arrow
Return

Evaluating deep learning for predicting epigenomic profiles

delete2022-12-05
delete23
delete
OA
AI
S
Shushan Toneyan
Z
Ziqi Tang
P
Peter K. Koo *
DOI:10.1038/s42256-022-00570-9delete
deleteOriginal
deleteOriginal request for help
deleteShare
deleteSave
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
Deep learning has been successful at predicting epigenomic profiles from DNA sequences. Most approaches frame this task as a binary classification relying on peak callers to define functional activity. Recently, quantitative models have emerged to directly predict the experimental coverage values as a regression. As new models with different architectures and training configurations continue to emerge, a major bottleneck is forming due to the lack of ability to fairly assess the novelty of proposed models and their utility for downstream biological discovery. Here we introduce a unified evaluation framework and use it to compare various binary and quantitative models trained to predict chromatin accessibility data. We highlight various modelling choices that affect generalization performance, including a downstream application of predicting variant effects. In addition, we introduce a robustness metric that can be used to enhance model selection and improve variant effect predictions. Our empirical study largely supports that quantitative modelling of epigenomic profiles leads to better generalizability and interpretability.
Keywords:
TRANSCRIPTION FACTOR-BINDING

Journal

Nature Machine Intelligence cover
Nature Machine Intelligence
IF:
23.9
Papers:
1.3K
Citations:
1.5W

Organization

C
Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory
Scholars:
2.8K
Papers: 1.7K
Citations: 7.2K
Cited Papers

Cited Papers

Evaluating the informativeness of deep learning annotations for human complex diseases
err2020-09-17
err16
errOAAI
errDey, Kushal K.; van de Geijn, Bryce; Kim, Samuel Sungil; Hormozdiari, Farhad; Kelley, David R.; Price, Alkes L.
errShare
errSave
Introduction to OPTICAL METROLOGY
err
IF0
err2017-07-12
err0
PREAI
errRajpal S. Sirohi
errShare
errSave
Unraveling determinants of transcription factor binding outside the core binding site
err2015-03-11
err133
errOAAI
errLevo, Michal; Zalckvar, Einat; Sharon, Eilon; Machado, Ana Carolina Dantas; Kalma, Yael; Lotam-Pompan, Maya; Weinberger, Adina; Yakhini, Zohar; Rohs, Remo; Segal, Eran
errShare
errSave
Genome-wide association study implicates novel loci and reveals candidate effector genes for longitudinal pediatric bone accrual
err2021-01-04
err16
errOAAI
errCousminer, Diana L.; Wagley, Yadav; Pippin, James A.; Elhakeem, Ahmed; Way, Gregory P.; Pahl, Matthew C.; McCormack, Shana E.; Chesi, Alessandra; Mitchell, Jonathan A.; Kindler, Joseph M.; Baird, Denis; Hartley, April; Howe, Laura; Kalkwarf, Heidi J.; Lappe, Joan M.; Lu, Sumei; Leonard, Michelle E.; Johnson, Matthew E.; Hakonarson, Hakon; Gilsanz, Vicente; Shepherd, John A.; Oberfield, Sharon E.; Greene, Casey S.; Kelly, Andrea; Lawlor, Deborah A.; Voight, Benjamin F.; Wells, Andrew D.; Zemel, Babette S.; Hankenson, Kurt D.; Grant, Struan F. A.
errShare
errSave
Quantifying similarity between motifs
err2007-02-26
err1.6K
errOAAI
errGupta, Shobhit; Stamatoyannopoulos, John A.; Bailey, Timothy L.; Noble, William Stafford
errShare
errSave
Integration of multiple epigenomic marks improves prediction of variant impact in saturation mutagenesis reporter assay
err2019-09-01
err43
errOAAI
errShigaki, Dustin; Adato, Orit; Adhikari, Aashish N.; Dong, Shengcheng; Hawkins-Hooker, Alex; Inoue, Fumitaka; Juven-Gershon, Tamar; Kenlay, Henry; Martin, Beth; Patra, Ayoti; Penzar, Dmitry D.; Schubach, Max; Xiong, Chenling; Yan, Zhongxia; Boyle, Alan P.; Kreimer, Anat; Kulakoyskiy, Ivan, V; Reid, John; Unger, Ron; Yosef, Nir; Shendure, Jay; Ahituv, Nadav; Kirche, Martin; Beer, Michael A.
errShare
errSave
Deep learning of immune cell differentiation
err2020-09-25
err57
errOAAI
errMaslova, Alexandra; Ramirez, Ricardo N.; Ma, Ke; Schmutz, Hugo; Wang, Chendi; Fox, Curtis; Ng, Bernard; Benoist, Christophe; Mostafavi, Sara; Project, Immunological Genome
errShare
errSave
researcher View more