arrow
Return

Human Morality Difference when Programming and Actually Operating Autonomous Machines

delete2025-03-05
delete0
PRE
AI
W
Wenfeng Yi
W
Wenhan Wu
M
Maoyin Chen *
X
Xiaoping Zheng *
DOI:10.26599/TST.2024.9010062delete
deleteOriginal
deleteOriginal request for help
deleteShare
deleteSave
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
Autonomous machines (AMs) are poised to possess human-like moral cognition, yet their morality is often pre-programmed for safety. This raises the question of whether the morality intended by programmers aligns with their actions during actual operation, a crucial consideration for a future society with both humans and AMs. Investigating this, we use a micro-robot swarm in a simulated fire scenario, with 180 participants, including 102 robot programmers, completing moral questionnaires and participating in virtual escape trials. These exercises mirror common societal moral dilemmas. Our comparative analysis reveals a morality gap between programming presets and real-time operation, primarily influenced by uncertainty about the future and heightened by external pressures, especially social punishment. This discrepancy suggests that operational morality can diverge from programmed intentions, underlining the need for careful AM design to foster a collaborative and efficient society.
Keywords:
Ethics
Uncertainty
Decision making
Programming
Real-time systems
Safety
Stakeholders
Mirrors
Machinery
Stress
moral machines
moral level
autonomous machines (AMs)
emergency evacuation
robot crowd

Journal

T
Tsinghua Science and Technology
IF:
3.5
Papers:
987
Citations:
2.5K

Organization

T
tsinghua university
Scholars:
11.8W
Papers: 10.0W
Citations: 137
C
china university of petroleum
Scholars:
4.1W
Papers: 2.7W
Citations: 30