Commentary: core descriptor sets using consensus methods support 'table one' consistency

Matthew J. Lee

doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111470

Return

Commentary: core descriptor sets using consensus methods support 'table one' consistency

2024-10-01

DOI：10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111470

Original

Save

View PDF

Abstract

En 中文

Background: Inconsistent reporting of patient characteristics in clinical research hampers reproducibility and limits analysis opportunities. This paper proposes condition-specific 'Core Descriptor Sets' comprising key factors like demographics, disease severity, comorbidities, and prognosis to standardize Table 1 reporting. Methods: Development entails stakeholder involvement, systematic identification of descriptors, value rating, and consensus-building using multiple Delphi rounds. Final agreement comes at an expert meeting. Conclusion: Benefits include easier cross-study comparison, for example, through individual patient meta-analysis, facilitated by comparison of consistently reported individual data rather than group-level analysis. This may also support routine data analyses, subgroup and risk identification, and reduced research waste. Core Descriptor Sets describe cohorts thoroughly while minimizing research burden. They are intended to enable improved clinical characterization, personalization, reproducibility, data sharing, and knowledge building. (c) 2024 The Author(s). Published by Elsevier Inc. This is an open access article under the CC BY license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.

Keywords:

Consensus

Prognosis

Research design

Risk factors

Data analysis

Documentation

Epidemiologic research design

Guidelines as topic

Pub- lishing

Reproducibility of results

AI Summary

Key information extracted from the uploaded paper, including a brief overview, abstract, background, key highlights, visual analysis, and future outlook.

Journal

Journal of Clinical Epidemiology

IF:

5.2

Papers:

8.4K

Citations:

4.3W

Organization

University of Birmingham

Scholars:

4.1W

Papers: 3.8W

Citations: 5.0W

University of Cambridge

Scholars:

7.7W

Papers: 7.1W

Citations: 13.7W

university of leicester

Scholars:

2.0W

Papers: 1.7W

Citations: 25

university of leeds

Scholars:

3.6W

Papers: 3.3W

Citations: 45

Royal College of Surgeons of England

Scholars:

510

Papers: 337

Citations: 254

Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust

Scholars:

8.2K

Papers: 5.5K

Citations: 4.9K

View more organizations

Cited Papers

Description of sup- and inf-preserving aggregation functions via families of clusters in data tables

Information Sciences

IF0

2017-08-01

OAAI

Radomír Halaš; Radko Mesiar; Jozef Pócs

Save

Adjoint negations, more than residuated negations

Information Sciences

IF0

2016-06-01

PREAI

M. Eugenia Cornejo; Jesús Medina; Eloísa Ramírez-Poussa

Save

Variation in descriptors of patient characteristics in randomized clinical trials of peptic ulcer repair: a systematic review

BRITISH JOURNAL OF SURGERY

IF8.7

2020-07-16

OAAI

Lee, M. J.; Coe, P. O.; O'Donoghue, R.; Peirson, M.; Saha, A.

