arrow
Return

Benchmarking single-cell multi-modal data integrations

delete2025-07-10
delete0
PRE
AI
傅沙镠 cover
傅沙镠 (Shaliu Fu)
S
Shu-Guang Wang
D
Duanmiao Si
G
Gaoyang Li
高亚威 cover
高亚威 (Yawei Gao)
刘琦 cover
刘琦 (Qi Liu) *
DOI:10.1038/s41592-025-02737-9delete
deleteOriginal
deleteOriginal request for help
deleteShare
deleteSave
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
Recent advances have enabled the generation of both unpaired (separate profiling) and paired (simultaneous measurement) single-cell multi-modal datasets, driving rapid development of single-cell multi-modal integration tools. Nevertheless, there is a pressing need for a comprehensive benchmark to assess algorithms under varying integrated dataset types, integrated modalities, dataset sizes and data quality. Here we present a systematic benchmark for 40 single-cell multi-modal integration algorithms involving modalities of DNA, RNA, protein and spatial omics for paired, unpaired and mosaic datasets (a mixture of paired and unpaired datasets). We evaluated usability, accuracy and robustness to assist researchers in selecting suitable integration methods tailored to their datasets and applications. Our benchmark provides valuable guidance in the ever-evolving field of single-cell multi-omics. This Registered Report presents a comprehensive benchmarking analysis of single-cell multi-modal data-integration methods.

Journal

Nature Methods cover
Nature Methods
IF:
32.1
Papers:
7.2K
Citations:
12.7W

Organization

S
School of Life Sciences and Technology
Scholars:
205
Papers: 53
Citations: 0
Cited Papers

Cited Papers

Identifying temporal and spatial patterns of variation from multimodal data using MEFISTO
err2022-01-13
err64
errOAAI
errVelten, Britta; Braunger, Jana M.; Argelaguet, Ricard; Arnol, Damien; Wirbel, Jakob; Bredikhin, Danila; Zeller, Georg; Stegle, Oliver
errShare
errSave
Stabilized mosaic single-cell data integration using unshared features
err2023-05-25
err30
errOAAI
errGhazanfar, Shila; Guibentif, Carolina; Marioni, John C. C.
errShare
errSave
Bi-order multimodal integration of single-cell data
err2022-05-09
err21
errOAAI
errDou, Jinzhuang; Liang, Shaoheng; Mohanty, Vakul; Miao, Qi; Huang, Yuefan; Liang, Qingnan; Cheng, Xuesen; Kim, Sangbae; Choi, Jongsu; Li, Yumei; Li, Li; Daher, May; Basar, Rafet; Rezvani, Katayoun; Chen, Rui; Chen, Ken
errShare
errSave
Mosaic integration and knowledge transfer of single-cell multimodal data with MIDAS
err2024-01-23
err9
errOAAI
errHe, Zhen; Hu, Shuofeng; Chen, Yaowen; An, Sijing; Zhou, Jiahao; Liu, Runyan; Shi, Junfeng; Wang, Jing; Dong, Guohua; Shi, Jinhui; Zhao, Jiaxin; Ou-Yang, Le; Zhu, Yuan; Bo, Xiaochen; Ying, Xiaomin
errShare
errSave
A deep generative model for multi-view profiling of single-cell RNA-seq and ATAC-seq data
err2022-01-12
err36
errOAAI
errLi, Gaoyang; Fu, Shaliu; Wang, Shuguang; Zhu, Chenyu; Duan, Bin; Tang, Chen; Chen, Xiaohan; Chuai, Guohui; Wang, Ping; Liu, Qi
errShare
errSave
Spatial epigenome–transcriptome co-profiling of mammalian tissues
err2023-03-15
err0
errOAAI
errDi Zhang; Yanxiang Deng; Petra Kukanja; Eneritz Agirre; Marek Bartosovic; Mingze Dong; Cong Ma; Sai Ma; Graham Su; Shuozhen Bao; Yang Liu; Yang Xiao; Gorazd B. Rosoklija; Andrew J. Dwork; J. John Mann; Kam W. Leong; Maura Boldrini; Liya Wang; Maximilian Haeussler; Benjamin J. Raphael; Yuval Kluger; Gonçalo Castelo-Branco; Rong Fan
errShare
errSave
Comprehensive Integration of Single-Cell Data
errCell
IF0
err2019-06-01
err0
errOAAI
errTim Stuart; Andrew Butler; Paul Hoffman; Christoph Hafemeister; Efthymia Papalexi; William M. Mauck; Yuhan Hao; Marlon Stoeckius; Peter Smibert; Rahul Satija
errShare
errSave
MultiMAP: dimensionality reduction and integration of multimodal data
err2021-12-20
err37
errOAAI
errJain, Mika Sarkin; Polanski, Krzysztof; Conde, Cecilia Dominguez; Chen, Xi; Park, Jongeun; Mamanova, Lira; Knights, Andrew; Botting, Rachel A.; Stephenson, Emily; Haniffa, Muzlifah; Lamacraft, Austen; Efremova, Mirjana; Teichmann, Sarah A.
errShare
errSave
Joint probabilistic modeling of single-cell multi-omic data with totalVI
err2021-02-15
err223
errOAAI
errGayoso, Adam; Steier, Zoe; Lopez, Romain; Regier, Jeffrey; Nazor, Kristopher L.; Streets, Aaron; Yosef, Nir
errShare
errSave
researcher View more