunidhi Sharma
errShare
errSave
Forest and UAV: a bibliometric review
err2016-01-01
err0
PREAI
errFilippo Gambella; Luisella Sistu; Davide Piccirilli; Sergio Corposanto; Maria Caria; Ettore Arcangeletti; Andrea Rosario Proto; Giovanni Chessa; Antonio Pazzona
errShare
errSave
More on errors
err2012-06-21
err10
errOAAI
errNixon, Kevin C.; Carpenter, James M.
errShare
errSave
researcher View more