arrow
Return

Benchmarking deep learning methods for biologically conserved single-cell integration

delete2025-11-22
delete0
delete
OA
AI
C
Chenxin Yi
J
Jinyu Cheng
J
Jiajun Chen
W
Wanquan Liu *
J
Junwei Liu
李
李逸平 (Yixue Li)
DOI:10.1186/s13059-025-03869-zdelete
deleteOriginal
deleteShare
deleteSave
View PDF
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
Advancements in single-cell RNA sequencing have enabled the analysis of millions of cells, but integrating such data across samples and methods while mitigating batch effects remains challenging. Deep learning approaches address this by learning biologically conserved gene expression representations, yet systematic benchmarking of loss functions and integration performance is lacking. We evaluate 16 integration methods using a unified variational autoencoder framework, incorporating batch and cell-type information. Results reveal limitations in the single-cell integration benchmarking index (scIB) for preserving intra-cell-type information. To address this, we introduce a correlation-based loss function and enhance benchmarking metrics to better capture biological conservation. Using cell annotations from lung and breast atlases, our approach improves biological signal preservation. We propose a refined integration framework, scIB-E, and metrics that provide deeper insights into the integration process and offer guidance for advanced developments in integrating increasingly complex single-cell data. This benchmark highlights the potential of deep learning-based approaches for single-cell data integration, emphasizing the importance of biologically informed metrics and improved benchmarking strategies.
Keywords:
Single-cell RNA sequencing
Data integration
Deep learning
Batch correction
Biological conservation

Journal

G
Genome Biology
IF:
9.4
Papers:
6.4K
Citations:
7.3W

Organization

S
sun yat-sen university
Scholars:
1.9W
Papers: 6.4K
Citations: 14
G
guangzhou national laboratory
Scholars:
538
Papers: 204
Citations: 0
Cited Papers

Cited Papers

Isolating salient variations of interest in single-cell data with contrastiveVI
err2023-08-07
err3
PREAI
errWeinberger, Ethan; Lin, Chris; Lee, Su-In
errShare
errSave
Benchmarking single-cell RNA-sequencing protocols for cell atlas projects
err2020-04-06
err293
errOAAI
errMereu, Elisabetta; Lafzi, Atefeh; Moutinho, Catia; Ziegenhain, Christoph; McCarthy, Davis J.; Alvarez-Varela, Adrian; Batlle, Eduard; Sagar; Gruen, Dominic; Lau, Julia K.; Boutet, Stephane C.; Sanada, Chad; Ooi, Aik; Jones, Robert C.; Kaihara, Kelly; Brampton, Chris; Talaga, Yasha; Sasagawa, Yohei; Tanaka, Kaori; Hayashi, Tetsutaro; Braeuning, Caroline; Fischer, Cornelius; Sauers, Sascha; Trefzer, Timo; Conrad, Christian; Adiconis, Xian; Nguyen, Lan T.; Regev, Aviv; Levin, Joshua Z.; Parekh, Swati; Janjic, Aleksandar; Wange, Lucas E.; Bagnoli, Johannes W.; Enard, Wolfgang; Gut, Marta; Sandberg, Rickard; Nikaido, Itoshi; Gut, Ivo; Stegle, Oliver; Heyn, Holger
errShare
errSave
Benchmarking multi-omics integration algorithms across single-cell RNA and ATAC data
err2024-03-16
err3
errOAAI
errXiao, Chuxi; Chen, Yixin; Meng, Qiuchen; Wei, Lei; Zhang, Xuegong
errShare
errSave
BBKNN: fast batch alignment of single cell transcriptomes
err2019-08-10
err0
errOAAI
errKrzysztof Polański; Matthew D Young; Zhichao Miao; Kerstin B Meyer; Sarah A Teichmann; Jong-Eun Park
errShare
errSave
The Human Cell Atlas
err2017-12-05
err0
errOAAI
errAviv Regev; Sarah A Teichmann; Eric S Lander; Ido Amit; Christophe Benoist; Ewan Birney; Bernd Bodenmiller; Peter Campbell; Piero Carninci; Menna Clatworthy; Hans Clevers; Bart Deplancke; Ian Dunham; James Eberwine; Roland Eils; Wolfgang Enard; Andrew Farmer; Lars Fugger; Berthold Göttgens; Nir Hacohen; Muzlifah Haniffa; Martin Hemberg; Seung Kim; Paul Klenerman; Arnold Kriegstein; Ed Lein; Sten Linnarsson; Emma Lundberg; Joakim Lundeberg; Partha Majumder; John C Marioni; Miriam Merad; Musa Mhlanga; Martijn Nawijn; Mihai Netea; Garry Nolan; Dana Pe'er; Anthony Phillipakis; Chris P Ponting; Stephen Quake; Wolf Reik; Orit Rozenblatt-Rosen; Joshua Sanes; Rahul Satija; Ton N Schumacher; Alex Shalek; Ehud Shapiro; Padmanee Sharma; Jay W Shin; Oliver Stegle; Michael Stratton; Michael J T Stubbington; Fabian J Theis; Matthias Uhlen; Alexander van Oudenaarden; Allon Wagner; Fiona Watt; Jonathan Weissman; Barbara Wold; Ramnik Xavier; Nir Yosef
errShare
errSave
Comprehensive Integration of Single-Cell Data
errCell
IF0
err2019-06-01
err0
errOAAI
errTim Stuart; Andrew Butler; Paul Hoffman; Christoph Hafemeister; Efthymia Papalexi; William M. Mauck; Yuhan Hao; Marlon Stoeckius; Peter Smibert; Rahul Satija
errShare
errSave
Integrating single-cell transcriptomic data across different conditions, technologies, and species
err2018-04-02
err7.4K
errOAAI
errButler, Andrew; Hoffman, Paul; Smibert, Peter; Papalexi, Efthymia; Satija, Rahul
errShare
errSave
A single-cell atlas enables mapping of homeostatic cellular shifts in the adult human breast
err2024-03-28
err0
errOAAI
errAustin D. Reed; Sara Pensa; Adi Steif; Jack Stenning; Daniel J. Kunz; Linsey J. Porter; Kui Hua; Peng He; Alecia-Jane Twigger; Abigail J. Q. Siu; Katarzyna Kania; Rachel Barrow-McGee; Iain Goulding; Jennifer J. Gomm; Valerie Speirs; J Louise Jones; John C. Marioni; Walid T. Khaled
errShare
errSave
errShare
errSave
researcher View more