Return
Comment on Kaur et al., Lithos 518–519 (2025) 108309, Evidence of hydrous magmatism and magma mixing in Sittampundi Anorthosite Complex, Southern Granulite Terrain, India: Inferences from petrography and mineral chemistry
S
K
DOI:10.1016/j.lithos.2026.108467.png)
Abstract
En 中文
We dispute the claim of Kaur et al. (2025) that the rocks of the late Archaean chromititic anorthosite complex at Sittampundi were formed by magma mixing. Because of the very close geological and geochemical similarities between the rocks of the Sittampundi Anorthosite Complex (SAC) and the Fiskenæsset Complex in west Greenland, we argue that the rocks of the SAC can be better understood (a) through the Fiskenæsset analogue and (b) through the robust crystal chemistry of the chromitites. Such a model was proposed by Veni et al. (2025) and suggests that a fractional crystallisation model, rather than magma mixing, provides a better way to interpret the chemical variations in the Fiskenæsset chromitites and by inference the evolution of the SAC.
Keywords:
chromitite
anorthosite complex
fractional crystallization
magma mixing
Sittampundi
Journal
IF:
2.5
Papers:
649
Citations:
2.8W

