arrow
Return

Fast track algorithm: How to differentiate a scleroderma pattern from a non-scleroderma pattern

delete2019-11-01
delete107
delete
OA
AI
V
Vanessa Smith *
A
Amber Vanhaecke
O
Oliver Distler
C
Christopher P. Denton
E
Ellen Deschepper
A
Alberto Sulli
M
Madelon C Vonk
U
Ulrich A. Walker
A
Alexandra, Balbir
S
Sofia, Barreira
L
Laura, Barrio Nogal
J
Joanna, Bartosinska
A
Anna, Bazela-Zadura
R
Rikke, Bech
A
Ana, Begovic
D
Devis, Benfaremo
R
Rens, Besseling
M
Martin, Bevan
V
Vladimira, Boyadzhieva
L
Luisa, Brites
V
Victor, Cazac
R
Radia, Chetouane-Bennafaa
J
Jacopo, Ciaffi
M
Mariateresa, Cirillo
I
Ines, Condeiro
C
Campochiaro, Corrado
N
Nemanja, Damjanov
Y
Yordanova, Damyana
A
Aleksandra, Danczak-Pazdrowska
R
Rossella, De Angelis
M
Meeke, de Kanter
M
Michael, De Moor
J
Jeska, de Vries-Bouwstra
B
Blerina, Dhamo
B
Balebail, Dharmanand
E
Emmanuela, Emperiale Valentina
N
Nouran, Eshak
E
Eleonora, Farina
I
Isabelle, Ferdinand
H
Havard, Fretheim
O
Olga, Gaidarji
S
Sara, Ganhao Santos
O
Onay, Gercik
K
Karina, Gheorghe
K
Katarzyna, Gruszecka
H
Hamida, Guerboukha
K
Karin, Gunnarsson
L
Lauren, Host
P
Po-Hao, Huang
S
Sherif, Ismail
M
Michal, Jakubaszek
C
Claudia, Kedor
F
Floor, Kerstens
P
Paula, Keskitalo
N
Nikita, Khmelinskii
A
Angeliki, Koulouri
E
Eugene, Kucharz
C
Carina, Lopes
F
Fabian, Ltscher
M
Mariana, Luis
P
Patricia, Martins
P
Puneet, Mashru
D
Daniela, Mazzocchi
Y
Yimy, Medina
K
Karin, Melsens
B
Bartosz, Miziolek
A
Agna, Neto
T
Tu, Nguyen Thanh Hien
T
Tandrup, Nielsen Christoffer
M
Mohamed, Osman
M
Monica, Pendolino
S
Stefaan, Poriau
M
Marta, Priora
M
Mislav, Radic
B
Bea, Radovits
M
Miriam, Raquel
G
Gabriela, Rinzis Mirela
K
Katarzyna, Romanowska-Prochnicka
V
Vasco, Romao
D
Danilo, Ruiz
B
Barbara, Russo
I
Ioana, Rusu
A
Anindita, Santosa
M
Mostafa, Seyed Mardani Seyed
T
Theodora, Simopolou
A
Alexia, Steelandt
W
Wendy, Stevens
N
Nikolay, Stoilov
G
Georgiana, Strugariu
B
Baidy, Sy Kane
S
Samuele, Tardito
C
Catarina, Tenazinha
A
Anna, Thoma
A
Amelia, Trombetta
F
Frank, van den Hoogen
N
Noortje, Van Herwaarden
E
Erwin, Van Spil
M
Michael, Vanden Bulcke
L
Lucas, Verniers
G
Guiseppe, Zampogna
DOI:10.1016/j.autrev.2019.102394delete
deleteOriginal
deleteShare
deleteSave
View PDF
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
Objectives: This study was designed to propose a simple Fast Track algorithm for capillaroscopists of any level of experience to differentiate scleroderma patterns from non-scleroderma patterns on capillaroscopy and to assess its inter-rater reliability. Methods: Based on existing definitions to categorise capillaroscopic images as scleroderma patterns and taking into account the real life variability of capillaroscopic images described standardly according to the European League Against Rheumatism (EULAR) Study Group on Microcirculation in Rheumatic Diseases, a fast track decision tree, the Fast Track algorithm was created by the principal expert (VS) to facilitate swift categorisation of an image as non-scleroderma pattern (category 1) or scleroderma pattern (category 2). Mean inter-rater reliability between all raters (experts/attendees) of the 8th EULAR course on capillaroscopy in Rheumatic Diseases (Genoa, 2018) and, as external validation, of the 8th European Scleroderma Trials and Research group (EUSTAR) course on systemic sclerosis (SSc) (Nijmegen, 2019) versus the principal expert, as well as reliability between the rater pairs themselves was assessed by mean Cohen's and Light's kappa coefficients. Results: Mean Cohen's kappa was 1/0.96 (95% CI 0.95-0.98) for the 6 experts/135 attendees of the 8th EULAR capillaroscopy course and 1/0.94 (95% CI 0.92-0.96) for the 3 experts/85 attendees of the 8th EUSTAR SSc course. Light's kappa was 1/0.92 at the 8th EULAR capillaroscopy course, and 1/0.87 at the 8th EUSTAR SSc course. C Conclusion: For the first time, a clinical expert based fast track decision algorithm has been developed to differentiate a non-scleroderma from a scleroderma pattern on capillaroscopic images, demonstrating excellent reliability when applied by capillaroscopists with varying levels of expertise versus the principal expert and corroborated with external validation.
Keywords:
EULAR Study Group on Microcirculation in
Rheumatic Diseases
Capillaroscopy
Reliability
Scleroderma patterns
Novices
AI Summary

