arrow
Return

Automated multi-objective reaction optimisation: which algorithm should I use?

delete2022-01-01
delete29
delete
OA
AI
P
Pia Mueller
A
Adam D. Clayton
J
Jamie A. Manson
S
Samuel Riley
O
Oliver May
N
Norman Govan
S
Stuart Notman
S
Steven V. Ley
T
Thomas W. Chamberlain
R
Richard A. Bourne *
DOI:10.1039/d1re00549adelete
deleteOriginal
deleteOriginal request for help
deleteShare
deleteSave
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
Multi-objective optimisation algorithms (MOOAs) are, of increasing interest for the efficient optimisation of chemical processes. However, an algorithm's performance can vary on a case-by-case basis, depending on the complexity of the search space and the nature of the underlying response surfaces. This makes appropriate algorithm selection for chemical reaction optimisation a challenging problem. An open-source reaction simulator has been developed, which enables the performance of multi-objective algorithms to be benchmarked against a series of chemistry-inspired test problems. The performance of four different MOOAs were compared, including three state-of-the-art Bayesian optimisation algorithms, and their ability to optimise different types of systems quantified using the hypervolume metric. In general, EIMEGO was found to achieve the highest hypervolume in the lowest number of experiments and was only outperformed by TSEMO in cases with three objectives. To verify the simulated results, EIMEGO and TSEMO were tested experimentally using a three-objective optimisation of methyl phenyl sulfide oxidation. Both algorithms successfully identified a trade-off between conversion, selectivity, and productivity with respect to the desired sulfoxide. In this case, TSEMO outperformed EIMEGO in terms of hypervolume, which was in agreement with the simulated results.
Keywords:
SOLVENT-FREE
OXIDATION
SULFIDES
EFFICIENT
PLATFORM
SULFONES
BATCH

Journal

Reaction Chemistry and Engineering cover
Reaction Chemistry and Engineering
IF:
3.1
Papers:
1.9K
Citations:
5.0K

Organization

D
defence science and technology laboratory
Scholars:
720
Papers: 619
Citations: 4
U
University of Cambridge
Scholars:
7.7W
Papers: 7.1W
Citations: 13.7W
U
university of leeds
Scholars:
3.5W
Papers: 3.3W
Citations: 45
researcher View more organizations