arrow
Return

Testing maximum entropy models with e-values

delete2026-05-01
delete1
PRE
AI
F
Francesca Giuffrida *
D
Diego Garlaschelli
P
Peter Grünwald
DOI:10.1103/xhf5-1l7pdelete
deleteOriginal
deleteOriginal request for help
deleteShare
deleteSave
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
E-values have recently emerged as a robust and flexible alternative to p-values for hypothesis testing, especially under optional continuation, i.e., when additional data from further experiments are collected. In this work we define optimal e-values for testing between maximum entropy models, in both the microcanonical (hard constraints) and canonical (soft constraints) settings. We show that, when testing between two hypotheses that are both microcanonical, the so-called growth-rate optimal e-variable admits an exact analytical expression, which also serves as a valid e-variable in the canonical case. For canonical tests, where exact solutions are typically unavailable, we introduce a microcanonical approximation and verify its excellent performance via both theoretical arguments and numerical simulations. We then consider constrained binary models, focusing on 2 & times; k contingency tables-an essential framework in statistics and a natural representation for various models of complex systems. Our microcanonical optimal e-variable performs well in both settings, constituting a tool that remains effective even in the challenging case when the number k of groups grows with the sample size, as in models with growing features used for the analysis of real-world heterogeneous networks and time series.
Keywords:
EXPONENTIAL FAMILY

Journal

Physical Review E cover
Physical Review E
IF:
2.4
Papers:
1.4K
Citations:
10.2W

Organization

L
leiden university - excl lumc
Scholars:
3.5W
Papers: 2.9W
Citations: 46
I
IMT School for Advanced Studies Lucca
Scholars:
676
Papers: 701
Citations: 693
Cited Papers

