arrow
Return

Proof constructions and evaluations

delete2009-03-06
delete67
PRE
AI
A
Andreas J. Stylianides *
G
Gabriel J. Stylianides
DOI:10.1007/s10649-009-9191-3delete
deleteOriginal
deleteOriginal request for help
deleteShare
deleteSave
Abstract

Abstract

En 中文
In this article, we focus on a group of 39 prospective elementary (grades K-6) teachers who had rich experiences with proof, and we examine their ability to construct proofs and evaluate their own constructions. We claim that the combined construction-evaluation activity helps illuminate certain aspects of prospective teachers' and presumably other individuals' understanding of proof that tend to defy scrutiny when individuals are asked to evaluate given arguments. For example, some prospective teachers in our study provided empirical arguments to mathematical statements, while being aware that their constructions were invalid. Thus, although these constructions considered alone could have been taken as evidence of an empirical conception of proof, the additional consideration of prospective teachers' evaluations of their own constructions overruled this interpretation and suggested a good understanding of the distinction between proofs and empirical arguments. We offer a possible account of our findings, and we discuss implications for research and instruction.
Keywords:
Logic
Mathematical reasoning
Proof
Proof construction
Teacher education
Teacher knowledge

Journal

Educational Studies in Mathematics cover
Educational Studies in Mathematics
IF:
1.9
Papers:
1.5K
Citations:
3.8K

Organization

U
University of Cambridge
Scholars:
7.7W
Papers: 7.1W
Citations: 13.7W
P
pennsylvania commonwealth system of higher education (pcshe)
Scholars:
12.9W
Papers: 11.7W
Citations: 177
Cited Papers

Cited Papers

errShare
errSave
Mathematics for teaching: A form of applied mathematics
err2010-02-01
err40
PREAI
errStylianides, Gabriel J.; Stylianides, Andreas J.
errShare
errSave
Moustached Brushfinch (Atlapetes albofrenatus)
err2020-03-19
err0
PREAI
errAlvaro Jaramillo; Josep del Hoyo; Nigel Collar; Guy M. Kirwan
errShare
errSave
A New Zn(II) Azido Complex of L-Arginine: X-ray Crystal Structure, Hirshfeld, and AIM Studies
err2023-09-14
err0
errOAAI
errMezna Saleh Altowyan; Amal Yousri; Jörg H. Albering; Roland C. Fischer; Morsy A. M. Abu-Youssef; Mohammed Salah Ayoup; Assem Barakat; Saied M. Soliman
errShare
errSave
errShare
errSave
researcher View more