Evaluating API-Level Deep Learning Fuzzers: A Comprehensive Benchmarking Study

doi:10.1145/3729533

Return

Evaluating API-Level Deep Learning Fuzzers: A Comprehensive Benchmarking Study

2026-02-01

PRE

Nima Shiri Harzevili *

Moshi Wei

Mohammad Mahdi Mohajer

Song Wang

Hung Viet Pham

DOI：10.1145/3729533

Original

Original request for help

Save

Abstract

En 中文

In recent years, the practice of fuzzing Deep Learning (DL) APIs has received significant attention in the software engineering community. Many API-level DL fuzzers have been proposed to test individual DL APIs by generating malformed input. Although these fuzzers have been effective in detecting bugs and outperforming prior work, there remains a gap in benchmarking them against ground-truth, real-world bugs in DL libraries. Existing comparisons among these API-level DL fuzzers primarily focus on the bugs detected but do not offer a comprehensive, in-depth evaluation of the fuzzers' effectiveness. In this work, we perform the first in-depth evaluation of state-of-the-art API-level DL fuzzers that generate tests for single DL APIs, focusing on their effectiveness against real-world bugs. We manually created an extensive benchmark dataset, including 517 real-world DL bugs collected from PyTorch and TensorFlow libraries that can be triggered by malformed inputs. We then apply seven state-of-the-art DL fuzzers-FreeFuzz, DeepRel, NablaFuzz, DocTer, ACETest, TitanFuzz, and FuzzGPT-to our benchmark dataset, following their respective instructions. Our results show that these fuzzers detect only 6.5% (34 out of 517) of the unique real-world bugs in the dataset. Our analysis identifies two dominant factors that impact the effectiveness of these fuzzers in detecting real-world bugs. These findings suggest opportunities for improving the performance of fuzzers in future work. Overall, this study extends previous work on DL fuzzers by providing an extensive evaluation and benchmarking platform for fuzzing DL libraries.

Keywords:

fuzzing

deep learning

benchmarking