arrow
Return

Proximal indirect comparison

delete2026-01-01
delete0
PRE
AI
Z
Zehao Su *
H
Helene C. W. Rytgaard
H
Henrik Ravn
F
Frank Eriksson
DOI:10.1093/biomet/asaf044delete
deleteOriginal
deleteOriginal request for help
deleteShare
deleteSave
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
We consider the problem of indirect comparison, where a treatment arm of interest is absent by design in one randomized controlled trial, but available in the other. The former is the target trial, and the latter is the source trial. The identifiability of the target population average treatment effect often relies on conditional transportability assumptions. However, it is a common concern whether all relevant effect modifiers are measured and controlled for. We give a new proximal identification result in the presence of shifted, unobserved effect modifiers based on proxies: an adjustment proxy in both trials and an additional reweighting proxy in the source trial. We propose an estimator that is doubly robust against misspecifications of the so-called bridge functions and asymptotically normal under mild consistency of estimators for the bridge functions. We use two weight management trials as a context to illustrate selection of proxies and apply our method to compare the weight loss effect of active treatments from these trials.
Keywords:
Indirect comparison
Meta-analysis
Proximal causal inference
Transportability

Journal

B
Biometrika
IF:
2.8
Papers:
34
Citations:
0

Organization

N
Novo Nordisk
Scholars:
4.3K
Papers: 2.7K
Citations: 31
U
university of copenhagen
Scholars:
7.8K
Papers: 3.1K
Citations: 0
Cited Papers

Cited Papers

A calibration approach to transportability and data‐fusion with observational data
err2022-07-18
err0
errOAAI
errKevin P. Josey; Fan Yang; Debashis Ghosh; Sridharan Raghavan
errShare
errSave
Multilevel Network Meta-Regression for Population-Adjusted Treatment Comparisons
err2020-06-07
err0
errOAAI
errDavid M. Phillippo; Sofia Dias; A. E. Ades; Mark Belger; Alan Brnabic; Alexander Schacht; Daniel Saure; Zbigniew Kadziola; Nicky J. Welton
errShare
errSave
Efficacy of Liraglutide for Weight Loss Among Patients With Type 2 Diabetes The SCALE Diabetes Randomized Clinical Trial
err2015-08-18
err718
PREAI
errDavies, Melanie J.; Bergenstal, Richard; Bode, Bruce; Kushner, Robert F.; Lewin, Andrew; Skjoth, Trine Vang; Andreasen, Arne Haahr; Jensen, Christine Bjorn; DeFronzo, Ralph A.
errShare
errSave
Causal Inference Methods for Combining Randomized Trials and Observational Studies: A Review
err2024-02-01
err20
errOAAI
errColnet, Benedicte; Mayer, Imke; Chen, Guanhua; Dieng, Awa; Li, Ruohong; Varoquaux, Gael; Vert, Jean -Philippe; Josse, Julie; Yang, Shu
errShare
errSave
Transporting experimental results with entropy balancing
err2021-05-20
err0
errOAAI
errKevin P. Josey; Seth A. Berkowitz; Debashis Ghosh; Sridharan Raghavan
errShare
errSave
errShare
errSave
Causal inference with hidden mediators
err2024-07-15
err0
errOAAI
errAmiremad Ghassami; Alan Yang; Ilya Shpitser; Eric Tchetgen Tchetgen
errShare
errSave
Impact of social determinants of health on outcomes for type 2 diabetes: a systematic review
err2014-02-15
err217
errOAAI
errWalker, Rebekah J.; Smalls, Brittany L.; Campbell, Jennifer A.; Williams, Joni L. Strom; Egede, Leonard E.
errShare
errSave
Global Variation in the Prevalence of Elevated Cholesterol in Outpatients With Established Vascular Disease or 3 Cardiovascular Risk Factors According to National Indices of Economic Development and Health System Performance
err2012-04-17
err32
errOAAI
errVenkitachalam, Lakshmi; Wang, Kaijun; Porath, Avi; Corbalan, Ramon; Hirsch, Alan T.; Cohen, David J.; Smith, Sidney C., Jr.; Ohman, E. Magnus; Steg, Ph Gabriel; Bhatt, Deepak L.; Magnuson, Elizabeth A.
errShare
errSave
researcher View more