arrow
Return

Approximating the living

delete2025-09-01
delete0
PRE
AI
R
Rob Phillips
DOI:10.1016/j.semcdb.2025.103646delete
deleteOriginal
deleteOriginal request for help
deleteShare
deleteSave
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
Is a herd of wildebeest better thought of as a series of individual animals, each with its own glorious and unmanageable volition, or as a field of moving arrows? Are the morphogen gradients that set up the coordinate systems for embryonic anterior–posterior patterning a smooth and continuous concentration field or instead a chaotic collection of protein molecules each jiggling about in the haphazard way first described by Robert Brown in his microscopical observations of pollen? Is water, the great liquid ether of the living world, a collection of discrete molecules or instead a perfectly continuous medium with a density of ≈1000 kg/m 3? In this article, I will argue that these questions pose a false dichotomy since there are many different and powerful representations of the world around us. Different representations suit us differently at different times and it is often useful to be able to hold these seemingly contradictory notions in our heads simultaneously. Indeed, mathematics is not only the language of representation, but often is also the engine of reconciliation of such disparate views. In a letter to Alfred Russel Wallace on 14 April 1869, Charles Darwin noted that Lord Kelvin’s “views on the recent age of the world have been for some time one of my sorest troubles”. Here, I will argue that one of the highest attainments of the scientific enterprise is a coherent picture of the world, a picture in which our stories about the geological age of the Earth are coherent with our stories of how whales populated the oceans, our understanding of the living jibes with our understanding of the inanimate, our insights into the dynamics of genes and molecular structures are consonant with our physical understanding of the laws of statistical physics. The underpinnings of such coherency are often best revealed when viewed through the lens of mathematics.
Keywords:
Emergent phenomena
Scientific representation
Mathematical modeling
Coherence in science
Biological and physical laws

Journal

Seminars in Cell and Developmental Biology cover
Seminars in Cell and Developmental Biology
IF:
6
Papers:
3.8K
Citations:
1.6W

Organization

No organization information available
Cited Papers

Cited Papers

Kinesin hydrolyses one ATP per 8-nm step
err1997-07-24
err0
errOAAI
errMark J. Schnitzer; Steven M. Block
errShare
errSave
Fly Cell Atlas: A single-nucleus transcriptomic atlas of the adult fruit fly
err2022-03-04
err0
errOAAI
errHongjie Li; Jasper Janssens; Maxime De Waegeneer; Sai Saroja Kolluru; Kristofer Davie; Vincent Gardeux; Wouter Saelens; Fabrice P. A. David; Maria Brbić; Katina Spanier; Jure Leskovec; Colleen N. McLaughlin; Qijing Xie; Robert C. Jones; Katja Brueckner; Jiwon Shim; Sudhir Gopal Tattikota; Frank Schnorrer; Katja Rust; Todd G. Nystul; Zita Carvalho-Santos; Carlos Ribeiro; Soumitra Pal; Sharvani Mahadevaraju; Teresa M. Przytycka; Aaron M. Allen; Stephen F. Goodwin; Cameron W. Berry; Margaret T. Fuller; Helen White-Cooper; Erika L. Matunis; Stephen DiNardo; Anthony Galenza; Lucy Erin O’Brien; Julian A. T. Dow; Heinrich Jasper; Brian Oliver; Norbert Perrimon; Bart Deplancke; Stephen R. Quake; Liqun Luo; Stein Aerts; Devika Agarwal; Yasir Ahmed-Braimah; Michelle Arbeitman; Majd M. Ariss; Jordan Augsburger; Kumar Ayush; Catherine C. Baker; Torsten Banisch; Katja Birker; Rolf Bodmer; Benjamin Bolival; Susanna E. Brantley; Julie A. Brill; Nora C. Brown; Norene A. Buehner; Xiaoyu Tracy Cai; Rita Cardoso-Figueiredo; Fernando Casares; Amy Chang; Thomas R. Clandinin; Sheela Crasta; Claude Desplan; Angela M. Detweiler; Darshan B. Dhakan; Erika Donà; Stefanie Engert; Swann Floc’hlay; Nancy George; Amanda J. González-Segarra; Andrew K. Groves; Samantha Gumbin; Yanmeng Guo; Devon E. Harris; Yael Heifetz; Stephen L. Holtz; Felix Horns; Bruno Hudry; Ruei-Jiun Hung; Yuh Nung Jan; Jacob S. Jaszczak; Gregory S. X. E. Jefferis; Jim Karkanias; Timothy L. Karr; Nadja Sandra Katheder; James Kezos; Anna A. Kim; Seung K. Kim; Lutz Kockel; Nikolaos Konstantinides; Thomas B. Kornberg; Henry M. Krause; Andrew Thomas Labott; Meghan Laturney; Ruth Lehmann; Sarah Leinwand; Jiefu Li; Joshua Shing Shun Li; Kai Li; Ke Li; Liying Li; Tun Li; Maria Litovchenko; Han-Hsuan Liu; Yifang Liu; Tzu-Chiao Lu; Jonathan Manning; Anjeli Mase; Mikaela Matera-Vatnick; Neuza Reis Matias; Caitlin E. McDonough-Goldstein; Aaron McGeever; Alex D. McLachlan; Paola Moreno-Roman; Norma Neff; Megan Neville; Sang Ngo; Tanja Nielsen; Caitlin E. O’Brien; David Osumi-Sutherland; Mehmet Neset Özel; Irene Papatheodorou; Maja Petkovic; Clare Pilgrim; Angela Oliveira Pisco; Carolina Reisenman; Erin Nicole Sanders; Gilberto dos Santos; Kristin Scott; Aparna Sherlekar; Philip Shiu; David Sims; Rene V. Sit; Maija Slaidina; Harold E. Smith; Gabriella Sterne; Yu-Han Su; Daniel Sutton; Marco Tamayo; Michelle Tan; Ibrahim Tastekin; Christoph Treiber; David Vacek; Georg Vogler; Scott Waddell; Wanpeng Wang; Rachel I. Wilson; Mariana F. Wolfner; Yiu-Cheung E. Wong; Anthony Xie; Jun Xu; Shinya Yamamoto; Jia Yan; Zepeng Yao; Kazuki Yoda; Ruijun Zhu; Robert P. Zinzen
errShare
errSave
The quantitative and condition-dependent Escherichia coli proteome
err2016-01-01
err582
errOAAI
errSchmidt, Alexander; Kochanowski, Karl; Vedelaar, Silke; Ahrne, Erik; Volkmer, Benjamin; Callipo, Luciano; Knoops, Kevin; Bauer, Manuel; Aebersold, Ruedi; Heinemann, Matthias
errShare
errSave
errShare
errSave
Stochastic mRNA Synthesis in Mammalian Cells
err2006-09-12
err0
errOAAI
errArjun Raj; Charles S Peskin; Daniel Tranchina; Diana Y Vargas; Sanjay Tyagi
errShare
errSave
On the nature of allosteric transitions: A plausible model
err1965-05-01
err0
PREAI
errJacque Monod; Jeffries Wyman; Jean-Pierre Changeux
errShare
errSave
How to make a Biological Switch
err2000-03-01
err0
PREAI
errJOSHUA L CHERRY; FREDERICK R ADLER
errShare
errSave
A synthetic oscillatory network of transcriptional regulators
err2000-01-01
err0
PREAI
errMichael B. Elowitz; Stanislas Leibler
errShare
errSave
researcher View more