arrow
Return

PhyCARE reporting guidelines for physiotherapy case reports: a consensus-based development

delete2026-01-27
delete0
PRE
AI
W
Waqar M. Naqvi
G
Gaurav Mishra *
S
Summaiya Zareen Shaikh
A
Aishwarya A. Pashine
E
Eleuterio A. Sánchez Romero
N
Narasimman Swaminathan
M
Mariya Jiandani
P
Pablo Herrero
B
Bohdanna T. Zazulak
C
Chelsea E. Macpherson
C
Chanan Goyal
J
Joshua R Zadro
P
Payal Sahni
T
Tiziano Innocenti
Q
Quazi Syed Zahiruddin
T
Thomas TJ. Hoogeboom
C
Carlotte Kiekens
DOI:10.1136/bmjopen-2025-110765delete
deleteOriginal
deleteOriginal request for help
deleteShare
deleteSave
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
Objectives Case reports (CRs) are essential in physiotherapy, yet reporting remains heterogeneous and insufficiently standardised. The 2013 CAse REport (CARE) guideline improves transparency but lacks physiotherapy-specific detail. This study aimed to develop a consensus-driven extension of the CARE reporting guideline to support structured reporting of physiotherapy CRs, encompassing physiotherapy-specific assessments and interventions. Design An e-Delphi consensus process study following the ACcurate COnsensus Reporting Document (ACCORD) guidelines. Setting Online. Participants Forty-four international experts in physiotherapy practice, research and education, along with six core committee members. Methods Experts objectively scored items for relevance (5-point Likert scale) and provided open-ended responses for each item of the drafts. Scores and responses were analysed to facilitate iterative refinement of the Physiotherapy CAse REport (PhyCARE) reporting guidelines. Consensus was predetermined at over 70% agreement. Results Round 1 had the majority of items achieving >= 70% agreement, except two items that did not meet the threshold were revised and replaced with an alternative. Five new items addressing physiotherapy-specific reporting needs were added, and 10 items were relocated. In round 2, all 35 items across 13 domains achieved 84%-100% agreement. The nomenclature of one domain was revised to 'Outcomes and Follow-up'. Following two e-Delphi rounds, consensus was achieved, and suggestions from online meeting, piloting led to item rephrasing, after which the PhyCARE guidelines were finalised. Conclusion The PhyCARE guidelines have the potential to provide a physiotherapy-specific extension of CARE to support structured, transparent and reproducible reporting of physiotherapy CRs.
Keywords:
Patient Care Management
Patient-Centered Care
Physical Therapy Modalities
Patient Reported Outcome Measures
Physical Fitness

Journal

BMJ Open cover
BMJ Open
IF:
2.3
Papers:
2.9K
Citations:
9.2W

Organization

J
jawaharlal nehru medical college wardha
Scholars:
287
Papers: 238
Citations: 1
State University System of Florida cover
State University System of Florida
Scholars:
12.6W
Papers: 10.8W
Citations: 130
U
university of sydney
Scholars:
5.3K
Papers: 2.4K
Citations: 0
U
University of Zaragoza
Scholars:
1.4W
Papers: 1.2W
Citations: 14
Florida Gulf Coast University cover
Florida Gulf Coast University
Scholars:
567
Papers: 466
Citations: 619
V
vrije universiteit amsterdam
Scholars:
2.7K
Papers: 1.2K
Citations: 0
W
washington university (wustl)
Scholars:
5.4W
Papers: 4.5W
Citations: 70
U
utrecht university medical center
Scholars:
443
Papers: 250
Citations: 0
U
University of Nizwa
Scholars:
1.4K
Papers: 1.2K
Citations: 1.5K
researcher View more organizations