arrow
Return

Contrasting thermophilization among forests, grasslands and alpine summits

delete2026-03-18
delete0
PRE
AI
K
Kai Yue *
P
Pieter Vangansbeke
I
Isla H. Myers‐Smith
D
Donald M. Waller
K
Kris Verheyen
M
Markus Bernhardt‐Römermann
L
Lander Baeten
I
Ingmar R. Staude
A
Anne D. Bjorkman
R
Radim Hédl
C
Christopher Andrews
E
Elena Barni
T
Thomas Becker
A
Antoine Becker-Scarpitta
J
José Luis Benito Alonso
J
Jonathan Bennie
I
Imre Berki
J
Jörg Brunet
J
James M. Bullock
H
Hans Van Calster
M
Michele Carbognani
M
Markéta Chudomelová
D
Déborah Closset-kopp
P
Pavel Dan Turtureanu
G
Gergana N. Daskalova
G
Guillaume Decocq
J
Jan Dick
M
Martin Diekmann
T
Thomas Dirnböck
T
Tomasz Durak
O
Ove Eriksson
B
Brigitta Erschbamer
B
Bente J. Graae
T
Thilo Heinken
M
Martin Hermy
P
Peter Horchler
U
Ute Jandt
B
Bogdan Jaroszewicz
R
Róbert Kanka
J
Jozef Kollár
M
Martin Kopecký
A
Andrea Lamprecht
J
Jonathan Lenoir
M
Martin Macek
M
Marek Malicki
F
Frantíšek Máliš
O
Ottar Michelsen
F
Fraser Mitchell
T
Tobias Naaf
T
Thomas A. Nagel
M
Miles Newman
A
A. C. Newton
L
Lena Nicklas
L
Ludovica Oddi
A
Anna Orczewska
S
Simone Orsenigo
A
Adrienne Ortmann-Ajkai
J
J. den Ouden
H
Harald Pauli
G
George Peterken
P
Petr Petřík
R
Remigiusz Pielech
M
Mihai Puşcaş
C
Christophe F. Randin
K
Kamila Reczyńska
C
Christian Rixen
F
Fride Høistad Schei
W
Wolfgang Schmidt
J
Jan Šebesta
A
Alina Stachurska‐Swakoń
T
Tibor Standovár
K
Krzysztof Świerkosz
B
Balázs Teleki
J
Jean‐Paul Theurillat
T
Tudor‐Mihai Ursu
T
Thomas Vanneste
M
Mark Vellend
P
Philippine Vergeer
O
Ondřej Vild
L
Luis Villar
P
Pascal Vittoz
M
Manuela Winkler
S
Sonja Wipf
F
Fuzhong Wu
S
Shengmin Zhang
P
Pieter De Frenne
DOI:10.1038/s41586-025-09622-7delete
deleteOriginal
deleteOriginal request for help
deleteShare
deleteSave
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
Climate warming is shifting biological communities, with warmth-demanding species being favoured at the expense of cold-adapted species in a process referred to as thermophilization1–4. Because biodiversity responses often lag behind climate warming, climatic debts are accumulating in many ecosystems across the world5–7. Although we might expect that thermophilization and climatic debts will vary among habitats, standardized quantification across ecosystems is lacking. Here we analysed multidecadal data from 6,067 resurveyed vegetation plots over 12–78 years in forests, grasslands and on alpine summits across Europe. We demonstrate that forest understory and grassland plant communities experienced positive thermophilization, although not significantly different from zero. By contrast, alpine summit vegetation showed much stronger (up to five times) and significant thermophilization. Thermophilization was driven largely by increases in warmth-demanding species in grasslands, by declines in cold-adapted species on alpine summits and by both processes in forests. Significant climatic debts have accumulated in forests and alpine summits, but less so in grasslands, with debts positively correlated with macroclimate temperature changes. Our findings uncover divergent thermophilization trajectories and increasing climatic debts across ecosystems. Moreover, we highlight the mechanisms that enable some communities to track climate change more closely than others and provide a basis for projecting future shifts in plant communities under accelerating climate warming. Analyses of large-scale, multitaxa and long-term thermophilization patterns in forests, grasslands and alpine summits across Europe provide insight into shifts in community composition among different ecosystems in a warming world.
Keywords:
Climate-change impacts
Community ecology
Science
Humanities and Social Sciences
multidisciplinary

