arrow
Return

Experimentation Without Randomised Controls

delete2025-04-04
delete0
PRE
AI
S
Stephen D. Simon *
DOI:10.1111/joor.13960delete
deleteOriginal
deleteOriginal request for help
deleteShare
deleteSave
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
BackgroundIn an experimental study, researchers often have the ability to assign different treatments. This is often done with randomisation. There are many settings; however, where it is not desirable to use randomisation. It is unclear how to best design an experimental study without randomisation while still providing persuasive evidence.ObjectivesThe aim of this study was to outline several approaches, broadly classified as quasiexperimental studies, where researchers can use methodologically sound alternatives to randomisation.ResultsThe interrupted time series, phased inventions, withdrawal design, waiting list control group, stepped wedge design and regression discontinuity all represent approaches where careful nonrandom allocation to treatment groups can produce high-quality research findings.ConclusionQuasiexperimental studies can produce rigorous research findings. The allocation to treatment groups and the times of evaluation need to be carefully designed. Proper use of these quasiexperimental approaches can enhance research options in settings where the research team has control of allocation but finds randomisation to be problematic.
Keywords:
interrupted time series
quasiexperimental studies
stepped wedge design
withdrawal design

Journal

Journal of Oral Rehabilitation cover
Journal of Oral Rehabilitation
IF:
4
Papers:
4.5K
Citations:
9.6K

Organization

U
University of Missouri-Kansas City
Scholars:
211
Papers: 123
Citations: 2
Cited Papers

Cited Papers

Randomized and nonrandomized studies: Complementary or competing?
err2014-11-01
err0
PREAI
errNikolaos Pandis; Yu-Kang Tu; Padhraig S. Fleming; Argy Polychronopoulou
errShare
errSave
Efficacy of Low-Level Laser Therapy for Oral Mucositis in Hematologic Patients Undergoing Transplantation: A Single-Arm Prospective Study
err2023-11-13
err3
errOAAI
errNishi, Hiromi; Horikoshi, Susumu; Ohta, Kouji; Yoshida, Tetsumi; Fukushima, Noriyasu; Oshita, Kyoko; Munenaga, Syuichi; Edahiro, Taro; Ureshino, Hiroshi; Shigeishi, Hideo; Yoshioka, Yukio; Konishi, Masaru; Ide, Noriaki; Ogawa, Yuma; Marukawa, Rikou; Shintani, Tomoaki; Ino, Natumi; Kajiya, Mikihito; Kakimoto, Naoya; Ohge, Hiroki; Ichinohe, Tatsuo; Kawaguchi, Hiroyuki
errShare
errSave
Differences in prevalence of self-reported oral hypofunction between older adult patients with rheumatoid arthritis and the general older population: A cross-sectional study using propensity score matching
err2024-02-14
err1
errOAAI
errKudo, Yoko; Takeuchi, Kenji; Kusama, Taro; Kojima, Toshihisa; Waguri-Nagaya, Yuko; Nagayoshi, Mako; Kondo, Katsunori; Mizuta, Kentaro; Osaka, Ken; Kojima, Masayo
errShare
errSave
err
IF0
err
err0
PREAI
err
errShare
errSave
Observational Studies
err2002-01-01
err0
errOAAI
errPaul R. Rosenbaum
errShare
errSave
Experimental Designs to Optimize Treatments for Individuals Personalized N-of-1 Trials
err2021-04-01
err24
errOAAI
errDavidson, Karina W.; Silverstein, Michael; Cheung, Ken; Paluch, Rocco A.; Epstein, Leonard H.
errShare
errSave
err
IF0
err
err0
PREAI
err
errShare
errSave
err
IF0
err
err0
PREAI
err
errShare
errSave
researcher View more