arrow
Return

Indirect Reciprocity Enhances Collective Cooperation on Weighted Networks

delete2025-10-23
delete0
PRE
AI
H
Hui Wei
张建磊 cover
张建磊 (Jianlei Zhang)
张春燕 cover
张春燕 (Chunyan Zhang)
M
Ming Cao
DOI:10.1109/TCYB.2025.3617531delete
deleteOriginal
deleteShare
deleteSave
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
Direct, indirect, and network reciprocities are established mechanisms that sustain cooperation in natural and artificial systems. Yet which mechanism most effectively promotes cooperation on a given network remains unclear. Here, we develop a game-theoretic model to explore the evolution of direct and indirect reciprocity on weighted networks. Unlike classical donor–recipient frameworks, we study symmetric repeated interactions on undirected weighted networks with bilateral reputation updates, capturing heterogeneous tie strengths and accelerating reputation spread. We derive a general condition for reciprocal cooperation that unifies unweighted and weighted cases. Across large ensembles of random and empirical networks, indirect reciprocity consistently enhances cooperation, whereas stronger interactions sharply lower the benefit-to-cost threshold under direct reciprocity. To test the robustness of these insights, we examine competition among six reciprocity strategies and find that indirect reciprocity dominates. Our findings demonstrate that choosing the right reciprocity can promote global cooperation on social networks.
Keywords:
Complex networks
cooperation
evolutionary game theory
reciprocity

Journal

IEEE Transactions on Cybernetics cover
IEEE Transactions on Cybernetics
IF:
10.5
Papers:
1.1W
Citations:
5.0W

Organization

P
Peking University
Scholars:
1.0W
Papers: 3.8K
Citations: 14.7W
U
university of groningen
Scholars:
5.6K
Papers: 2.3K
Citations: 0
N
nankai university
Scholars:
4.8W
Papers: 3.3W
Citations: 74
researcher View more organizations
Cited Papers

Cited Papers

errShare
errSave
Heterogeneously Networked Evolutionary Games With Intergroup Conflicts
err2024-10-01
err4
PREAI
errLiu, Aixin; Wang, Lin; Chen, Guanrong; Guan, Xinping
errShare
errSave
Payoff Control in Multichannel Games: Influencing Opponent Learning Evolution
err2025-02-01
err0
PREAI
errShi,Juan; Chu,Chen; Fan,Guoxi; Hu,Die; Liu,Jinzhuo; Wang,Zhen; Hu,Shuyue
errShare
errSave
Indirect reciprocity with private, noisy, and incomplete information
err2018-11-14
err102
errOAAI
errHilbe, Christian; Schmid, Laura; Tkadlec, Josef; Chatterjee, Krishnendu; Nowak, Martin A.
errShare
errSave
The evolution of universal cooperation
err2023-02-17
err15
errOAAI
errGross, Jorg; Meder, Zsombor Z.; De Dreu, Carsten K. W.; Romano, Angelo; Molenmaker, Welmer E.; Hoenig, Laura C.
errShare
errSave
Direct reciprocity in structured populations
err2012-06-04
err182
errOAAI
errvan Veelen, Matthijs; Garcia, Julian; Rand, David G.; Nowak, Martin A.
errShare
errSave
researcher View more