arrow
Return

Benchmarking differential expression, imputation and quantification methods for proteomics data

delete2022-04-10
delete14
PRE
AI
M
Miao‐Hsia Lin
P
Pei‐Shan Wu
T
Tzu-Hsuan Wong
I
I‐Ying Lin
J
Johnathan Lin
J
Jürgen Cox
S
Sung‐Huan Yu *
DOI:10.1093/bib/bbac138delete
deleteOriginal
deleteOriginal request for help
deleteShare
deleteSave
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
Data analysis is a critical part of quantitative proteomics studies in interpreting biological questions. Numerous computational tools for protein quantification, imputation and differential expression (DE) analysis were generated in the past decade and the search for optimal tools is still going on. Moreover, due to the rapid development of RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) technology, a vast number of DE analysis methods were created for that purpose. The applicability of these newly developed RNA-seq-oriented tools to proteomics data remains in doubt. In order to benchmark these analysis methods, a proteomics dataset consisting of proteins derived from humans, yeast and drosophila, in defined ratios, was generated in this study. Based on this dataset, DE analysis tools, including microarray-and RNA-seq-based ones, imputation algorithms and protein quantification methods were compared and benchmarked. Furthermore, applying these approaches to two public datasets showed that RNA-seq-based DE tools achieved higher accuracy (ACC) in identifying DEPs. This study provides useful guidelines for analyzing quantitative proteomics datasets. All the methods used in this study were integrated into the Perseus software, version 2.0.3.0, which is available at https://www.maxquant.org/perseus.
Keywords:
differential expression
proteomics
benchmark data
imputation
matching between runs

Journal

Briefings in Bioinformatics cover
Briefings in Bioinformatics
IF:
7.7
Papers:
5.8K
Citations:
2.7W

Organization

N
National Taiwan University
Scholars:
4.7W
Papers: 4.2W
Citations: 3.6W
N
national sun yat sen university
Scholars:
7.6K
Papers: 7.7K
Citations: 3
M
Max Planck Society
Scholars:
8.2W
Papers: 7.7W
Citations: 3.3W
researcher View more organizations
Cited Papers

Cited Papers

Neural Stem Cells (NSCs) and Proteomics
err2016-02-01
err36
errOAAI
errShoemaker, Lorelei D.; Kornblum, Harley I.
errShare
errSave
DEqMS: A Method for Accurate Variance Estimation in Differential Protein Expression Analysis
err2020-06-01
err132
errOAAI
errZhu, Yafeng; Orre, Lukas M.; Tran, Yan Zhou; Mermelekas, Georgios; Johansson, Henrik J.; Malyutina, Alina; Anders, Simon; Lehtio, Janne
errShare
errSave
Less label, more free: Approaches in label-free quantitative mass spectrometry
err2011-01-17
err661
errOAAI
errNeilson, Karlie A.; Ali, Naveid A.; Muralidharan, Sridevi; Mirzaei, Mehdi; Mariani, Michael; Assadourian, Garine; Lee, Albert; van Sluyter, Steven C.; Haynes, Paul A.
errShare
errSave
The MaxQuant computational platform for mass spectrometry-based shotgun proteomics
err2016-10-27
err3.1K
PREAI
errTyanova, Stefka; Temu, Tikira; Cox, Juergen
errShare
errSave
Empirical Bayesian Random Censoring Threshold Model Improves Detection of Differentially Abundant Proteins
err2014-08-22
err21
errOAAI
errKoopmans, Frank; Cornelisse, L. Niels; Heskes, Tom; Dijkstra, Tjeerd M. H.
errShare
errSave
Optimization of Statistical Methods Impact on Quantitative Proteomics Data
err2015-09-08
err63
errOAAI
errPursiheimo, Anna; Vehmas, Anni P.; Afzal, Saira; Suomi, Tomi; Chand, Thaman; Strauss, Leena; Poutanen, Matti; Rokka, Anne; Corthals, Garry L.; Elo, Laura L.
errShare
errSave
TeStor: Deriving Test Sequences from Model-Based Specifications
err2005-01-01
err0
PREAI
errPatrizio Pelliccione; Henry Muccini; Antonio Bucchiarone; Fabrizio Facchini
errShare
errSave
DeMix-Q: Quantification-Centered Data Processing Workflow
err2016-04-01
err62
errOAAI
errZhang, Bo; Kall, Lukas; Zubarev, Roman A.
errShare
errSave
researcher View more