AI Summary

Key information extracted from the uploaded paper, including a brief overview, abstract, background, key highlights, visual analysis, and future outlook.

Journal

Autoimmunity Reviews cover
Autoimmunity Reviews
IF:
8.3
Papers:
3.3K
Citations:
1.4W

Organization

U
University of Pecs
Scholars:
6.3K
Papers: 4.3K
Citations: 3.9K
V
VIB
Scholars:
7.8K
Papers: 5.2K
Citations: 18
U
universidade de lisboa
Scholars:
3.4W
Papers: 3.1W
Citations: 29
G
Ghent University
Scholars:
5.2W
Papers: 4.5W
Citations: 5.5W
U
University of Copenhagen
Scholars:
7.6W
Papers: 6.6W
Citations: 86
S
St Vincent's Hospital Sydney
Scholars:
3.3K
Papers: 2.7K
Citations: 2.2K
U
Universidad Nacional de Colombia
Scholars:
7.8K
Papers: 5.8K
Citations: 4.8K
U
University of Basel
Scholars:
3.1W
Papers: 2.4W
Citations: 38
V
Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
Scholars:
4.2W
Papers: 3.7W
Citations: 3.7W
U
University of Tokyo
Scholars:
7.1W
Papers: 6.5W
Citations: 2.2K
A
Asklepios Klinik Altona
Scholars:
310
Papers: 266
Citations: 374
H
hospital spedali civili brescia
Scholars:
6.1K
Papers: 4.0K
Citations: 1
I
iuliu hatieganu university of medicine & pharmacy
Scholars:
5.9K
Papers: 3.1K
Citations: 2
C
china medical university hospital - taiwan
Scholars:
4.3K
Papers: 4.2K
Citations: 2
U
university hospital brussels
Scholars:
3.4K
Papers: 2.5K
Citations: 3
M
medical university gdansk
Scholars:
5.3K
Papers: 4.2K
Citations: 101
F
fahrenheit universities
Scholars:
1.6W
Papers: 1.3W
Citations: 21
S
Stanford Medicine
Scholars:
2.5K
Papers: 1.5K
Citations: 8.1K
M
Marche Polytechnic University
Scholars:
1.2W
Papers: 9.5K
Citations: 1.1W
U
University of Indonesia
Scholars:
8.1K
Papers: 4.2K
Citations: 3.2K
U
University of Witwatersrand
Scholars:
1.4W
Papers: 1.1W
Citations: 12
U
University of Sherbrooke
Scholars:
1.1W
Papers: 9.5K
Citations: 11
U
university of hamburg
Scholars:
3.7W
Papers: 2.9W
Citations: 30
U
University of Oulu
Scholars:
1.5W
Papers: 1.3W
Citations: 1.6W
U
Utrecht University
Scholars:
6.0W
Papers: 5.1W
Citations: 5.8W
R
Rigshospitalet
Scholars:
1.7W
Papers: 1.3W
Citations: 2.1W
U
university of milano-bicocca
Scholars:
2.0W
Papers: 1.5W
Citations: 22
U
University of Utah
Scholars:
3.0W
Papers: 2.2W
Citations: 4.6W
A
aou san giovanni battista-molinette
Scholars:
2.9K
Papers: 2.1K
Citations: 1
U
university zurich hospital
Scholars:
1.2W
Papers: 9.5K
Citations: 7
U
University Medical Centre Ljubljana
Scholars:
3.3K
Papers: 2.6K
Citations: 0
I
Izmir Katip Celebi University
Scholars:
1.7K
Papers: 1.5K
Citations: 12
L
lomonosov moscow state university
Scholars:
2.1W
Papers: 1.5W
Citations: 19
U
universite de rennes
Scholars:
1.7W
Papers: 1.3W
Citations: 30
U
University of Verona
Scholars:
1.9W
Papers: 1.4W
Citations: 1.5W
U
universite de montreal
Scholars:
4.6W
Papers: 3.8W
Citations: 46
U
University of Padua
Scholars:
5.1W
Papers: 4.3W
Citations: 57
A
Aarhus University
Scholars:
4.3W
Papers: 4.2W
Citations: 4.8W
H
Hacettepe University
Scholars:
1.2W
Papers: 1.0W
Citations: 11
S
Stanford University
Scholars:
9.6W
Papers: 8.2W
Citations: 17.0W
U
University College London
Scholars:
7.9W
Papers: 6.2W
Citations: 15.7W
S
Salford Royal NHS Foundation Trust
Scholars:
