arrow
Return

A comprehensive comparison on clustering methods for multi-slice spatially resolved transcriptomics data analysis

delete2025-09-01
delete0
PRE
AI
C
Caiwei Xiong
S
Shuai Huang
M
Muqing Zhou
Y
Yiyan Zhang
W
Wenrong Wu
X
Xihao Li
H
Huaxiu Yao
J
Jiawen Chen
李
李越 (Yun Li) *
DOI:10.1093/bib/bbaf471delete
deleteOriginal
deleteOriginal request for help
deleteShare
deleteSave
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
Spatial transcriptomics (ST) data, by providing spatial information, enable simultaneous analysis of gene expression distributions and their spatial patterns within tissue. Clustering or spatial domain detection represents an essential methodology for ST data, facilitating the exploration of spatial organizations with shared gene expression or histological characteristics. Traditionally, clustering algorithms for ST have focused on individual tissue sections. However, the emergence of numerous contiguous tissue sections derived from the same or similar tissue specimens within or across individuals has led to the development of multi-slice clustering methods. In this study, we assess seven single-slice and four multi-slice clustering methods on two simulated datasets and four real datasets. Additionally, we investigate the effectiveness of preprocessing techniques, including spatial coordinate alignment (e.g. PASTE) and gene expression batch effect removal (e.g. Harmony), on clustering performance. Our study provides a comprehensive comparison of clustering methods for multi-slice ST data, serving as a practical guide for method selection in various scenarios.
Keywords:
spatial transcriptomics
clustering
multi-slice clustering
evaluation

Journal

Briefings in Bioinformatics cover
Briefings in Bioinformatics
IF:
7.7
Papers:
5.8K
Citations:
2.7W

Organization

U
university of north carolina
Scholars:
7.4W
Papers: 6.5W
Citations: 93
U
University of North Carolina School of Medicine
Scholars:
1.6W
Papers: 1.1W
Citations: 20
U
University of North Carolina Chapel Hill
Scholars:
3.9W
Papers: 3.1W
Citations: 46
researcher View more organizations
Cited Papers