Save

Empty pelvis syndrome: PelvEx Collaborative guideline proposal

BRITISH JOURNAL OF SURGERY

IF8.7

2023-09-26

OAAI

West, C. T.; West, M. A.; Mirnezami, A. H.; Drami, I; Denys, A.; Glyn, T.; Sutton, P. A.; Tiernan, J.; Behrenbruch, C.; Guerra, G.; Waters, P. S.; Woodward, N.; Applin, S.; Charles, S. J.; Rose, S. A.; Pape, E.; van Ramshorst, G. H.; Aalbers, A. G. J.; Abdul, Aziz N.; Abecasis, N.; Abraham-Nordling, M.; Akiyoshi, T.; Alahmadi, R.; Alberda, W.; Albert, M.; Andric, M.; Angeles, M.; Angenete, E.; Antoniou, A.; Armitage, J.; Auer, R.; Austin, K. K.; Aytac, E.; Aziz, O.; Bacalbasa, N.; Baker, R. P.; Bali, M.; Baransi, S.; Baseckas, G.; Bebington, B.; Bedford, M.; Bednarski, B. K.; Beets, G. L.; Berg, P. L.; Bergzoll, C.; Biondo, S.; Boyle, K.; Bordeianou, L.; Brecelj, E.; Bremers, A. B.; Brown, K.; Brunner, M.; Buchwald, P.; Bui, A.; Burgess, A.; Burger, J. W. A.; Burling, D.; Burns, E.; Campain, N.; Carvalhal, S.; Castro, L.; Caycedo-Marulanda, A.; Ceelen, W.; Chan, K. K. L.; Chang, G. J.; Chew, M. H.; Chok, A. K.; Chong, P.; Christensen, H. K.; Clouston, H.; Collins, D.; Colquhoun, A. J.; Constantinides, J.; Corr, A.; Coscia, M.; Cosimelli, M.; Cotsoglou, C.; Coyne, P. E.; Croner, R. S.; Damjanovic, L.; Daniels, I. R.; Davies, M.; Davies, R. J.; Delaney, C. P.; de Wilt, J. H. W.; Denost, Q. D.; Deutsch, C.; Dietz, D.; Domingo, S.; Dozois, E. J.; Drozdov, E.; Duff, M.; Egger, E.; Eglinton, T.; Enrique-Navascues, J. M.; Espin-Basany, E.; Evans, M. D.; Eyjolfsdottir, B.; Fahy, M.; Fearnhead, N. S.; Fichtner-Feigl, S.; Flatmark, K.; Fleming, F.; Flor, B.; Folkesson, J.; Foskett, K.; Frizelle, F. A.; Funder, J.; Gallego, M. A.; Garcia-Granero, E.; Garcia-Sabrido, J. L.; Gargiulo, M.; Gava, V. G.; Gentilini, L.; George, M. L.; George, V; Georgiou, P.; Ghosh, A.; Ghouti, L.; Gil-Moreno, A.; Giner, F.; Ginther, N.; Glover, T.; Goffredo, P.; Golda, T.; Gomez, C. M.; Griffiths, B.; Gwenael, F.; Harris, C.; Harris, D. A.; Hagemans, J. A. W.; Hanchanale, V; Harji, D. P.; Helbren, C.; Helewa, R. M.; Hellawell, G.; Heriot, A. G.; Hochman, D.; Hohenberger, W.; Holm, T.; Holmstroem, A.; Hompes, R.; Hornung, B.; Hurton, S.; Hyun, E.; Ito, M.; Iversen, L. H.; Jenkins, J. T.; Jourand, K.; Kaffenberger, S.; Kandaswamy, G., V; Kapur, S.; Kanemitsu, Y.; Kaufman, M.; Kazi, M.; Kelley, S. R.; Keller, D. S.; Kelly, M. E.; Kersting, S.; Ketelaers, S. H. J.; Khan, M. S.; Khaw, J.; Kim, H.; Kim, H. J.; Kiran, R.; Koh, C. E.; Kok, N. F. M.; Kokelaar, R.; Kontovounisios, C.; Kose, F.; Koutra, M.; Kraft, M.; Kristensen, H. o; Kumar, S.; Kusters, M.; Lago, V; Lakkis, Z.; Lampe, B.; Langheinrich, M. C.; Larach, T.; Larsen, S. G.; Larson, D. W.; Law, W. L.; Laurberg, S.; Lee, P. J.; Limbert, M.; Loria, A.; Lydrup, M. L.; Lyons, A.; Lynch, A. C.; Mackintosh, M.; Mann, C.; Mantyh, C.; Mathis, K. L.; Margues, C. F. S.; Martinez, A.; Martling, A.; Meijerink, W. J. H. J.; Merchea, A.; Merkel, S.; Mehta, A. M.; Mcarthur, D. R.; Mccormick, J. J.; Mcdermott, F. D.; Mcgrath, J. S.; Mcphee, A.; Maciel, J.; Malde, S.; Manfredelli, S.; Mikalauskas, S.; Modest, D.; Monson, J. R. T.; Morton, J. R.; Mullaney, T. G.; Navarro, A. S.; Neeff, H.; Negoi, I; Neto, J. W. M.; Nguyen, B.; Nielsen, M. B.; Nieuwenhuijzen, G. A. P.; Nilsson, P. J.; Nordkamp, S.; O'Dwyer, S. T.; Paarnio, K.; Palmer, G.; Pappou, E.; Park, J.; Patsouras, D.; Peacock, A.; Pellino, G.; Peterson, A. C.; Pfeffer, F.; Piqeur, F.; Pinson, J.; Poggioli, G.; Proud, D.; Quinn, M.; Oliver, A.; Quyn, A.; Radwan, R. W.; Rajendran, N.; Rao, C.; Rasheed, S.; Rasmussen, P. C.; Rausa, E.; Regenbogen, S. E.; Reims, H. M.; Renehan, A.; Rintala, J.; Rocha, R.; Rochester, M.; Rohila, J.; Rothbarth, J.; Rottoli, M.; Roxburgh, C.; Rutten, H. J. T.; Safar, B.; Sagar, P. M.; Sahai, A.; Saklani, A.; Sammour, T.; Sayyed, R.; Schizas, A. M. P.; Schwarzkopf, E.; Scripcariu, D.; Scripcariu, V; Seifert, G.; Selvasekar, C.; Shaban, M.; Shaikh, I; Shida, D.; Simpson, A.; Skeie-Jensen, T.; Smart, N. J.; Smart, P.; Smith, J. J.; Smith, T.; Solbakken, A. M.; Solomon, M. J.; Sorensen, M. M.; Spasojevic, M.; Steele, S. R.; Steffens, D.; Stitzenberg, K.; Stocchi, L.; Stylianides, N. A.; Swartling, T.; Sumrien, H.; Swartking, T.; Takala, H.; Tan, E. J.; Taylor, C.; Taylor, D.; Tejedor, P.; Tekin, A.; Tekkis, P. P.; Teras, J.; Thanapal, M. R.; Thaysen, H., V; Thorgersen, E.; Thurairaja, R.; Toh, E. L.; Tsarkov, P.; Tolenaar, J.; Tsukada, Y.; Tsukamoto, S.; Tuech, J. J.; Turner, G.; Turner, W. H.; Tuynman, J. B.; Valente, M.; van Rees, J.; van Zoggel, D.; Vasquez-Jimenez, W.; Verhoef, C.; Vierimaa, M.; Vizzielli, G.; Voogt, E. L. K.; Uehara, K.; Wakeman, C.; Warrier, S.; Wasmuth, H. H.; Weber, K.; Weiser, M. R.; Westney, O. L.; Wheeler, J. M. D.; Wild, J.; Wilson, M.; Wolthuis, A.; Yano, H.; Yip, B.; Yip, J.; Yoo, R. N.; Zappa, M. A.; Winter, D. C.

Save

Core Outcome Set-STAndards for Development: The COS-STAD recommendations

PLOS MEDICINE

IF9.9

2017-11-16

469

OAAI

Kirkham, Jamie J.; Davis, Katherine; Altman, Douglas G.; Blazeby, Jane M.; Clarke, Mike; Tunis, Sean; Williamson, Paula R.

Save

Atypical Combinations and Scientific Impact

SCIENCE

IF45.8