arrow
Return

Comparing methods for comparing networks

delete2019-11-26
delete170
delete
OA
AI
M
Mattia Tantardini
F
Francesca Ieva
L
Lucia Tajoli
C
Carlo Piccardi *
DOI:10.1038/s41598-019-53708-ydelete
deleteOriginal
deleteShare
deleteSave
View PDF
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
With the impressive growth of available data and the flexibility of network modelling, the problem of devising effective quantitative methods for the comparison of networks arises. Plenty of such methods have been designed to accomplish this task: most of them deal with undirected and unweighted networks only, but a few are capable of handling directed and/or weighted networks too, thus properly exploiting richer information. In this work, we contribute to the effort of comparing the different methods for comparing networks and providing a guide for the selection of an appropriate one. First, we review and classify a collection of network comparison methods, highlighting the criteria they are based on and their advantages and drawbacks. The set includes methods requiring known node-correspondence, such as DeltaCon and Cut Distance, as well as methods not requiring a priori known node-correspondence, such as alignment-based, graphlet-based, and spectral methods, and the recently proposed Portrait Divergence and NetLSD. We test the above methods on synthetic networks and we assess their usability and the meaningfulness of the results they provide. Finally, we apply the methods to two real-world datasets, the European Air Transportation Network and the FAO Trade Network, in order to discuss the results that can be drawn from this type of analysis.
Keywords:
GRAPH KERNELS
ALIGNMENT
AI Summary

AI Summary

Key information extracted from the uploaded paper, including a brief overview, abstract, background, key highlights, visual analysis, and future outlook.

Journal

Scientific Reports cover
Scientific Reports
IF:
3.9
Papers:
28.2W
Citations:
83.5W

Organization

P
Polytechnic University of Milan
Scholars:
2.0W
Papers: 1.8W
Citations: 24
H
Human Technopole
Scholars:
405
Papers: 181
Citations: 540
Cited Papers

Cited Papers

Field-Emission Electron Source Using Carbon Nanotubes for X-ray Tubes
err2008-04-15
err0
PREAI
errHyun Suk Kim; Dao Quang Duy; Jae Hoon Kim; Hyung Joo Lee; Dang Mo Yoon; Seok Seung Shin; Jung Woong Ha; Kang Jea Lee; Yong Gyoo Hwang; Choong Hun Lee; Chong-Yun Park
errShare
errSave
Graphlet-based Characterization of Directed Networks
err2016-10-13
err78
errOAAI
errSarajlic, Anida; Malod-Dognin, Noel; Yaveroglu, Omer Nebil; Przulj, Natasa
errShare
errSave
Elastic wave velocities and Raman shift of MORB glass at high pressures
err2008-01-01
err0
errOAAI
errYoshio KONO; Hiroaki OHFUJI; Yuji HIGO; Akihiro YAMADA; Toru INOUE; Tetsuo IRIFUNE; Ken-ichi FUNAKOSHI
errShare
errSave
Structural reducibility of multilayer networks
err2015-04-23
err349
errOAAI
errDe Domenico, Manlio; Nicosia, Vincenzo; Arenas, Alexandre; Latora, Vito
errShare
errSave
Magnesium-enriched poultry manure enhances phosphorus bioavailability in biochars
err2023-08-01
err0
errOAAI
errAline do Amaral Leite; Leônidas Carrijo Azevedo Melo; Luis Carlos Colocho Hurtarte; Lucia Zuin; Cristiano Dela Piccolla; Don Werder; Itamar Shabtai; Johannes Lehmann
errShare
errSave
errShare
errSave
Cut Based Method for Comparing Complex Networks
err2018-03-23
err23
errOAAI
errLiu, Qun; Dong, Zhishan; Wang, En
errShare
errSave
researcher View more