arrow
Return

STRmix™ collaborative exercise on DNA mixture interpretation

delete2019-05-01
delete32
PRE
AI
J
Jo‐Anne Bright *
K
Kevin Cheng
Z
Zane Kerr
C
Catherine McGovern
H
Hannah Kelly
T
Tamyra R. Moretti
M
Michael A. Smith
F
Frederick R. Bieber
B
Bruce Budowle
M
Michael D. Coble
R
Rashed Alghafri
P
Paul Stafford Allen
B
Barbee, Amy
V
Vickie Beamer
C
Christina Buettner
M
Melanie Russell
C
Christian Gehrig
T
Tacha Hicks
J
Jessica Charak
K
Kate Cheong-Wing
A
Anne Ciecko
C
Christie T. Davis
M
Michael Donley
N
Natalie Pedersen
B
Bill Gartside
D
Dominic Granger
M
MaryMargaret Greer-Ritzheimer
E
Erick Reisinger
J
Jarrah Kennedy
E
Erin Grammer
M
Marla Kaplan
D
David Hansen
H
Hans Jakob Larsen
A
Alanna Laureano
C
Christina Li
E
Eugene Lien
E
Emilia Lindberg
C
Ciara Marie Kelly
B
Ben Mallinder
S
Simon Malsom
A
Alyse Yacovone-Margetts
A
Andrew J. McWhorter
S
Sapana M. Prajapati
T
Tamar Powell
G
Gary Shutler
K
Kate Stevenson
A
April R. Stonehouse
L
L. Glenn Smith
J
Julie Murakami
E
Eric Halsing
D
Darren Wright
L
Leigh Clark
D
Duncan Taylor
J
John Buckleton
DOI:10.1016/j.fsigen.2019.01.006delete
deleteOriginal
deleteOriginal request for help
deleteShare
deleteSave
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
An intra and inter-laboratory study using the probabilistic genotyping (PG) software STRmix (TM) is reported. Two complex mixtures from the PROVEDIt set, analysed on an Applied Biosystems (TM) 3500 Series Genetic Analyzer, were selected. 174 participants responded. For Sample 1 (low template, in the order of 200 rfu for major contributors) five participants described the comparison as inconclusive with respect to the POI or excluded him. Where LRs were assigned, the point estimates ranging from 2 x 10(4) to 8 x 10(6). For Sample 2 (in the order of 2000 rfu for major contributors), LRs ranged from 2 x 10(28) to 2 x 10(29). Where LRs were calculated, the differences between participants can be attributed to (from largest to smallest impact): varying number of contributors (NoC), the exclusion of some loci within the interpretation, differences in local CE data analysis methods leading to variation in the peaks present and their heights in the input files used, and run-to-run variation due to the random sampling inherent to all MCMC-based methods. This study demonstrates a high level of repeatability and reproducibility among the participants. For those results that differed from the mode, the differences in LR were almost always minor or conservative.
Keywords:
Forensic DNA interpretation
Probabilistic genotyping
STRmix
Inter-laboratory study
Intra-laboratory study
AI Summary

AI Summary

Key information extracted from the uploaded paper, including a brief overview, abstract, background, key highlights, visual analysis, and future outlook.

Journal

Forensic Science International-Genetics cover
Forensic Science International-Genetics
IF:
3.1
Papers:
2.8K
Citations:
5.8K

Organization

U
University of Copenhagen
Scholars:
7.6W
Papers: 6.6W
Citations: 86
U
University of North Texas Health Science Center
Scholars:
940
Papers: 660
Citations: 2.3K
H
Harvard University
Scholars:
26.5W
Papers: 22.0W
Citations: 28.7W
F
forensic science sa
Scholars:
52
Papers: 55
Citations: 0
H
harvard university medical affiliates
Scholars:
5.8W
Papers: 4.5W
Citations: 36
U
University of Lausanne
Scholars:
2.5W
Papers: 2.0W
Citations: 3.0W
U
University of Auckland
Scholars:
2.3W
Papers: 2.4W
Citations: 3.3W
U
university of north texas denton
Scholars:
4.4K
Papers: 3.9K
Citations: 10
F
Flinders University South Australia
Scholars:
8.9K
Papers: 1.0W
Citations: 84
H
Harvard Medical School
Scholars:
6.5W
Papers: 4.8W
Citations: 91
U
University of North Texas System
Scholars:
8.1K
Papers: 7.7K
Citations: 178
researcher View more organizations
Cited Papers