Cited Papers

Many Labs 2: Investigating Variation in Replicability Across Samples and Settings
err2018-12-24
err552
errOAAI
errKlein, Richard A.; Vianello, Michelangelo; Hasselman, Fred; Adams, Byron G.; Adams, Reginald B., Jr.; Alper, Sinan; Aveyard, Mark; Axt, Jordan R.; Babalola, Mayowa T.; Bahnik, Stepan; Batra, Rishtee; Berkics, Mihaly; Bernstein, Michael J.; Berry, Daniel R.; Bialobrzeska, Olga; Binan, Evans Dami; Bocian, Konrad; Brandt, Mark J.; Busching, Robert; Redei, Anna Cabak; Cai, Huajian; Cambier, Fanny; Cantarero, Katarzyna; Carmichael, Cheryl L.; Ceric, Francisco; Chandler, Jesse; Chang, Jen-Ho; Chatard, Armand; Chen, Eva E.; Cheong, Winnee; Cicero, David C.; Coen, Sharon; Coleman, Jennifer A.; Collisson, Brian; Conway, Morgan A.; Corker, Katherine S.; Curran, Paul G.; Cushman, Fiery; Dagona, Zubairu K.; Dalgar, Ilker; Dalla Rosa, Anna; Davis, William E.; de Bruijn, Maaike; De Schutter, Leander; Devos, Thierry; de Vries, Marieke; Dogulu, Canay; Dozo, Nerisa; Dukes, Kristin Nicole; Dunham, Yarrow; Durrheim, Kevin; Ebersole, Charles R.; Edlund, John E.; Eller, Anja; English, Alexander Scott; Finck, Carolyn; Frankowska, Natalia; Freyre, Miguel-Angel; Friedman, Mike; Galliani, Elisa Maria; Gandi, Joshua C.; Ghoshal, Tanuka; Giessner, Steffen R.; Gill, Tripat; Gnambs, Timo; Gomez, Angel; Gonzalez, Roberto; Graham, Jesse; Grahe, Jon E.; Grahek, Ivan; Green, Eva G. T.; Hai, Kakul; Haigh, Matthew; Haines, Elizabeth L.; Hall, Michael P.; Heffernan, Marie E.; Hicks, Joshua A.; Houdek, Petr; Huntsinger, Jeffrey R.; Ho Phi Huynh; IJzerman, Hans; Inbar, Yoel; Innes-Ker, Ase H.; Jimenez-Leal, William; John, Melissa-Sue; Joy-Gaba, Jennifer A.; Kamiloglu, Roza G.; Kappes, Heather Barry; Karabati, Serdar; Karick, Haruna; Keller, Victor N.; Kende, Anna; Kervyn, Nicolas; Knezevic, Goran; Kovacs, Carrie; Krueger, Lacy E.; Kurapov, German; Kurtz, Jamie; Lakens, Daniel; Lazarevic, Ljiljana B.; Levitan, Carmel A.; Lewis, Neil A., Jr.; Lins, Samuel; Lipsey, Nikolette P.; Losee, Joy E.; Maassen, Esther; Maitner, Angela T.; Malingumu, Winfrida; Mallett, Robyn K.; Marotta, Satia A.; Mededovic, Janko; Mena-Pacheco, Fernando; Milfont, Taciano L.; Morris, Wendy L.; Murphy, Sean C.; Myachykov, Andriy; Neave, Nick; Neijenhuijs, Koen; Nelson, Anthony J.; Neto, Felix; Nichols, Austin Lee; Ocampo, Aaron; O'Donnell, Susan L.; Oikawa, Haruka; Oikawa, Masanori; Ong, Elsie; Orosz, Gabor; Osowiecka, Malgorzata; Packard, Grant; Perez-Sanchez, Rolando; Pilati, Ronaldo; Pinter, Brad; Podesta, Lysandra; Pogge, Gabrielle; Pollmann, Monique M. H.; Rutchick, Abraham M.; Saavedra, Patricio; Saeri, Alexander K.; Salomon, Erika; Schmidt, Kathleen; Schonbrodt, Felix D.; Sekerdej, Maciej B.; Sirlopu, David; Skorinko, Jeanine L. M.; Smith, Michael A.; Smith-Castro, Vanessa; Smolders, Karin C. H. J.; Sobkow, Agata; Sowden, Walter; Spachtholz, Philipp; Srivastava, Manini; Steiner, Troy G.; Stouten, Jeroen; Street, Chris N. H.; Sundfelt, Oskar K.; Szeto, Stephanie; Szumowska, Ewa; Tang, Andrew C. W.; Tanzer, Norbert; Tear, Morgan J.; Theriault, Jordan; Thomae, Manuela; Torres, David; Traczyk, Jakub; Tybur, Joshua M.; Ujhelyi, Adrienn; van Aert, Robbie C. M.; van Assen, Marcel A. L. M.; van der Hulst, Marije; van Lange, Paul A. M.; van 't Veer, Anna Elisabeth; Vasquez-Echeverria, Alejandro; Vaughn, Leigh Ann; Vazquez, Alexandra; Diego Vega, Luis; Verniers, Catherine; Verschoor, Mark; Voermans, Ingrid P. J.; Vranka, Marek A.; Welch, Cheryl; Wichman, Aaron L.; Williams, Lisa A.; Wood, Michael; Woodzicka, Julie A.; Wronska, Marta K.; Young, Liane; Zelenski, John M.; Zeng Zhijia; Nosek, Brian A.
errShare
errSave
Breaking of Ensemble Equivalence in Networks
err2015-12-30
err0
errOAAI
errTiziano Squartini; Joey de Mol; Frank den Hollander; Diego Garlaschelli
errShare
errSave
errShare
errSave
Redefine statistical significance
err2017-09-01
err0
errOAAI
errDaniel J. Benjamin; James O. Berger; Magnus Johannesson; Brian A. Nosek; E.-J. Wagenmakers; Richard Berk; Kenneth A. Bollen; Björn Brembs; Lawrence Brown; Colin Camerer; David Cesarini; Christopher D. Chambers; Merlise Clyde; Thomas D. Cook; Paul De Boeck; Zoltan Dienes; Anna Dreber; Kenny Easwaran; Charles Efferson; Ernst Fehr; Fiona Fidler; Andy P. Field; Malcolm Forster; Edward I. George; Richard Gonzalez; Steven Goodman; Edwin Green; Donald P. Green; Anthony G. Greenwald; Jarrod D. Hadfield; Larry V. Hedges; Leonhard Held; Teck Hua Ho; Herbert Hoijtink; Daniel J. Hruschka; Kosuke Imai; Guido Imbens; John P. A. Ioannidis; Minjeong Jeon; James Holland Jones; Michael Kirchler; David Laibson; John List; Roderick Little; Arthur Lupia; Edouard Machery; Scott E. Maxwell; Michael McCarthy; Don A. Moore; Stephen L. Morgan; Marcus Munafó; Shinichi Nakagawa; Brendan Nyhan; Timothy H. Parker; Luis Pericchi; Marco Perugini; Jeff Rouder; Judith Rousseau; Victoria Savalei; Felix D. Schönbrodt; Thomas Sellke; Betsy Sinclair; Dustin Tingley; Trisha Van Zandt; Simine Vazire; Duncan J. Watts; Christopher Winship; Robert L. Wolpert; Yu Xie; Cristobal Young; Jonathan Zinman; Valen E. Johnson
errShare
errSave
Selecting food web models using normalized maximum likelihood
err2014-05-10
err11
errOAAI
errStaniczenko, Phillip P. A.; Smith, Matthew J.; Allesina, Stefano
errShare
errSave
Maximum entropy approach to multivariate time series randomization
err2020-06-30
err1
errOAAI
errMarcaccioli, Riccardo; Livan, Giacomo
errShare
errSave
Description length of canonical and microcanonical models
err
err0
PREAI
errGiuffrida,Francesca; Squartini,Tiziano; Grünwald,Peter; Garlaschelli,Diego
errShare
errSave
A Tutorial on Safe Anytime-Valid Inference: Practical Maximally Flexible Sampling Designs for Experiments Based on e-Values
err
IF0
err
err0
PREAI
errLy,Alexander; Boehm,Udo; Grünwald,Peter; Ramdas,Aaditya; van Ravenzwaaij,Don
errShare
errSave
Abandon Statistical Significance
err2019-03-20
err0
errOAAI
errBlakeley B. McShane; David Gal; Andrew Gelman; Christian Robert; Jennifer L. Tackett
errShare
errSave
researcher View more