1
Return

From fixed to dynamic: setting flow-related habitat values for macroinvertebrate ecological status assessment in Mediterranean rivers

delete2026-07-19
delete0
delete
OA
AI
S
Silvia Quadroni
S
Stefania Erba *
M
Marcello Cazzola
S
Simona Cislaghi
A
Andrea Buffagni
DOI:10.1186/s12302-026-01455-zdelete
deleteOriginal
deleteOriginal request for help
deleteShare
deleteSave
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
Type-specific reference conditions are the anchor point of classifications of river ecological status. Usually based on the idea of a fixed and predictable status, they contrast with river dynamic hydrological trajectories. In this study, we focused on the impact of temporal streamflow variation and the related changes of lentic-lotic character of Mediterranean rivers on the definition of reference conditions for the assessment of their ecological status based on benthic macroinvertebrate community. Starting from 71-year long streamflow timeseries of a reference and a slightly altered river reach, located in the Sardinia Island, and using empirical relationships, we investigated the annual and monthly variability of the lentic-lotic character and of the biological metrics used to define the ecological status of Italian rivers (STAR_ICM index and its six sub-metrics) in different mesohabitats (pool and riffle). Then, we compared the result of the application of dynamic vs. fixed reference conditions for the STAR_ICMi calculation and ecological status classification. As expected, the lentic-lotic character of Sardinian rivers fluctuates continuously over time from lotic conditions in winter to extremely lentic conditions in summer, with significant variations from one year to another. All the biological metrics vary consequently over time, with a significant reduction in the summer months due to droughts/low flows and display a higher variability in pool than in riffle. If dynamic instead of fixed reference conditions are used, quality classification shifts towards better ecological status, proving the potentially strong impact of ignoring the effects of natural habitat variability when assessing river ecological status.
Keywords:
Streamflow
Lentic-lotic character
Benthic macroinvertebrates
Mesohabitat
Reference conditions
Water framework directive

Journal

Environmental Sciences Europe cover
Environmental Sciences Europe
IF:
6
Papers:
1.4K
Citations:
5.6K

Organization

W
Water Research Institute
Scholars:
80
Papers: 34
Citations: 1.6K
Cited Papers

Cited Papers

Citing Papers

Citing Papers