arrow
Return

Classifying information-sharing methods

delete2021-05-22
delete8
delete
OA
AI
G
Georgios F. Nikolaidis *
B
Beth Woods
S
Stephen Palmer
M
Marta Soares
DOI:10.1186/s12874-021-01292-zdelete
deleteOriginal
deleteShare
deleteSave
View PDF
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
Background Sparse relative effectiveness evidence is a frequent problem in Health Technology Assessment (HTA). Where evidence directly pertaining to the decision problem is sparse, it may be feasible to expand the evidence-base to include studies that relate to the decision problem only indirectly: for instance, when there is no evidence on a comparator, evidence on other treatments of the same molecular class could be used; similarly, a decision on children may borrow-strength from evidence on adults. Usually, in HTA, such indirect evidence is either included by ignoring any differences ('lumping') or not included at all ('splitting'). However, a range of more sophisticated methods exists, primarily in the biostatistics literature. The objective of this study is to identify and classify the breadth of the available information-sharing methods. Methods Forwards and backwards citation-mining techniques were used on a set of seminal papers on the topic of information-sharing. Papers were included if they specified (network) meta-analytic methods for combining information from distinct populations, interventions, outcomes or study-designs. Results Overall, 89 papers were included. A plethora of evidence synthesis methods have been used for information-sharing. Most papers (n=79) described methods that shared information on relative treatment effects. Amongst these, there was a strong emphasis on methods for information-sharing across multiple outcomes (n=42) and treatments (n=25), with fewer papers focusing on study-designs (n=23) or populations (n=8). We categorise and discuss the methods under four 'core' relationships of information-sharing: functional, exchangeability-based, prior-based and multivariate relationships, and explain the assumptions made within each of these core approaches. Conclusions This study highlights the range of information-sharing methods available. These methods often impose more moderate assumptions than lumping or splitting. Hence, the degree of information-sharing that they impose could potentially be considered more appropriate. Our identification of four 'core' methods of information-sharing allows for an improved understanding of the assumptions underpinning the different methods. Further research is required to understand how the methods differ in terms of the strength of sharing they impose and the implications of this for health care decisions.
Keywords:
Meta-analysis
Network meta-analysis
Borrowing-strength
Indirect evidence
Information-sharing

Journal

BMC Medical Research Methodology cover
BMC Medical Research Methodology
IF:
3.4
Papers:
4.0K
Citations:
3.5W

Organization

U
university of york - uk
Scholars:
1.5W
Papers: 1.5W
Citations: 2.6W
Cited Papers

Cited Papers

err
IF0
err
err0
PREAI
err
errShare
errSave
Learning Factory with Product Configurator for Teaching Product Family Modelling and Systems Integration
err2019-01-01
err0
errOAAI
errThomas Ditlev Brunoe; Steffen Tram Mortensen; Ann-Louise Andersen; Kjeld Nielsen
errShare
errSave
errShare
errSave
Adjustment for reporting bias in network meta-analysis of antidepressant trials
err2012-09-27
err88
errOAAI
errTrinquart, Ludovic; Chatellier, Gilles; Ravaud, Philippe
errShare
errSave
Evidence Synthesis for Decision Making 1: Introduction
err2013-06-26
err130
errOAAI
errDias, Sofia; Welton, Nicky J.; Sutton, Alex J.; Ades, A. E.
errShare
errSave
researcher View more