arrow
Return

Simplifying Random Forests' Probabilistic Forecasts

delete2025-10-01
delete1
delete
OA
AI
F
Fabian Krüger *
DOI:10.1080/00031305.2025.2552284delete
deleteOriginal
deleteShare
deleteSave
View PDF
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
Since their introduction by Breiman, Random Forests (RFs) have proven to be useful for both classification and regression tasks. The RF prediction of a previously unseen observation can be represented as a weighted sum of all training sample observations. This nearest-neighbor-type representation is useful, among other things, for constructing forecast distributions (as in Meinshausen's Quantile Regression Forests). In this article, we consider simplifying RF-based forecast distributions by sparsifying them. That is, we focus on a small subset of k nearest neighbors while setting the remaining weights to zero. This simplification, which we refer to as Topk, greatly improves the interpretability of RF predictions. It can be applied to any forecasting task without re-training existing RF models. In empirical experiments, we document that the simplified predictions can be similar to or exceed the original ones in terms of forecasting performance. We explore the statistical sources of this finding via a stylized analytical model of RFs. The model suggests that simplification is particularly promising if the unknown true forecast distribution contains many small weights that are estimated imprecisely.
Keywords:
Forecast distribution
Random forests
Simplicity
AI Summary

AI Summary

Key information extracted from the uploaded paper, including a brief overview, abstract, background, key highlights, visual analysis, and future outlook.

Journal

A
AMERICAN STATISTICIAN
IF:
2.1
Papers:
61
Citations:
0

Organization

H
Helmholtz Association
Scholars:
13.2W
Papers: 10.7W
Citations: 145
Cited Papers