3.2K
Papers: 2.5K
Citations: 2.1K
S
St Vincent's Health
Scholars:
3.2K
Papers: 2.4K
Citations: 430
N
national research centre (nrc)
Scholars:
6.1K
Papers: 5.5K
Citations: 3
E
egyptian knowledge bank (ekb)
Scholars:
11.6W
Papers: 9.3W
Citations: 84
L
leiden university - excl lumc
Scholars:
3.5W
Papers: 2.9W
Citations: 46
U
universidade federal do tocantins (uft)
Scholars:
908
Papers: 522
Citations: 0
A
azienda ospedaliera - universita di padova
Scholars:
4.5K
Papers: 3.4K
Citations: 5
G
grigore t popa university of medicine & pharmacy
Scholars:
4.5K
Papers: 2.1K
Citations: 5
V
vu university medical center
Scholars:
6.2K
Papers: 4.8K
Citations: 5
Japanese Red Cross Medical Center cover
Japanese Red Cross Medical Center
Scholars:
779
Papers: 589
Citations: 323
M
ministry of health of the russian federation
Scholars:
4.1K
Papers: 1.5K
Citations: 6
U
University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf
Scholars:
1.8W
Papers: 1.3W
Citations: 2.0W
U
University of Ljubljana
Scholars:
1.5W
Papers: 1.3W
Citations: 1.7W
U
university of belgrade
Scholars:
2.8W
Papers: 2.1W
Citations: 25
R
Rambam Health Care Campus
Scholars:
4.0K
Papers: 3.0K
Citations: 3.0K
U
university of alberta
Scholars:
5.1W
Papers: 4.9W
Citations: 65
U
university of zurich
Scholars:
5.1W
Papers: 4.0W
Citations: 65
U
university of pavia
Scholars:
2.1W
Papers: 1.6W
Citations: 8
P
prince of asturias university hospital
Scholars:
1.3K
Papers: 855
Citations: 1
I
ibn rochd university hospital center of casablanca
Scholars:
401
Papers: 274
Citations: 0
C
China Medical University Taiwan
Scholars:
1.2W
Papers: 1.1W
Citations: 6
U
Utrecht University Medical Center
Scholars:
2.1W
Papers: 1.8W
Citations: 30
S
sao joao hospital
Scholars:
2.6K
Papers: 1.7K
Citations: 1
D
Democritus University of Thrace
Scholars:
4.8K
Papers: 3.7K
Citations: 3.8K
U
University of Nebraska Lincoln
Scholars:
7.8K
Papers: 6.5K
Citations: 2.0W
U
university of oslo
Scholars:
4.2W
Papers: 3.5W
Citations: 53
C
Chiba University
Scholars:
1.5W
Papers: 1.1W
Citations: 1.0W
P
Poznan University of Medical Sciences
Scholars:
7.6K
Papers: 5.3K
Citations: 5.1K
M
medical university - sofia
Scholars:
3.7K
Papers: 2.5K
Citations: 2
U
Universite Paris Cite
Scholars:
8.9W
Papers: 6.3W
Citations: 604
U
University of Lausanne
Scholars:
2.5W
Papers: 2.0W
Citations: 3.0W
M
Medical University of Warsaw
Scholars:
9.6K
Papers: 7.2K
Citations: 12
S
St. Marien Hospital
Scholars:
1.8K
Papers: 1.4K
Citations: 168
L
leiden university medical center (lumc)
Scholars:
1.9W
Papers: 1.5W
Citations: 12
O
ollscoil na gaillimhe-university of galway
Scholars:
1.1W
Papers: 8.7K
Citations: 5
U
university of occupational & environmental health - japan
Scholars:
3.1K
Papers: 2.4K
Citations: 4
C
centre hospitalier universitaire vaudois (chuv)
Scholars:
9.4K
Papers: 7.4K
Citations: 15
N
NSW Health
Scholars:
1.9W
Papers: 1.5W
Citations: 12
U
university of geneva
Scholars:
3.6W
Papers: 2.9W
Citations: 35
U
University of Perugia
Scholars:
1.8W
Papers: 1.4W
Citations: 1.5W
U
university of munster
Scholars:
2.9W
Papers: 2.2W
Citations: 45
K
Karolinska University Hospital
Scholars:
1.4W
Papers: 1.1W
Citations: 2.5W
U
university of london
Scholars:
21.5W