Cited Papers

Transcriptome-scale spatial gene expression in the human dorsolateral prefrontal cortex
err2021-02-08
err0
errOAAI
errKristen R. Maynard; Leonardo Collado-Torres; Lukas M. Weber; Cedric Uytingco; Brianna K. Barry; Stephen R. Williams; Joseph L. Catallini; Matthew N. Tran; Zachary Besich; Madhavi Tippani; Jennifer Chew; Yifeng Yin; Joel E. Kleinman; Thomas M. Hyde; Nikhil Rao; Stephanie C. Hicks; Keri Martinowich; Andrew E. Jaffe
errShare
errSave
SPIRAL: integrating and aligning spatially resolved transcriptomics data across different experiments, conditions, and technologies
err2023-10-20
err8
errOAAI
errGuo, Tiantian; Yuan, Zhiyuan; Pan, Yan; Wang, Jiakang; Chen, Fengling; Zhang, Michael Q.; Li, Xiangyu
errShare
errSave
Spatially resolved cell atlas of the mouse primary motor cortex by MERFISH
err2021-10-06
err0
errOAAI
errMeng Zhang; Stephen W. Eichhorn; Brian Zingg; Zizhen Yao; Kaelan Cotter; Hongkui Zeng; Hongwei Dong; Xiaowei Zhuang
errShare
errSave
Spatial CRISPR genomics identifies regulators of the tumor microenvironment
errCell
IF0
err2022-03-01
err0
errOAAI
errMaxime Dhainaut; Samuel A. Rose; Guray Akturk; Aleksandra Wroblewska; Sebastian R. Nielsen; Eun Sook Park; Mark Buckup; Vladimir Roudko; Luisanna Pia; Robert Sweeney; Jessica Le Berichel; C. Matthias Wilk; Anela Bektesevic; Brian H. Lee; Nina Bhardwaj; Adeeb H. Rahman; Alessia Baccarini; Sacha Gnjatic; Dana Pe’er; Miriam Merad; Brian D. Brown
errShare
errSave
Expansion sequencing: Spatially precise in situ transcriptomics in intact biological systems
err2021-01-29
err0
errOAAI
errShahar Alon; Daniel R. Goodwin; Anubhav Sinha; Asmamaw T. Wassie; Fei Chen; Evan R. Daugharthy; Yosuke Bando; Atsushi Kajita; Andrew G. Xue; Karl Marrett; Robert Prior; Yi Cui; Andrew C. Payne; Chun-Chen Yao; Ho-Jun Suk; Ru Wang; Chih-Chieh (Jay) Yu; Paul Tillberg; Paul Reginato; Nikita Pak; Songlei Liu; Sukanya Punthambaker; Eswar P. R. Iyer; Richie E. Kohman; Jeremy A. Miller; Ed S. Lein; Ana Lako; Nicole Cullen; Scott Rodig; Karla Helvie; Daniel L. Abravanel; Nikhil Wagle; Bruce E. Johnson; Johanna Klughammer; Michal Slyper; Julia Waldman; Judit Jané-Valbuena; Orit Rozenblatt-Rosen; Aviv Regev; George M. Church; Adam H. Marblestone; Edward S. Boyden; H. R. Ali; M. Al Sa’d; S. Alon; S. Aparicio; G. Battistoni; S. Balasubramanian; R. Becker; B. Bodenmiller; E. S. Boyden; D. Bressan; A. Bruna; Marcel Burger; C. Caldas; M. Callari; I. G. Cannell; H. Casbolt; N. Chornay; Y. Cui; A. Dariush; K. Dinh; A. Emenari; Y. Eyal-Lubling; J. Fan; A. Fatemi; E. Fisher; E. A. González-Solares; C. González-Fernández; D. Goodwin; W. Greenwood; F. Grimaldi; G. J. Hannon; O. Harris; S. Harris; C. Jauset; J. A. Joyce; E. D. Karagiannis; T. Kovačević; L. Kuett; R. Kunes; A. Küpcü Yoldaş; D. Lai; E. Laks; H. Lee; M. Lee; G. Lerda; Y. Li; A. McPherson; N. Millar; C. M. Mulvey; F. Nugent; C. H. O'Flanagan; M. Paez-Ribes; I. Pearsall; F. Qosaj; A. J. Roth; O. M. Rueda; T. Ruiz; K. Sawicka; L. A. Sepúlveda; S. P. Shah; A. Shea; A. Sinha; A. Smith; S. Tavaré; S. Tietscher; I. Vázquez-García; S. L. Vogl; N. A. Walton; A. T. Wassie; S. S. Watson; J. Weselak; S. A. Wild; E. Williams; J. Windhager; T. Whitmarsh; C. Xia; P. Zheng; X. Zhuang
errShare
errSave
Slide-seq: A scalable technology for measuring genome-wide expression at high spatial resolution
err2019-03-29
err0
errOAAI
errSamuel G. Rodriques; Robert R. Stickels; Aleksandrina Goeva; Carly A. Martin; Evan Murray; Charles R. Vanderburg; Joshua Welch; Linlin M. Chen; Fei Chen; Evan Z. Macosko
errShare
errSave
Spatial deconvolution of HER2-positive breast cancer delineates tumor-associated cell type interactions
err2021-10-14
err158
errOAAI
errAndersson, Alma; Larsson, Ludvig; Stenbeck, Linnea; Salmen, Fredrik; Ehinger, Anna; Wu, Sunny Z.; Al-Eryani, Ghamdan; Roden, Daniel; Swarbrick, Alex; Borg, Ake; Frisen, Jonas; Engblom, Camilla; Lundeberg, Joakim
errShare
errSave
Spatially informed clustering, integration, and deconvolution of spatial transcriptomics with GraphST
err2023-03-01
err115
errOAAI
errLong, Yahui; Ang, Kok Siong; Li, Mengwei; Chong, Kian Long Kelvin; Sethi, Raman; Zhong, Chengwei; Xu, Hang; Ong, Zhiwei; Sachaphibulkij, Karishma; Chen, Ao; Zeng, Li; Fu, Huazhu; Wu, Min; Lim, Lina Hsiu Kim; Liu, Longqi; Chen, Jinmiao
errShare
errSave
err
IF0
err
err0
PREAI
err
errShare
errSave
Spatiotemporal transcriptomic atlas of mouse organogenesis using DNA nanoball-patterned arrays
errCell
IF0
err2022-05-01
err0
errOAAI
errAo Chen; Sha Liao; Mengnan Cheng; Kailong Ma; Liang Wu; Yiwei Lai; Xiaojie Qiu; Jin Yang; Jiangshan Xu; Shijie Hao; Xin Wang; Huifang Lu; Xi Chen; Xing Liu; Xin Huang; Zhao Li; Yan Hong; Yujia Jiang; Jian Peng; Shuai Liu; Mengzhe Shen; Chuanyu Liu; Quanshui Li; Yue Yuan; Xiaoyu Wei; Huiwen Zheng; Weimin Feng; Zhifeng Wang; Yang Liu; Zhaohui Wang; Yunzhi Yang; Haitao Xiang; Lei Han; Baoming Qin; Pengcheng Guo; Guangyao Lai; Pura Muñoz-Cánoves; Patrick H. Maxwell; Jean Paul Thiery; Qing-Feng Wu; Fuxiang Zhao; Bichao Chen; Mei Li; Xi Dai; Shuai Wang; Haoyan Kuang; Junhou Hui; Liqun Wang; Ji-Feng Fei; Ou Wang; Xiaofeng Wei; Haorong Lu; Bo Wang; Shiping Liu; Ying Gu; Ming Ni; Wenwei Zhang; Feng Mu; Ye Yin; Huanming Yang; Michael Lisby; Richard J. Cornall; Jan Mulder; Mathias Uhlén; Miguel A. Esteban; Yuxiang Li; Longqi Liu; Xun Xu; Jian Wang
errShare
errSave
researcher View more