Cited Papers

The Energy of Data
err2017-03-07
err81
PREAI
errSzekely, Gabor J.; Rizzo, Maria L.
errShare
errSave
A random forest guided tour
errTEST
IF0
err2016-04-19
err0
errOAAI
errGérard Biau; Erwan Scornet
errShare
errSave
err
IF0
err
err0
PREAI
err
errShare
errSave
errShare
errSave
Probabilistic Forecasting
err2014-01-03
err621
PREAI
errGneiting, Tilmann; Katzfuss, Matthias
errShare
errSave
Scoring rules and the evaluation of probabilities
errTest
IF0
err1996-06-01
err0
PREAI
errR. L. Winkler; Javier Muñoz; José L. Cervera; José M. Bernardo; Gail Blattenberger; Joseph B. Kadane; Dennis V. Lindley; Allan H. Murphy; Robert M Oliver; David Ríos-Insua
errShare
errSave
Evaluation of individual and ensemble probabilistic forecasts of COVID-19 mortality in the United States
err2022-04-08
err131
errOAAI
errCramer, Estee Y.; Ray, Evan L.; Lopez, Velma K.; Bracher, Johannes; Brennen, Andrea; Rivadeneira, Alvaro J. Castro; Gerding, Aaron; Gneiting, Tilmann; House, Katie H.; Huang, Yuxin; Jayawardena, Dasuni; Kanji, Abdul H.; Khandelwal, Ayush; Le, Khoa; Muhlemann, Anja; Niemi, Jarad; Shah, Apurv; Stark, Ariane; Wang, Yijin; Wattanachit, Nutcha; Zorn, Martha W.; Gu, Youyang; Jain, Sansiddh; Bannur, Nayana; Deva, Ayush; Kulkarni, Mihir; Merugu, Srujana; Raval, Alpan; Shingi, Siddhant; Tiwari, Avtansh; White, Jerome; Abernethy, Neil F.; Woody, Spencer; Dahan, Maytal; Fox, Spencer; Gaither, Kelly; Lachmann, Michael; Meyers, Lauren Ancel; Scott, James G.; Tec, Mauricio; Srivastava, Ajitesh; George, Glover E.; Cegan, Jeffrey C.; Dettwiller, Ian D.; England, William P.; Farthing, Matthew W.; Hunter, Robert H.; Lafferty, Brandon; Linkov, Igor; Mayo, Michael L.; Parno, Matthew D.; Rowland, Michael A.; Trump, Benjamin D.; Zhang-James, Yanli; Chen, Samuel; Faraone, Stephen, V; Hess, Jonathan; Morley, Christopher P.; Salekin, Asif; Wang, Dongliang; Corsetti, Sabrina M.; Baer, Thomas M.; Eisenberg, Marisa C.; Falb, Karl; Huang, Yitao; Martin, Emily T.; McCauley, Ella; Myers, Robert L.; Schwarz, Tom; Sheldon, Daniel; Gibson, Graham Casey; Yu, Rose; Gao, Liyao; Ma, Yian; Wu, Dongxia; Yan, Xifeng; Jin, Xiaoyong; Wang, Yu-Xiang; Chen, YangQuan; Guo, Lihong; Zhao, Yanting; Gu, Quanquan; Chen, Jinghui; Wang, Lingxiao; Xu, Pan; Zhang, Weitong; Zou, Difan; Biegel, Hannah; Lega, Joceline; McConnell, Steve; Nagraj, V. P.; Guertin, Stephanie L.; Hulme-Lowe, Christopher; Turner, Stephen D.; Shi, Yunfeng; Ban, Xuegang; Walraven, Robert; Hong, Qi-Jun; Kong, Stanley; van de Walle, Axel; Turtle, James A.; Ben-Nun, Michal; Riley, Steven; Riley, Pete; Koyluoglu, Ugur; DesRoches, David; Forli, Pedro; Hamory, Bruce; Kyriakides, Christina; Leis, Helen; Milliken, John; Moloney, Michael; Morgan, James; Nirgudkar, Ninad; Ozcan, Gokce; Piwonka, Noah; Ravi, Matt; Schrader, Chris; Shakhnovich, Elizabeth; Siegel, Daniel; Spatz, Ryan; Stiefeling, Chris; Wilkinson, Barrie; Wong, Alexander; Cavany, Sean; Espana, Guido; Moore, Sean; Oidtman, Rachel; Perkins, Alex; Kraus, David; Kraus, Andrea; Gao, Zhifeng; Bian, Jiang; Cao, Wei; Ferres, Juan Lavista; Li, Chaozhuo; Liu, Tie-Yan; Xie, Xing; Zhang, Shun; Zheng, Shun; Vespignani, Alessandro; Chinazzi, Matteo; Davis, Jessica T.; Mu, Kunpeng; Piontti, Ana Pastore Y.; Xiong, Xinyue; Zheng, Andrew; Baek, Jackie; Farias, Vivek; Georgescu, Andreea; Levi, Retsef; Sinha, Deeksha; Wilde, Joshua; Perakis, Georgia; Bennouna, Mohammed Amine; Nze-Ndong, David; Singhvi, Divya; Spantidakis, Ioannis; Thayaparan, Leann; Tsiourvas, Asterios; Sarker, Arnab; Jadbabaie, Ali; Shah, Devavrat; Della Penna, Nicolas; Celi, Leo A.; Sundar, Saketh; Wolfinger, Russ; Osthus, Dave; Castro, Lauren; Fairchild, Geoffrey; Michaud, Isaac; Karlen, Dean; Kinsey, Matt; Mullany, Luke C.; Rainwater-Lovett, Kaitlin; Shin, Lauren; Tallaksen, Katharine; Wilson, Shelby; Lee, Elizabeth C.; Dent, Juan; Grantz, Kyra H.; Hill, Alison L.; Kaminsky, Joshua; Kaminsky, Kathryn; Keegan, Lindsay T.; Lauer, Stephen A.; Lemaitre, Joseph C.; Lessler, Justin; Meredith, Hannah R.; Perez-Saez, Javier; Shah, Sam; Smith, Claire P.; Truelove, Shaun A.; Wills, Josh; Marshall, Maximilian; Gardner, Lauren; Nixon, Kristen; Burant, John C.; Wang, Lily; Gao, Lei; Gu, Zhiling; Kim, Myungjin; Li, Xinyi; Wang, Guannan; Wang, Yueying; Yu, Shan; Reiner, Robert C.; Barber, Ryan; Gakidou, Emmanuela; Hay, Simon, I; Lim, Steve; Murray, Chris; Pigott, David; Gurung, Heidi L.; Baccam, Prasith; Stage, Steven A.; Suchoski, Bradley T.; Prakash, B. Aditya; Adhikari, Bijaya; Cui, Jiaming; Rodriguez, Alexander; Tabassum, Anika; Xie, Jiajia; Keskinocak, Pinar; Asplund, John; Baxter, Arden; Oruc, Buse Eylul; Serban, Nicoleta; Arik, Sercan O.; Dusenberry, Mike; Epshteyn, Arkady; Kanal, Elli; Le, Long T.; Li, Chun-Liang; Pfister, Tomas; Sava, Dario; Sinha, Rajarishi; Tsai, Thomas; Yoder, Nate; Yoon, Jinsung; Zhang, Leyou; Abbott, Sam; Bosse, Nikos, I; Funk, Sebastian; Hellewell, Joel; Meakin, Sophie R.; Sherratt, Katharine; Zhou, Mingyuan; Kalantari, Rahi; Yamana, Teresa K.; Pei, Sen; Shaman, Jeffrey; Li, Michael L.; Bertsimas, Dimitris; Lami, Omar Skali; Soni, Saksham; Bouardi, Hamza Tazi; Ayer, Turgay; Adee, Madeline; Chhatwal, Jagpreet; Dalgic, Ozden O.; Ladd, Mary A.; Linas, Benjamin P.; Mueller, Peter; Xiao, Jade; Wang, Yuanjia; Wang, Qinxia; Xie, Shanghong; Zeng, Donglin; Green, Alden; Bien, Jacob; Brooks, Logan; Hu, Addison J.; Jahja, Maria; McDonald, Daniel; Narasimhan, Balasubramanian; Politsch, Collin; Rajanala, Samyak; Rumack, Aaron; Simon, Noah; Tibshirani, Ryan J.; Tibshirani, Rob; Ventura, Valerie; Wasserman, Larry; O'Dea, Eamon B.; Drake, John M.; Pagano, Robert; Tran, Quoc T.; Ho, Lam Si Tung; Huong Huynh; Walker, Jo W.; Slayton, Rachel B.; Johansson, Michael A.; Biggerstaff, Matthew; Reich, Nicholas G.
errShare
errSave
Scoring Rules for Continuous Probability Distributions
err1976-06-01
err0
PREAI
errJames E. Matheson; Robert L. Winkler
errShare
errSave
researcher View more