arrow
Return

Benchmarking segmentation methods for spatial transcriptomics

delete2026-10-23
delete0
delete
OA
AI
X
Xabier Martinez‐de‐Morentin *
S
Sumeer A. Khan
A
Alberto Maillo
R
Robert Lehmann
N
Narsis A. Kiani
V
Vincenzo Lagani
D
David Gómez-Cabrero *
J
Jesper Tegnér *
DOI:10.1038/s41592-026-03272-xdelete
deleteOriginal
deleteShare
deleteSave
View PDF
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
Cell segmentation is a critical yet under-standardized step in spatial transcriptomics, directly affecting cell identity assignment, spatial organization and downstream biological interpretation. Despite rapid advances in spatial transcriptomics technologies, systematic evaluations of segmentation methods across platforms and biological contexts remain limited. Here we benchmark 11 image-based, transcriptomics-based and multimodal segmentation methods across 15 datasets generated by 5 spatial transcriptomics technologies, spanning 12 human and mouse tissue types. We introduce biologically informed evaluation metrics that quantify segmentation quality, transcript recovery, cell composition, morphology, expression purity and spatial organization. Benchmarking reveals substantial variation in performance across datasets, technologies and evaluation criteria, highlighting trade-offs among segmentation completeness, transcriptomic fidelity and biological interpretability. Cross-technology analyses further demonstrate that segmentation choice critically shapes downstream analyses, including cell-type specificity, transcript contamination and ligand–receptor inference. Together, our unified Nextflow pipeline provides a scalable foundation for standardized evaluation of segmentation and method selection in spatial transcriptomics. This Analysis benchmarks segmentation methods across different datasets and presents Nextflow, a pipeline for standardized method selection for spatial transcriptomics.
AI Summary

AI Summary

Key information extracted from the uploaded paper, including a brief overview, abstract, background, key highlights, visual analysis, and future outlook.

Journal

Nature Methods cover
Nature Methods
IF:
32.1
Papers:
7.3K
Citations:
12.7W

Organization

K
Karolinska Institute
Scholars:
96
Papers: 51
Citations: 0
K
King Abdullah University of Science and Technology
Scholars:
529
Papers: 195
Citations: 0
Cited Papers

Cited Papers

Sopa: a technology-invariant pipeline for analyses of image-based spatial omics
err2024-06-11
err4
errOAAI
errBlampey, Quentin; Mulder, Kevin; Gardet, Margaux; Christodoulidis, Stergios; Dutertre, Charles-Antoine; Andre, Fabrice; Ginhoux, Florent; Cournede, Paul-Henry
errShare
errSave
A single-cell and spatially resolved atlas of human breast cancers
err2021-09-06
err628
errOAAI
errWu, Sunny Z.; Al-Eryani, Ghamdan; Roden, Daniel Lee; Junankar, Simon; Harvey, Kate; Andersson, Alma; Thennavan, Aatish; Wang, Chenfei; Torpy, James R.; Bartonicek, Nenad; Wang, Taopeng; Larsson, Ludvig; Kaczorowski, Dominik; Weisenfeld, Neil, I; Uytingco, Cedric R.; Chew, Jennifer G.; Bent, Zachary W.; Chan, Chia-Ling; Gnanasambandapillai, Vikkitharan; Dutertre, Charles-Antoine; Gluch, Laurence; Hui, Mun N.; Beith, Jane; Parker, Andrew; Robbins, Elizabeth; Segara, Davendra; Cooper, Caroline; Mak, Cindy; Chan, Belinda; Warrier, Sanjay; Ginhoux, Florent; Millar, Ewan; Powell, Joseph E.; Williams, Stephen R.; Liu, X. Shirley; O'Toole, Sandra; Lim, Elgene; Lundeberg, Joakim; Perou, Charles M.; Swarbrick, Alexander
errShare
errSave
VIP interneurons in mouse primary visual cortex selectively enhance responses to weak but specific stimuli
err2020-10-27
err46
errOAAI
errMillman, Daniel J.; Ocker, Gabriel Koch; Caldejon, Shiella; Kato, India; Larkin, Josh D.; Lee, Eric Kenji; Luviano, Jennifer; Nayan, Chelsea; Nguyen, Thuyanh V.; North, Kat; Seid, Sam; White, Cassandra; Lecoq, Jerome; Reid, Clay; Buice, Michael A.; de Vries, Saskia E. J.
errShare
errSave
Spatially resolved cell atlas of the mouse primary motor cortex by MERFISH
err2021-10-06
err0
errOAAI
errMeng Zhang; Stephen W. Eichhorn; Brian Zingg; Zizhen Yao; Kaelan Cotter; Hongkui Zeng; Hongwei Dong; Xiaowei Zhuang
errShare
errSave
The single-cell transcriptional landscape of mammalian organogenesis
err2019-02-20
err0
errOAAI
errJunyue Cao; Malte Spielmann; Xiaojie Qiu; Xingfan Huang; Daniel M. Ibrahim; Andrew J. Hill; Fan Zhang; Stefan Mundlos; Lena Christiansen; Frank J. Steemers; Cole Trapnell; Jay Shendure
errShare
errSave
SpaDecon: cell-type deconvolution in spatial transcriptomics with semi-supervised learning
err2023-04-07
err11
errOAAI
errColeman, Kyle; Hu, Jian; Schroeder, Amelia; Lee, Edward B.; Li, Mingyao
errShare
errSave
errShare
errSave
Squidpy: a scalable framework for spatial omics analysis
err2022-01-31
err293
errOAAI
errPalla, Giovanni; Spitzer, Hannah; Klein, Michal; Fischer, David; Schaar, Anna Christina; Kuemmerle, Louis Benedikt; Rybakov, Sergei; Ibarra, Ignacio L.; Holmberg, Olle; Virshup, Isaac; Lotfollahi, Mohammad; Richter, Sabrina; Theis, Fabian J.
errShare
errSave
Sulfatase 2 promotes generation of a spinal cord astrocyte subtype that stands out through the expression of Olig2
errGLIA
IF5.1
err2019-04-13
err15
errOAAI
errOhayon, David; Escalas, Nathalie; Cochard, Philippe; Glise, Bruno; Danesin, Cathy; Soula, Cathy
errShare
errSave
researcher View more