arrow
Return

When to replicate systematic reviews of interventions: consensus checklist

delete2020-09-15
delete50
delete
OA
AI
P
Peter Tugwell *
V
Vivian Welch
S
Sathya Karunananthan
L
Lara Maxwell
E
Elie A. Akl
M
Marc T. Avey
Z
Zulfiqar A Bhutta
M
Melissa Brouwers
J
Jocalyn Clark
S
Sophie Cook
L
Luis Gabriel Cuervo
J
Janet Curran
E
Elizabeth Tanjong Ghogomu
G
Graham, Ian G.
J
Jeremy Grimshaw
B
Brian Hutton
J
John P. A. Ioannidis
Z
Zoe Jordan
J
Janet Jull
E
Elizabeth Kristjansson
É
Étienne V Langlois
J
Julian Little
A
Anne Lyddiatt
J
Janet Martin
A
Ana Marušić
L
Lawrence Mbuagbaw
D
David Moher
R
Rachael L. Morton
M
Mona Nasser
M
Matthew J. Page
J
Jordi Pardo Pardo
J
Jennifer Petkovic
M
Mark Petticrew
T
Terri Pigott
K
Kevin Pottie
G
Gabriel Rada
T
Tamara Rader
A
Alison Riddle
H
Hannah R. Rothstein
H
Holger J Schüneman
L
Larissa Shamseer
B
Beverley Shea
R
Rosiane Simeon
K
Konstantinos C. Siontis
M
Maureen Smith
K
Karla Soares‐Weiser
K
Kednapa Thavorn
D
David Tovey
B
Brigitte Vachon
V
Valentine, Jeffery
R
Rebecca Villemaire
P
Peter Walker
L
Laura Weeks
G
George A. Wells
D
David B. Wilson
H
Howard White
DOI:10.1136/bmj.m2864delete
deleteOriginal
deleteShare
deleteSave
View PDF
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
Replication is an essential part of the scientific method, yet replication of systematic reviews is too often overlooked, and done unnecessarily or poorly. Excessive replication (doing the same study repeatedly) is unethical and a cause of research wastage. This article provides consensus based guidance on when to replicate and not replicate systematic reviews.
Keywords:
MASS-PRODUCTION
HEALTH
AI Summary

AI Summary

Key information extracted from the uploaded paper, including a brief overview, abstract, background, key highlights, visual analysis, and future outlook.

Journal

B
BMJ and British Medical Journal
IF:
42.7
Papers:
4.8W
Citations:
17.4W

Organization

Q
queens university - canada
Scholars:
1.7W
Papers: 1.6W
Citations: 29
M
Monash University
Scholars:
5.4W
Papers: 5.4W
Citations: 79
W
western university (university of western ontario)
Scholars:
2.9W
Papers: 2.7W
Citations: 33
U
University of Adelaide
Scholars:
2.3W
Papers: 2.4W
Citations: 4.2W
W
world health organization
Scholars:
2.0W
Papers: 1.4W
Citations: 20
O
Ottawa Hospital Research Institute
Scholars:
6.5K
Papers: 5.2K
Citations: 1.3W
B
baruch college (cuny)
Scholars:
628
Papers: 639
Citations: 0
P
Pan American Health Organization
Scholars:
1.3K
Papers: 806
Citations: 1
U
University of Split
Scholars:
4.4K
Papers: 4.0K
Citations: 3.7K
U
university system of georgia
Scholars:
7.2W
Papers: 6.5W
Citations: 101
H
hospital for sick children (sickkids)
Scholars:
1.1W
Papers: 8.1K
Citations: 16
U
universite de montreal
Scholars:
4.6W
Papers: 3.8W
Citations: 46
U
University of Sydney
Scholars:
6.5W
Papers: 6.2W
Citations: 90
S
Stanford University
Scholars:
9.6W
Papers: 8.2W
Citations: 17.0W
U
University of Plymouth
Scholars:
7.0K
Papers: 6.7K
Citations: 9.3K
M
mayo clinic
Scholars:
8.1W
Papers: 6.5W
Citations: 85
U
University of Louisville
Scholars:
1.3W
Papers: 1.0W
Citations: 1.3W
P
Public Health Agency of Canada
Scholars:
2.8K
Papers: 2.0K
Citations: 2.2K
L
London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine
Scholars:
1.7W
Papers: 1.3W
Citations: 28
D
Dalhousie University
Scholars:
1.9W
Papers: 1.8W
Citations: 2.3W
U
university of london
Scholars:
21.3W
Papers: 19.6W
Citations: 305
A
American University of Beirut
Scholars:
8.3K
Papers: 6.0K
Citations: 1.1W
G
Georgia State University
Scholars:
5.4K
Papers: 4.4K
Citations: 9.6K
C
city university of new york (cuny) system
Scholars:
1.6W
Papers: 1.5W
Citations: 26
M
McMaster University
Scholars:
3.6W
Papers: 3.3W
Citations: 4.4W
U
University of Ottawa
Scholars:
3.5W
Papers: 3.1W
Citations: 3.8W
U
university of toronto
Scholars:
14.5W
Papers: 11.9W
Citations: 165
researcher View more organizations