arrow
Return

Inferential procedures for random effects in generalized linear mixed models

delete2025-04-16
delete0
delete
OA
AI
N
Ning Xu *
F
Francis K. C. Hui
A
A. H. Welsh
DOI:10.1371/journal.pone.0320797delete
deleteOriginal
deleteOriginal request for help
deleteShare
deleteSave
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
We study three commonly applied measures of uncertainty for random effects prediction in generalized linear mixed models (GLMMs), namely the unconditional and conditional mean squared errors of prediction (UMSEP and CMSEP, respectively), and the unconditional variance of the prediction gap used by the popular R package for glmmTMB. We demonstrate that, although the three theoretical measures differ in how they quantify uncertainty, the resulting estimators all turn out to be very similar in form. We derive asymptotic results regarding the consistency of the three measures of uncertainty, and in doing so resolve a contradiction between theoretical and empirical results for the glmmTMB variance estimator by re-interpreting it conditionally on a finite subset of the random effects. Our results have important implications for predictive inference in GLMMs, particularly around the legitimacy and implications of coupling these measures with a normality assumption to construct prediction intervals for the random effects.
Keywords:
MEAN SQUARED ERROR
MISSING DATA
LONGITUDINAL DATA
STANDARD ERRORS
PREDICTION
APPROXIMATIONS

Journal

PLoS One cover
PLoS One
IF:
2.6
Papers:
2.6W
Citations:
81.6W

Organization

A
Australian Natl Univ
Scholars:
865
Papers: 494
Citations: 212