1
Return

Brain stimulation and VEGF concentrations: meta-analysis, meta-regression, and hierarchical cluster analysis of 200 correlations

delete2026-08-07
delete0
PRE
AI
A
Amene Saghazadeh *
R
Riccardo Gironi
M
Mohamed Abdel Fattah Khalil
M
Matteo Costanzo
M
Murat İlhan Atagün
L
Linda van Diermen
D
Didier Schrijvers
G
Gianna Carla Riccitelli
DOI:10.1007/s00406-026-02333-8delete
deleteOriginal
deleteOriginal request for help
deleteShare
deleteSave
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
Studies on VEGF responses to brain stimulation (BS) are inconsistent. We systematically reviewed and meta-analyzed these data. Overall meta-analyses for the three main models (time, group, time×group) showed no significant effects (p>0.05). Given the high heterogeneity across interventions and populations, we conducted extensive exploratory subgroup analyses to generate hypotheses. These revealed several within-subgroup effects, but they were based on limited data constraining their interpretability, with several single studies and others on 2–4 observations. For time-difference analyses, higher post-BS VEGF emerged in older rTMS patients (k=4, g=2.14), responders (k=3, g=0.58), and remitters (k=2, g=0.56), but not in other subgroups. Group-difference analyses showed higher post-BS VEGF in tDCS (k=1, g=1.01) and DBS (k=1, g=6.03) groups vs. controls; at baseline, non-responders had lower VEGF than controls (k=3, g=-0.31). Time×group analyses favored rTMS over non-rTMS (k=3, g=1.95), responders over non-responders (k=4, g=0.54), and remitters over non-remitters (k=3, g=0.72). Meta-regression (k=19) identified age as a major variability source (β=1.12, R²=88.9%). HCA ranked the top eight VEGF correlates: PANSS, MADRS, HDRS/HAM-D, HAMA, treatment outcome, age, SHAPS, and BPRS-5. These significant subgroup findings derive from post-hoc exploratory analyses with small sample sizes and should not be interpreted as confirmatory. We provide an early meta-analytical framework, but the small number of observations per BS technique, psychiatric condition, and timepoint precludes definitive conclusions. Future updates with larger, more homogenous datasets are essential to rigorously test whether VEGF can serve as a reliable biomarker of differential BS responses. These exploratory results are hypothesis-generating and require confirmation in future studies.
Keywords:
Biomarker
Brain modeling
Outcome prediction
Precision brain stimulation
Response variability
Vascular age

Journal

European Archives of Psychiatry and Clinical Neuroscience cover
European Archives of Psychiatry and Clinical Neuroscience
IF:
3.7
Papers:
3.4K
Citations:
6.2K

Organization

N
neurocenter of southern switzerland
Scholars:
30
Papers: 15
Citations: 0
K
kasr al-ainy faculty of medicine
Scholars:
16
Papers: 3
Citations: 0
S
school of medicine
Scholars:
3.5K
Papers: 1.2K
Citations: 0
D
Department of Human Neurosciences
Scholars:
84
Papers: 30
Citations: 0
F
faculty of medicine and health sciences
Scholars:
324
Papers: 133
Citations: 0
F
faculty of medicine
Scholars:
6.1K
Papers: 2.1K
Citations: 0
Cited Papers

Cited Papers

Citing Papers

Citing Papers