Journal

Nature cover
Nature
IF:
48.5
Papers:
1.8W
Citations:
96.5W

Organization

R
research institute for nature and forest
Scholars:
5
Papers: 5
Citations: 0
B
Babes-Bolyai University
Scholars:
198
Papers: 87
Citations: 0
U
University of Dublin
Scholars:
72
Papers: 36
Citations: 1
B
bournemouth university
Scholars:
162
Papers: 102
Citations: 0
B
bavarian state institute of forestry
Scholars:
4
Papers: 4
Citations: 0
U
University of Innsbruck
Scholars:
9.8K
Papers: 8.6K
Citations: 8
G
Ghent University
Scholars:
5.2W
Papers: 4.5W
Citations: 5.5W
U
university of silesia
Scholars:
359
Papers: 191
Citations: 0
S
slovak academy of sciences
Scholars:
9.4K
Papers: 7.9K
Citations: 4
U
University of Sherbrooke
Scholars:
1.1W
Papers: 9.4K
Citations: 11
U
University of Warsaw
Scholars:
1.2W
Papers: 1.0W
Citations: 1.1W
W
wageningen university
Scholars:
505
Papers: 242
Citations: 2
U
umr pvbmt
Scholars:
12
Papers: 4
Citations: 0
B
beechwood house
Scholars:
1
Papers: 1
Citations: 0
B
bms umweltplanung
Scholars:
1
Papers: 1
Citations: 0
C
centre for ecology and hydrology
Scholars:
119
Papers: 56
Citations: 0
C
CSIC
Scholars:
1.2K
Papers: 550
Citations: 13
U
university of leuven
Scholars:
174
Papers: 83
Citations: 0
U
university of gothenburg
Scholars:
2.6W
Papers: 2.3W
Citations: 33
U
University of Sopron
Scholars:
63
Papers: 33
Citations: 444
N
NTNU
Scholars:
189
Papers: 92
Citations: 4
F
Fujian Normal University
Scholars:
1.2W
Papers: 7.8K
Citations: 1.3W
U
University of Ljubljana
Scholars:
1.5W
Papers: 1.3W
Citations: 1.7W
J
jagiellonian university
Scholars:
2.2W
Papers: 1.8W
Citations: 11
U
university of pavia
Scholars:
2.0W
Papers: 1.6W
Citations: 8
U
university of turin
Scholars:
4.0K
Papers: 1.5K
Citations: 0
U
university of lausanne
Scholars:
2.7K
Papers: 1.2K
Citations: 2
U
university of wisconsin
Scholars:
1.2K
Papers: 575
Citations: 0
F
Federal Institute of Hydrology
Scholars:
30
Papers: 12
Citations: 1.1K
N
norwegian institute of bioeconomy research
Scholars:
70
Papers: 44
Citations: 0
U
universite de picardie jules verne
Scholars:
53
Papers: 26
Citations: 0
U
university of goettingen
Scholars:
87
Papers: 59
Citations: 0
U
university of pecs
Scholars:
682
Papers: 222
Citations: 0
M
Mendel University
Scholars:
27
Papers: 11
Citations: 0
U
university of wroclaw
Scholars:
255
Papers: 134
Citations: 0
E
Environment Agency Austria
Scholars:
13
Papers: 7
Citations: 705
U
university of gottingen
Scholars:
950
Papers: 437
Citations: 0
S
Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences
Scholars:
1.1W
Papers: 1.2W
Citations: 2.1W
C
czech academy of sciences
Scholars:
3.4W
Papers: 2.6W
Citations: 31
U
University of Exeter
Scholars:
2.0W
Papers: 2.1W
Citations: 3.6W
U
University of Potsdam
Scholars:
7.8K
Papers: 7.1K
Citations: 1.4W
A
Austrian Academy of Sciences
Scholars:
4.9K
Papers: 3.9K
Citations: 8.2K
S
Stockholm University
Scholars:
1.8W
Papers: 1.7W
Citations: 32
U
university of rzeszow
Scholars:
734
Papers: 365
Citations: 0
W
wageningen university and research
Scholars:
1.0K
Papers: 417
Citations: 0
F
fondation du jardin botanique flore alpe
Scholars:
1
Papers: 1
Citations: 0
J
jolube consultor botánico y editor
Scholars:
1
Papers: 1
Citations: 0
S
SLF
Scholars:
71
Papers: 36
Citations: 9
U
University of Trier
Scholars:
65
Papers: 44
Citations: 0
U
university of british columbia
Scholars:
2.8K
Papers: 1.3K
Citations: 1
U
University of Bremen
Scholars:
8.1K
Papers: 7.2K
Citations: 1.1W
G
german centre for integrative biodiversity research
Scholars:
40
Papers: 26
Citations: 0
U
University of Parma
Scholars:
1.7W
Papers: 1.3W
Citations: 1.3W
E
Eotvos Lorand University
Scholars:
7.5K
Papers: 6.3K
Citations: 84
T
Technical University in Zvolen
Scholars:
116
Papers: 50
Citations: 0
F
friedrich schiller university jena
Scholars:
515
Papers: 190
Citations: 0
L
Leibniz Centre for Agricultural Landscape Research
Scholars:
118
Papers: 66
Citations: 2.9K
N
norwegian university of science and technology
Scholars:
1.3K
Papers: 685
Citations: 1
researcher View more organizations