Papers: 19.7W
Citations: 305
G
Gazi University
Scholars:
9.5K
Papers: 7.5K
Citations: 5.0K
U
university of leeds
Scholars:
3.6W
Papers: 3.3W
Citations: 45
C
Changi General Hospital
Scholars:
1.8K
Papers: 1.2K
Citations: 825
H
Hassan II University of Casablanca
Scholars:
5.4K
Papers: 3.4K
Citations: 3
U
universite libre de bruxelles
Scholars:
2.0W
Papers: 1.7W
Citations: 27
C
carl gustav carus university hospital
Scholars:
5.4K
Papers: 4.1K
Citations: 1
Q
quironsalud group
Scholars:
1.4K
Papers: 861
Citations: 1
U
Utah System of Higher Education
Scholars:
4.6W
Papers: 4.0W
Citations: 161
M
Medical University Silesia
Scholars:
6.9K
Papers: 5.1K
Citations: 18
V
Vrije Universiteit Brussel
Scholars:
1.4W
Papers: 1.3W
Citations: 129
A
Alexandria University
Scholars:
6.6K
Papers: 5.5K
Citations: 9.5K
J
justus liebig university giessen
Scholars:
1.5W
Papers: 1.2W
Citations: 95
C
CHU Lille
Scholars:
7.9K
Papers: 6.2K
Citations: 8
R
royal free london nhs foundation trust
Scholars:
3.2K
Papers: 2.4K
Citations: 3
U
universite de lille
Scholars:
2.7W
Papers: 2.0W
Citations: 15
U
University of Groningen
Scholars:
4.4W
Papers: 4.3W
Citations: 5.9W
H
Hebrew University of Jerusalem
Scholars:
2.8W
Papers: 2.3W
Citations: 2.7W
L
Leiden University
Scholars:
4.0W
Papers: 3.3W
Citations: 3.8W
K
Karolinska Institutet
Scholars:
5.8W
Papers: 4.8W
Citations: 7.1W
M
McGill University
Scholars:
5.5W
Papers: 4.9W
Citations: 7.0W
E
egas moniz hospital
Scholars:
450
Papers: 287
Citations: 0
C
centro hospitalar de lisboa ocidental, epe
Scholars:
916
Papers: 541
Citations: 1
S
sint maartens clinic
Scholars:
682
Papers: 557
Citations: 1
C
CHU Rennes
Scholars:
5.2K
Papers: 3.7K
Citations: 23
H
Hadassah University Medical Center
Scholars:
4.0K
Papers: 2.7K
Citations: 8
H
Hospital Santa Maria
Scholars:
1.6K
Papers: 1.2K
Citations: 2
A
a.o.u. citta della salute e della scienza di torino
Scholars:
1.1W
Papers: 6.9K
Citations: 4
A
Azienda Ospedaliera Universitaria Integrata Verona
Scholars:
5.0K
Papers: 3.5K
Citations: 1.6K
R
Radboud University Nijmegen
Scholars:
4.4W
Papers: 3.4W
Citations: 5.4W
U
universidade de coimbra
Scholars:
1.9W
Papers: 1.6W
Citations: 16
I
IRCCS Ospedale San Raffaele
Scholars:
1.4W
Papers: 1.0W
Citations: 6.0K
V
Vita-Salute San Raffaele University
Scholars:
2.7W
Papers: 1.6W
Citations: 1.4W
U
university of genoa
Scholars:
3.0W
Papers: 2.2W
Citations: 20
U
University of Manchester
Scholars:
5.7W
Papers: 5.3W
Citations: 7.4W
T
Technische Universitat Dresden
Scholars:
3.2W
Papers: 2.5W
Citations: 249
G
Ghent University Hospital
Scholars:
8.4K
Papers: 6.6K
Citations: 1.6W
U
universidad de chile
Scholars:
2.1W
Papers: 1.4W
Citations: 18
M
Medical University of Lublin
Scholars:
6.5K
Papers: 4.8K
Citations: 4
U
University Cheikh Anta Diop Dakar
Scholars:
2.0K
Papers: 1.1K
Citations: 2
University of Nebraska System cover
University of Nebraska System
Scholars:
2.7W
Papers: 2.3W
Citations: 58
S
sapienza university rome
Scholars:
6.3W
Papers: 4.7W
Citations: 381
U
universita della campania vanvitelli
Scholars:
1.8W
Papers: 1.4W
Citations: 13
G
general university gregorio maranon hospital
Scholars:
8.2K
Papers: 5.5K
Citations: 3
researcher View more organizations
Cited Papers

