arrow
Return

Data Challenges for Externally Controlled Trials: Viewpoint

delete2023-04-05
delete5
delete
OA
AI
R
Russanthy Velummailum
C
Chelsea McKibbon
D
Darren M. Brenner
E
ELIZABETH A. STRINGER
L
Leeland Ekstrom
L
Louis Dron *
DOI:10.2196/43484delete
deleteOriginal
deleteOriginal request for help
deleteShare
deleteSave
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
The preferred evidence of a large randomized controlled trial is difficult to adopt in scenarios, such as rare conditions or clinical subgroups with high unmet needs, and evidence from external sources, including real-world data, is being increasingly considered by decision makers. Real-world data originate from many sources, and identifying suitable real-world data that can be used to contextualize a single-arm trial, as an external control arm, has several challenges. In this viewpoint article, we provide an overview of the technical challenges raised by regulatory and health reimbursement agencies when evaluating comparative efficacy, such as identification, outcome, and time selection challenges. By breaking down these challenges, we provide practical solutions for researchers to consider through the approaches of detailed planning, collection, and record linkage to analyze external data for comparative efficacy.
Keywords:
external control arm
synthetic control arm
single-arm trial
real-world evidence
regulatory approval
data
clinical
decision-making
efficacy
rare conditions
trial

Journal

Journal of Medical Internet Research cover
Journal of Medical Internet Research
IF:
6
Papers:
9.7K
Citations:
5.0W

Organization

C
Cytel
Scholars:
257
Papers: 164
Citations: 0
U
University of Calgary
Scholars:
3.8W
Papers: 3.3W
Citations: 52
C
cytel canada
Scholars:
37
Papers: 24
Citations: 0
researcher View more organizations
Cited Papers

Cited Papers

Boundary organizations in regime complexes: a social network profile of IPBES
err2016-07-26
err0
PREAI
errJean-Frédéric Morin; Sélim Louafi; Amandine Orsini; Mohamed Oubenal
errShare
errSave
The external validity of published randomized controlled trials in primary care
err2009-01-19
err34
errOAAI
errJones, Ritu; Jones, Robert O.; McCowan, Colin; Montgomery, Alan A.; Fahey, Tom
errShare
errSave
errShare
errSave
Understanding Use of Real-World Data and Real-World Evidence to Support Regulatory Decisions on Medical Product Effectiveness
err2021-07-02
err40
PREAI
errMahendraratnam, Nirosha; Mercon, Kerra; Gill, Mira; Benzing, Laura; McClellan, Mark B.
errShare
errSave
A call for an integrated approach to improve efficiency, equity and sustainability in rare disease research in the United States
err2022-03-07
err18
errOAAI
errHalley, Meghan C.; Smith, Hadley Stevens; Ashley, Euan A.; Goldenberg, Aaron J.; Tabor, Holly K.
errShare
errSave
Generating Real-World Tumor Burden Endpoints from Electronic Health Record Data: Comparison of RECIST, Radiology-Anchored, and Clinician-Anchored Approaches for Abstracting Real-World Progression in Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer
err2019-05-28
err125
errOAAI
errGriffith, Sandra D.; Tucker, Melisa; Bowser, Bryan; Calkins, Geoffrey; Chang, Che-hsu (Joe); Guardino, Ellie; Khozin, Sean; Kraut, Josh; You, Paul; Schrag, Deb; Miksad, Rebecca A.
errShare
errSave
A Fan-Shaped Axillopectoral Muscle
err2009-11-01
err0
PREAI
errChay-You Ang; Siew-Weng Ng; Bien-Keem Tan
errShare
errSave
researcher View more