Cited Papers

Investigating a common approach to DNA profile interpretation using probabilistic software
err2015-05-01
err26
PREAI
errCooper, Stuart; McGovern, Catherine; Bright, Jo-Anne; Taylor, Duncan; Buckleton, John
errShare
errSave
A series of recommended tests when validating probabilistic DNA profile interpretation software
err2015-01-01
err37
PREAI
errBright, Jo-Anne; Evett, Ian W.; Taylor, Duncan; Curran, James M.; Buckleton, John
errShare
errSave
Euroforgen-NoE collaborative exercise on LRmix to demonstrate standardization of the interpretation of complex DNA profiles
err2014-03-01
err46
errOAAI
errPrieto, L.; Haned, H.; Mosquera, A.; Crespillo, M.; Aleman, M.; Aler, M.; Alvarez, F.; Baeza-Richer, C.; Dominguez, A.; Doutremepuich, C.; Farfan, M. J.; Fenger-Gron, M.; Garcia-Ganivetm, J. M.; Gonzalez-Moya, E.; Hombreiro, L.; Lareu, M. V.; Martinez-Jarreta, B.; Merigioli, S.; Milans del Bosch, P.; Morling, N.; Munoz-Nieto, M.; Ortega-Gonzalez, E.; Pedrosa, S.; Perez, R.; Solis, C.; Yurrebaso, I.; Gill, P.
errShare
errSave
The variability in likelihood ratios due to different mechanisms
err2015-01-01
err25
errOAAI
errBright, Jo-Anne; Stevenson, Kate E.; Curran, James M.; Buckleton, John S.
errShare
errSave
Internal validation of STRmix™ for the interpretation of single source and mixed DNA profiles
err2017-07-01
err71
errOAAI
errMoretti, Tamyra R.; Just, Rebecca S.; Kehl, Susannah C.; Willis, Leah E.; Buckleton, John S.; Bright, Jo-Anne; Taylor, Duncan A.; Onorato, Anthony J.
errShare
errSave
GHEP-ISFG collaborative exercise on mixture profiles (GHEP-MIX06). Reporting conclusions: Results and evaluation
err2018-07-01
err19
PREAI
errBarrio, P. A.; Crespillo, M.; Luque, J. A.; Aler, M.; Baeza-Richer, C.; Baldassarri, L.; Carnevali, E.; Coufalova, P.; Flores, I; Garcia, O.; Garcia, M. A.; Gonzalez, R.; Hernandez, A.; Ingles, V; Luque, G. M.; Mosquera-Miguel, A.; Pedrosa, S.; Pontes, M. L.; Porto, M. J.; Posada, Y.; Ramella, M., I; Ribeiro, T.; Riego, E.; Sala, A.; Saragoni, V. G.; Serrano, A.; Vannelli, S.
errShare
errSave
Population data on the expanded CODIS core STR loci for eleven populations of significance for forensic DNA analyses in the United States
err2016-11-01
err71
errOAAI
errMoretti, Tamyra R.; Moreno, Lilliana I.; Smerick, Jill B.; Pignone, Michelle L.; Hizon, Rosana; Buckleton, John S.; Bright, Jo-Anne; Onorato, Anthony J.
errShare
errSave
Developmental validation of STRmix™, expert software for the interpretation of forensic DNA profiles
err2016-07-01
err118
PREAI
errBright, Jo-Anne; Taylor, Duncan; McGovern, Catherine; Cooper, Stuart; Russell, Laura; Abarno, Damien; Buckleton, John
errShare
errSave
researcher View more