Cited Papers

Convenient preparation of sterically hindered selones
err2002-05-01
err0
PREAI
errFrank S. Guziec; Christine A. Moustakis
errShare
errSave
errShare
errSave
err
IF0
err
err0
PREAI
err
errShare
errSave
Reliability of the qualitative and semiquantitative nailfold videocapillaroscopy assessment in a systemic sclerosis cohort: a two-centre study
err2010-06-01
err145
errOAAI
errSmith, Vanessa; Pizzorni, Carmen; De Keyser, Filip; Decuman, Saskia; Van Praet, Jens T.; Deschepper, Ellen; Sulli, Alberto; Cutolo, Maurizio
errShare
errSave
Preliminary criteria for the very early diagnosis of systemic sclerosis: results of a Delphi Consensus Study from EULAR Scleroderma Trials and Research Group
err2011-03-01
err339
errOAAI
errAvouac, J.; Fransen, J.; Walker, U. A.; Riccieri, V.; Smith, V.; Muller, C.; Miniati, I.; Tarner, I. H.; Bellando Randone, S.; Cutolo, M.; Allanore, Y.; Distler, O.; Valentini, G.; Czirjak, L.; Mueller-Ladner, U.; Furst, D. E.; Tyndall, A.; Matucci-Cerinic, M.
errShare
errSave
errShare
errSave
Guest Editorial
err2007-07-27
err0
PREAI
errUpkar Varshney; Oscar Mayora
errShare
errSave
2013 classification criteria for systemic sclerosis: an American college of rheumatology/European league against rheumatism collaborative initiative
err2013-11-01
err2.8K
errOAAI
errvan den Hoogen, Frank; Khanna, Dinesh; Fransen, Jaap; Johnson, Sindhu R.; Baron, Murray; Tyndall, Alan; Matucci-Cerinic, Marco; Naden, Raymond P.; Medsger, Thomas A., Jr.; Carreira, Patricia E.; Riemekasten, Gabriela; Clements, Philip J.; Denton, Christopher P.; Distler, Oliver; Allanore, Yannick; Furst, Daniel E.; Gabrielli, Armando; Mayes, Maureen D.; van Laar, Jacob M.; Seibold, James R.; Czirjak, Laszlo; Steen, Virginia D.; Inanc, Murat; Kowal-Bielecka, Otylia; Mueller-Ladner, Ulf; Valentini, Gabriele; Veale, Douglas J.; Vonk, Madelon C.; Walker, Ulrich A.; Chung, Lorinda; Collier, David H.; Csuka, Mary Ellen; Fessler, Barri J.; Guiducci, Serena; Herrick, Ariane; Hsu, Vivien M.; Jimenez, Sergio; Kahaleh, Bashar; Merkel, Peter A.; Sierakowski, Stanislav; Silver, Richard M.; Simms, Robert W.; Varga, John; Pope, Janet E.
errShare
errSave
errShare
errSave
researcher View more